We've played OK. Always winning this game anyway. Nice pen from RvP.
Manchester United vs. Crystal Palace
- Thread starter Damien
- Start date
- Status
Your the only one showing himself to be one today.
But other than that...
Young as his uses.
It was a clear red if it was a foul. Goalscoring chance.
Hang on, people don't think that was a red? If you think it's a penalty, or could be a penalty, then surely you understand that it has to be a red too? There's little leeway here. If you deny a clear goalscoring opportunity, which he certainly was if you assume that it was a foul in the first place (which I do), then it's a red. Whether or not he breaks is leg or "merely" brings him down without getting the ball in the process is frankly irrelevant.
Perfect time to get Fellaini on now.
That we don't create much even with lots of possession.
It was another dive from Young.
Decent first half, the wingers need to put better crosses in though, but for one Young cross towards Rooney neither of them seem to be picking out anyone and just floating a cross inside, they need to do more then that. Can see why it was a red but always think those ones are slightly harsh. Hopefully can wrap it up quickly after half time and get RVP rested and give Januzaj and Zaha some time.
Get a grip. Hate really?
Valencia and Anderson are the two players that should be replaced.
i was afraid for a moment young would get a red card .
Looks like Holloway will be getting a further 6 match touchline ban after this game then.
Why is it a crime to dislike a United player?
I agree he is playing well, I just dont like the diving he needs to cut it out.
What will the former Leeds United manager Neil Warnock say now?
Like the other games so far this season, we're dominating and looking comfortable but for the most part creating next to nothing. Things improved in the final 10 minutes of the half, and we got the goal but I'm still slightly concerned at the lack of chances we're creating.
This is a great chance to get some goals and give Zaha + Januzaj some game time. Hopefully a couple of early goals in the 2nd half and those 2 can come on. Would also like to see Hernandez given some game time.
This is a great chance to get some goals and give Zaha + Januzaj some game time. Hopefully a couple of early goals in the 2nd half and those 2 can come on. Would also like to see Hernandez given some game time.
Red card - yes. Pen - no. Take it - yes. Impressed by performance - no.
I'm not sure but I thought I saw another defender close to young. Like I said, could be wrong. Just saw it once.
Certainly a foul. and also a red.. Young was through on goal. Without that foul, he would've had a clear goal scoring opportunity.
Will probably need a slow mo to be sure if it was inside the box or not..
The Young yellow was annoying. he needs to stop doing that
Will probably need a slow mo to be sure if it was inside the box or not..
The Young yellow was annoying. he needs to stop doing that
Clear foul and sending off. Haven't seen a replay that shows whether or not it was in the box though.
It was a clear red card. Not sure about the penalty.
The performance has been okayish. Got better in the last fifteen minutes.
The performance has been okayish. Got better in the last fifteen minutes.
Mate if it was on RVP they'd all say it was a red. The amount of shite we used to talk about Ronaldo going down easily to justify it and now Young does it people are debating whether it should be a straight red.
Young is a decent squad player who broke down this team. Still no-one says anything.
It's getting beyond a joke now.
Funny thing is if it was the reverse situation and Ferdinand took down Gayle for example he'd be calling the ref an idiot and Ferdinand a hero.
Carrick/Anderson does not work.
Lets just ignore the good play to get into the position then yeah?
I'd like to see that replay again, first view was Young was going down before the Palace player made contact, but may have just been a bad angle. We dominated, created very little. Young was one the whole awful, but he at least kept going. Valencia is out of the game completely, I really don't like our tactics though, we're pumping it wide and throwing in the crosses. That didn't work against Chelsea and it didn't work in this half. The Rooney cross was sublime, but that was on the break.
There's been a few situations where we asked for a penalty, surely the ref feels he has to give it sooner or later.
Broke down this team by going down easily outside the box. Thanks, I'll pass.
Carrick's passing has been well off to be fair. Given it away a lot.
Yeah same here. Our final ball has been poor, and strangely most of our attacking play is going through the left. Valencia and Fabio have been mainly non-existent.
Would the Palace lad have been sent off if Anderson did not remind the ref that it was a goal scoring chance?
You actually want him to play badly. That's going beyond stupid.
Imo he should have been sent off
The performance hasnt been bad at all. It hasn't been stellar.. but how many stellar performances do we get a season anyway? We've been dominant.. and very often, in games like these, we break the team down in the second half.. So to complain about the performance is pointless.
He's just following the rules of the game, get a grip.
we have all seen pen like that before and there was no red given, but I do agree with you point.
- Status