Andersons Dietician
Full Member
- Joined
- Jun 14, 2016
- Messages
- 13,578
Alright let’s forget a comparison to AWB for a second because they’re in different leagues. You just pulled out a negative for AWB and at worst he still nullified any threat from any opposition we have played so far. Toss in the fact that if Jesse wasn’t as useless as he is, AWB would have 2 direct assists vs Wolves. To really put it to bed - AWB had 9 successful tackles to Shaw’s 2 vs wolves. So AWB aside - it’s back to the main point. Why are you accepting how mediocre Shaw is? I understand we can’t do anything about it but how can you be satisfied with the contributions when he can’t even keep it up past 60 minutes? Never mind his non existent attacking contributions - why do we have to look at what happened to him and our team when Adama came on and think to our selves ‘yea that’s all we could do, we go again next game, Shaw is still decent’? It just feels like I’m reading a mid table forum being satisfied with mediocre players.
Unfortunately like kouroux was saying - we can’t really do anything about it so I guess we agree to disagree
You’re saying he his mediocre. Many are saying he isn’t. So many don’t see it as accepting anything.
Harry Maguire made 1 tackle, Victor 3. Luke Shaw won 4 headers, Harry Maguire 6 Bissaka 0
Luke Shaw also had the highest key passes in the game and made more crosses.
That pass was great but I imagine the deflection wouldn’t have given it as an assist even if Lingard had managed to adjust.
I would say Shaw’s work in our build up and approach was far superior not to mention there were more good runs than just the one for Martials goal. There was a run he made that had breached the backline just Pogbas pass to him was cut out. Then he got in position to put in some crosses.
I think he is a good player and he can improve aspects of his game but personally I think his football IQ, first touch, and passing is far superior currently.
He had a good game, honestly don’t really get where all the hate is coming from for that performance.
Last edited: