The problem isn't being credited for playing well. The problem, which I thought I pointed out quite nicely, is the abuse thrown at a player when he isn't playing well and how quickly it changes after a few good matches. In the pre-season, he was a miserable professional thats let himself go, fat and useless, refusing to piss off from the club because he enjoys the wages too much, will never get a good contract again, how stupid is he to think that someone will sign him considering how unprofessional he is. 3 matches into the first season and suddenly him staying shows that he's got balls, that he's willing to prove himself shows his strong mentality to be a winner, and surprise surprise he still looks the same but he's no longer fat.
The amount of hyperbole makes it difficult to have a sensible debate regarding every player, because the general attitude goes from hell to heaven, or heaven to hell..Last season the general impression was that Lukaku was one of the best strikers in the league, maybe even in Europe, and that his injury towards the end of the season and how we played afterwards just proves how crucial and underrated he is. Thank god he returned early from vacation. 3 matches into the season and the general impression is that he's, well, shite and hopefully not at the club next season.
It's absurd.