Summit
"do the dead, spread your seed and get out"
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2011
- Messages
- 51,051
Ah this is the guyGoretzka has been a Bayern fan and still is..he will join Bayern! Deal done and dusted since summer.
Ah this is the guyGoretzka has been a Bayern fan and still is..he will join Bayern! Deal done and dusted since summer.
Not yet, the guy breaking the news is a radio host from Catalunya.Any other credible links?
Wont be surprised if he goes Barca, but would have liked us to try at least
Some muppets need to be more skeptical. This is obviously not true.
he was the one talking senseCalm it down, only one talking like a muppet is you
Keep in mind guys that today is "April's fool" day in Spain. So any news coming from Spain today may be a joke.
he was the one talking sense
Interesting. What's the history of fooling on 28th Dec?
It´s the day Real and Barca traditionally do their taxes.
It´s the day Real and Barca traditionally do their taxes.
he was the one talking sense
take your own adviceBy calling people muppets?
Seriously?
How dare a legitimate transfer story be questioned. Isnt that the point of the forum?
take your own advice
Yeah. Original tweeter probably realised it was a windup (said that Barcelona had beaten Bayern to Goretzka but it is "Innocent's Day" in Spain today which is their version of April Fools)Is the tweet deleted?
Liverpool meaning business.BILD today reports a strong push for him from Klopp, and since they've just now even quickly mustered their sports editor-in-chief to write an opinion piece admonishing Goretzka to think long and hard, as a 'decision for Liverpool would mean a decision against major trophies within the foreseeable future', and that 'Liverpool surely would go out of CL against Bayern', I have to assume that the threat of him turning down Bayern for Liverpool is serious.
http://www.bild.de/sport/fussball/m...tzka-jetzt-bedenken-sollte-54323188.bild.html
Liverpool meaning business.
GK
Defence
Keïta
Goretzka Lemar
Salah Firmino Mané
Is a mean front six.
Keita makes no sense as a deep lying player though. That's what's strange about the Goretzka interest. Too many similar players, or at least players occupying similar spaces. Wijnaldum, Keita, Lallana, Ox, and then Goretzka? Meanwhile Henderson ...Liverpool meaning business.
GK
Defence
Keïta
Goretzka Lemar
Salah Firmino Mané
Is a mean front six.
Liverpool meaning business.
GK
Defence
Keïta
Goretzka Lemar
Salah Firmino Mané
Is a mean front six.
I think Lemar would be in the front 3 with Keita as a box to box along with Goretzka, not sure who their holder would be though as Can is likely off and Henderson isn't good enough.
Yeah, I know he's not a defensive midfielder but like you say they're all similar players and can't see where they'd all fit. Maybe 4231 with both Keita and Goretzka sharing some of the defensive responsibilities? There's some reason Goretzka continues to be linked and no defensive midfielder. Either way, the three of them would be an upgrade on Wijnaldum and Henderson.Keita makes no sense as a deep lying player though. That's what's strange about the Goretzka interest. Too many similar players, or at least players occupying similar spaces. Wijnaldum, Keita, Lallana, Ox, and then Goretzka? Meanwhile Henderson ...
Yeah, I know he's not a defensive midfielder but like you say they're all similar players and can't see where they'd all fit. Maybe 4231 with both Keita and Goretzka sharing some of the defensive responsibilities? There's some reason Goretzka continues to be linked and no defensive midfielder. Either way, the three of them would be an upgrade on Wijnaldum and Henderson.
Who do you think Lemar would replace in the front three Dmc?
Yeah, I know he's not a defensive midfielder but like you say they're all similar players and can't see where they'd all fit. Maybe 4231 with both Keita and Goretzka sharing some of the defensive responsibilities? There's some reason Goretzka continues to be linked and no defensive midfielder. Either way, the three of them would be an upgrade on Wijnaldum and Henderson.
Who do you think Lemar would replace in the front three Dmc?
They just spent 75m on Van Dijk. I doubt they'll spend 90 odd on Lemar.
They would if they're selling Coutinho. Lemar is more fitting for the Coutinho replacement than Goretzka.They just spent 75m on Van Dijk. I doubt they'll spend 90 odd on Lemar. Goretzka would be replacement for Can and Coutinho if they are interested. Would love Goretzka to come to United though.
Yeah that is what I was thinking. Decent point about the competition with Mané - we've seen Coutinho at times play instead of Mané and also at number 10 with the others around him so maybe that could be the case with Lemar too.Goretzka and Keita does seem like overkill but could also be very dynamic if they get a holder as well, I'm not sure they are cut out to be a partnership as they are too similar. My guess is that if they get Goretzka they will probably move more to a 4-3-3 and perhaps Lemar wont be bought.
If he is bought though I think Lemar would compete with Mane for the left, Salah is undroppable for them and I can't see Lemar or Mane in the central role Firmino plays.
He's been linked to them constantly since last summer but Monaco were pretty firm that they weren't going to sell at the time. The Monaco VP has also said this:Have I missed something re Liverpool and Lemar? He’s a player I’d love here, think he can have a similar impact to Coutinho for us.
“It is difficult to keep them (star players)” he said, “of course Monaco is a great club and it’s an historic club in France (with) amazing success but we cannot compare ourselves with the likes of Real Madrid or (the) Manchesters, United or City. We are not in the same league.”
“So we understand that at a certain stage, the players want – once they get offers – to play at big clubs, they want to play in front of big clubs and we have to let them go at the right time.”
“(But) When is the right time? This is the tricky point.”
He's been linked to them constantly since last summer but Monaco were pretty firm that they weren't going to sell at the time. The Monaco VP has also said this:
So sounds like he'll be gone at the end of the season.
Yeah that is what I was thinking. Decent point about the competition with Mané - we've seen Coutinho at times play instead of Mané and also at number 10 with the others around him so maybe that could be the case with Lemar too.
Liverpool meaning business.
GK
Defence
Keïta
Goretzka Lemar
Salah Firmino Mané
Is a mean front six.
I doubt they get Goretzka or Lemar. Isn't Goretzka all but done to Bayern anyway?
He's already said he wants it settled in January. That's reason enough.Obviously it isn't. Goretzka is a smart guy, he can choose the club of his liking, and pretty much dictate his wage demands as a free agent.
Still, I have my doubts about Liverpool being the top contender to land him. From a legal standpoint he's free to sign any contract from Jan, 1st on. There's zero reason for a pre-contract agreement, if he had made his mind up for Liverpool already. So if I were to guess, this is probably negotiation tactics to up the pressure on those clubs who he might want to join for real.
I think we get lemar if and when Coutinho goes.I doubt they get Goretzka or Lemar. Isn't Goretzka all but done to Bayern anyway?