Fluctuation0161
Full Member
Not his usual United self but not sure how he gets picked out for his performance or the Iceland goal (think the RB was on the halfway line)
Useless media.
Not his usual United self but not sure how he gets picked out for his performance or the Iceland goal (think the RB was on the halfway line)
Saying he "lacks nous" means he permanently lacks that trait. Its absolute bullshit. Maybe he lacked a little in that game, but he has demonstrated plenty of nous.I think it's more ridiculous how some people can't handle criticism of United players by journalists, and label it as hate, like it's some personal attack on the lad when it isn't
The media hate is ridiculous.
“Kobbie can you do your best to not hit women ?” It wouldn’t be great for your careerNot that there's a whiff of a problem yet, but someone needs to make sure that what happened to Marcus Rashford and Mason Greenwood does not happen to Kobbie Mainoo. The boy needs to be looked after.
Not his usual United self but not sure how he gets picked out for his performance or the Iceland goal (think the RB was on the halfway line)
Fair assessment of the performance last night.
He's a young player and is still learning, not sure what people are expecting?!
Fair assessment of the performance last night.
He's a young player and is still learning, not sure what people are expecting?!
Saying he "lacks nous" means he permanently lacks that trait. Its absolute bullshit. Maybe he lacked a little in that game, but he has demonstrated plenty of nous.
Journalists an absolute waste of space.
He's the type of player that would be the first name on the team sheet if he was Spanish or Portuguese. But for some reason, these type of players always seem to be a problem for England.He isn't strong defensively, in my opinion. If England fans, journalists or Southgate had watched him for season they would see that is his weakness and opposition coaches try to exploit it.
He did fine against City because of how compact we were as a unit, but when we try to play on the front foot, we were exploited similarly (not just because of Mainoo). The problem is, this shows that even with a great partner like Rice, it's still unbalanced. And we were hoping a signing like Rice would be the key for us.
I think he's a great young player with bags of talent, but tactically we (United) might need to make some provisions for him.
I don’t think he’s weak defensively, he just lacks running power. Rice was awful last night btw, he was far more culpable than Mainoo.He isn't strong defensively, in my opinion. If England fans, journalists or Southgate had watched him for season they would see that is his weakness and opposition coaches try to exploit it.
He did fine against City because of how compact we were as a unit, but when we try to play on the front foot, we were exploited similarly (not just because of Mainoo). The problem is, this shows that even with a great partner like Rice, it's still unbalanced. And we were hoping a signing like Rice would be the key for us.
I think he's a great young player with bags of talent, but tactically we (United) might need to make some provisions for him.
I’d agree with this. I do think for England there’s balance to be found in a Rice, Mainoo, Bellingham midfield but it relies on good tactics (which we won’t get under Southgate). Fundamentally my issue with this current England squad and the reason I don’t buy the hype is that we don’t actually have a balanced team. It’s full of fantastic individuals doing great things at club level, but there are very few relationships on the pitch. There’s no surprise that we did our best work in the last few tournaments with some existing relationships (Rashford-Shaw, Maguire-Stones, Walker-Sterling etc). I don’t think he’s picked a very well balanced squad which I expect will lead to huge disappointment.Mainoo has mostly played in flashes this season, incredibly promising flashes but he hasn't really been a constant factor in games. Expecting him to go and control games as a starter in the Euros is putting too much on him at this stage. Ideally he would be a back up getting the experience of a major tournament with the expectation that he is fully integrated by the time the WC rolls around, but the problem is the alternatives aren't great, Gallagher is a workhorse with technical deficiencies, Wharton is another kid, Bellingham is better higher up, Trent is erratic in that role.
Really hope this tournament doesn't negatively impact Mainoo's development.
Mainoo has mostly played in flashes this season, incredibly promising flashes but he hasn't really been a constant factor in games. Expecting him to go and control games as a starter in the Euros is putting too much on him at this stage. Ideally he would be a back up getting the experience of a major tournament with the expectation that he is fully integrated by the time the WC rolls around, but the problem is the alternatives aren't great, Gallagher is a workhorse with technical deficiencies, Wharton is another kid, Bellingham is better higher up, Trent is erratic in that role.
Really hope this tournament doesn't negatively impact Mainoo's development.
I missed most the game but if the pair started it wouldn't surprise me if Southgate threw mainoo in a 6 for bants.Hang on, isn’t Rice supposed to be a 6? Why on earth would Mainoo, who has never been classed as a 6, be the one who’s position is being questioned. Rice is supposed to be the more defensive of the 2. Typical anti united media soon again yeah. Morons the lot of them
I missed most the game but if the pair started it wouldn't surprise me if Southgate threw mainoo in a 6 for bants.
To break it down, the back 4 were all over the place, not even close to being in line with each other. Rice was out of position meaning Kobbie (more noticeably) had to chase their player back. Stones didn’t put a foot in and let the attacker shoot through his legs, Ramsdale let a saveable shot go in at the near post. Also if Kane and Palmer score easy chances then this goal wouldn’t be highlighted. That result is on Southgate. Nobody else.
Think I agree with this, hoping I’m wrong but feel like this England side is a little overrated and won’t win the entire thing!England's chance was a few tournaments ago, what they have now is a inflated opinion of themselves because Bellingham is doing stuff in Madrid.
Last night Foden/Rice/Kane did nothing of note, yet it's Saka and Mainoo (on his 2nd appearance) that gets the stick? Classic over-reaction from the media as per fecking usual.
It was a boring friendly and means feck all.
the defence isn't good enoughThink I agree with this, hoping I’m wrong but feel like this England side is a little overrated and won’t win the entire thing!
Think I agree with this, hoping I’m wrong but feel like this England side is a little overrated and won’t win the entire thing!
Yup, ultimately that’s where we will fall down.the defence isn't good enough
Hope you’re wrong, and I think Southgate gets way more flack than he deserves, but he isn’t amazing by any means.With Southgate, they wont win anything anyway.
Yup, ultimately that’s where we will fall down.
Hope you’re wrong, and I think Southgate gets way more flack than he deserves, but he isn’t amazing by any means.
Jason Burt, is that you??Mainoo will become a wonderful player for England no doubt, but a natural number 6 in a double pivot he most definitely is not. He just doesn’t have the defensive mind set, and the sixth sense to sniff out danger. The way he let Iceland run straight through his channel for their goal was terrible, and it’s not like it came from broken play or a turnover, it was all there in front of him from a build up perspective. I’m not sure whether Gallagher would be better, or TAA or Wharton, or maybe Mainoo will take this on board that his primary role is not fancy one touch passing, but providing a shield for the defence on that side. Whatever happens though, every team in the tournament that will face England, will be watching the tape of an extremely limited Iceland play through England’s right sided midfield like it wasn’t even there, and they’ll be licking their collective lips at the thought.
Jason Burt, is that you??
I don’t know how anyone can watch that goal and go “yeah, that’s Mainoos fault”.
The Icelandic player with light hair is in his own box, several yards further back than Rice.. watch that lad and Rice, and say Rice wasn’t completely useless. Rice CAN clearly see what’s there, the lads right in front of him and runs past him, Rice moves a few yards.
Also watch Foden, not only does he dive in and get nowhere, that same player runs past Foden too who doesn’t follow him. That’s two England players who are yards from that lad and with a little run and a 1-2, he’s suddenly several yards past Rice AND Foden who have done the sum total of feck all.
That player doesn’t then skin Mainoo, he simply passes out wide where Stones is right by him… he’s Stones man but the best English CH allows this lad to cut in and shoot. Meanwhile Ramsdale gets done at his near post.
And it’s Mainoos fault?
I’d agree with this. I do think for England there’s balance to be found in a Rice, Mainoo, Bellingham midfield but it relies on good tactics (which we won’t get under Southgate). Fundamentally my issue with this current England squad and the reason I don’t buy the hype is that we don’t actually have a balanced team. It’s full of fantastic individuals doing great things at club level, but there are very few relationships on the pitch. There’s no surprise that we did our best work in the last few tournaments with some existing relationships (Rashford-Shaw, Maguire-Stones, Walker-Sterling etc). I don’t think he’s picked a very well balanced squad which I expect will lead to huge disappointment.
I don’t think he’s weak defensively, he just lacks running power. Rice was awful last night btw, he was far more culpable than Mainoo.
Positionally he is too. Teams focused on him by putting an extra man in the space behind him, knowing he would get pulled out of position and leave huge spaces. And like you said he lacks the pace to recover.
Exactly. Dont know what the fuss is about. I watched the full 90 and I thought he was fine. That's how he normally plays and I love it. When there are no options ahead, he recycles the ball and retains possession. If there are options, he takes the risk and passes it forward. It looks boring but that's what a central/defensive midfielder is supposed to look like. Retain possession and control tempo and take the odd risk when necessary.Looking at Kobbie's highlights seemed like he had a normal game for him.
Twitter is a cesspit:
"You know what you attempted to do" - Like it's some sort of Pre-meditated attack on a young lad, which it was not.