It seems like it indeed. And Jose has gone gung-ho recently and we are like Liverpool from the start of last season.
Jurgen Klopp Sack Watch
- Thread starter Samid
- Start date
It seems like it indeed. And Jose has gone gung-ho recently and we are like Liverpool from the start of last season.
That's not my point through. I don't think Liverpool have had trouble against defensive teams, either this season or last season. The issue has been against teams that press their midfield and don't allow them space in the middle, which is what Red Star did. They have no midfielder who is very comfortable in the ball and therefore they struggle to set up attacks.
Keita and Ox are two midfielders who can drive through pressure, rather than holding possession, but they are both injured.
It was a 3-1 loss.
This post should be pinned.
If you listened to Utd fans on here you would think Liverpool were playing like Brazil 70 this season.
That'll teach me to read results without my glasses on. Point still stands, losing away to the best team in the league isn't anything to be ashamed of.
If he takes Liverpool in the EL again, it will be his Sevilla moment. That, and not winning the league or any cups despite playing a brand of football which is less entertaining than previous seasons will imply a regression.
If for arguments sake Klopp doesn't win anything this season how much longer will it take for the fans to want a change of manager?
He's at a club that hasn't been used to winning anything for years so there won't be much problem. He's a perfect match for them. A loser managing losers.
Last edited:
Not winning anything won't be a factor.
However, should they fail to get out of their CL group and end up in a battle for top 4, questions will probably start being asked. Not enough to get rid of him I wouldn't have thought, but the pressure will be on next season.
Jürgen Flopp.
If he was a farmer he'd be Jurgen Cropp
Whats changed up front for Liverpool? Same players, same formation, different results.......
It surely can't all be down to Salah not working miracles any more?
They had the same pretty average midfield last year as well and that didn't seem to hold them back too much.
It surely can't all be down to Salah not working miracles any more?
They had the same pretty average midfield last year as well and that didn't seem to hold them back too much.
2017 wants its hot take back.
Same as Mourinho's results last year, it wasn't going to last. Once Coutinho went, Chamberlain was the only one who kept our midfield from being one-dimensional. When he got injured, it was basically running on fumes of confidence to see out the season.
Hopefully Keita will find his feet soon and take up the mantle of keeping the midfield from being too one-dimensional.
The proper solution is to get in a proper 10 though.
Despite the current problems you’d be hard pressed to find fans displeased with that outcome.
Despite the current problems you’d be hard pressed to find fans displeased with that outcome.
I disagree, after another year of failure or shall I say no silverware the Scousers will be rioting.
Depends if there's a better option available. No point going from being competitive but not winning anything, to not being competitive and not winning anything.
I wish United fans were more sensible like you. We have people pining for Eddie Howe and Ryan Giggs because they think attacking football is all you need and quality of coaching doesn't matter. Atleast people like Pochettino and Tuchel have shown to be competent at the highest level.
Exactly if we got rid of Klopp and you got rid of Mourinho, what top quality replacements are available? I can't see any. Both clubs need to back their manager financially and let the chips fall where they may
I’ll never subscribe to that theory, we’ve been in the doldrums for years prior to Klopps arrival, one magnificent season notwithstanding.
He’s made us competitive and relevant again. The next step is trophies of course, but I feel like demanding trophies is only something we can do once we’ve actually won a few.
We have one of the top managers in the world and we’d be fools to replace him, and FSG for all their faults wouldn’t do that. He’s perfect for them, he’s built the club exactly the way they wanted.
Klopp is the best Liverpool can get, there’s no way their fans or the club will want to get rid of him.
They might not win feck all under him but the fans enjoy being competitive again and despite Liverpool looking a bit crap this season, they are still the second or third best team in the league at the moment.
If Liverpool get rid of Klopp they will just go backwards.
He isn’t the type of manager who is best when things are demanded and expected of him. He’s best as the plucky underdog when the expectations are low.
He’s perfect for Liverpool and they are perfect for him. He wouldn’t be right for Man Utd because our fans want more, a top 4 finish isn’t enough when you’re a giant of a club. No real fan of Utd got excited about finishing second last season, it was dull and I couldn’t wait for season to finish.
Just being in the CL doesn’t excite me, it’s the kind of thing Spurs fans pine for. We want to win the CL and at least be runnning City to the last day of the season. You can stick your top 4 up your backside, I won’t remember that when I’m old and telling my kids about United. I will be telling them about Barcelona in 99, winning the league on a rainy afternoon away at Wigan in 08. They are memories, not finishing second or third because it’s financially fun.
Football fans are like fecking accountants now, it’s depressing. Look at posters like @GlastonSpur and a few others (not picking on you Glastonspurs, it’s just that you instantly spring to mind when I think about who posts a lot about budgets and finance related news). These posters spend so much time and energy posting about bank balances and balance sheets. It seems to all be about Top 4, Top 4, Top 4...
Right now Utd are a million miles away of where we should be which is why some of our fans want Jose out. It’s not that we’re spoilt, it’s because we should behave like a giant club. Bayern and Real Madrid don’t accept mediocrity, why should we?
Sorry for the rant but why do we (Liverpool fans and Utd) accept it? We are both behemoths in the football world, absolute giant clubs. Yet we look at 4th place like some kind of trophy now and it’s absurd.
They might not win feck all under him but the fans enjoy being competitive again and despite Liverpool looking a bit crap this season, they are still the second or third best team in the league at the moment.
If Liverpool get rid of Klopp they will just go backwards.
He isn’t the type of manager who is best when things are demanded and expected of him. He’s best as the plucky underdog when the expectations are low.
He’s perfect for Liverpool and they are perfect for him. He wouldn’t be right for Man Utd because our fans want more, a top 4 finish isn’t enough when you’re a giant of a club. No real fan of Utd got excited about finishing second last season, it was dull and I couldn’t wait for season to finish.
Just being in the CL doesn’t excite me, it’s the kind of thing Spurs fans pine for. We want to win the CL and at least be runnning City to the last day of the season. You can stick your top 4 up your backside, I won’t remember that when I’m old and telling my kids about United. I will be telling them about Barcelona in 99, winning the league on a rainy afternoon away at Wigan in 08. They are memories, not finishing second or third because it’s financially fun.
Football fans are like fecking accountants now, it’s depressing. Look at posters like @GlastonSpur and a few others (not picking on you Glastonspurs, it’s just that you instantly spring to mind when I think about who posts a lot about budgets and finance related news). These posters spend so much time and energy posting about bank balances and balance sheets. It seems to all be about Top 4, Top 4, Top 4...
Right now Utd are a million miles away of where we should be which is why some of our fans want Jose out. It’s not that we’re spoilt, it’s because we should behave like a giant club. Bayern and Real Madrid don’t accept mediocrity, why should we?
Sorry for the rant but why do we (Liverpool fans and Utd) accept it? We are both behemoths in the football world, absolute giant clubs. Yet we look at 4th place like some kind of trophy now and it’s absurd.
Last edited:
People talking about Klopp being sacked are mental to be honest.
There is nobody they would get who is better suited.
I don't see them winning a PL or CL under him as being in any way inevitable though, he's not going to build a dynasty in that way. I can see him at Liverpool for the next few years though. They'll probably roughly have the same strengths and weaknesses all the time with him. A bit like Wenger, it may get a bit stale and familiarity may start to build contempt in 3-4 more years but for now he's on a decent road with them and I think he can get some trophies somewhere along the line.
He'd be mad not to take the FA Cup this year seriously IMO.
There is nobody they would get who is better suited.
I don't see them winning a PL or CL under him as being in any way inevitable though, he's not going to build a dynasty in that way. I can see him at Liverpool for the next few years though. They'll probably roughly have the same strengths and weaknesses all the time with him. A bit like Wenger, it may get a bit stale and familiarity may start to build contempt in 3-4 more years but for now he's on a decent road with them and I think he can get some trophies somewhere along the line.
He'd be mad not to take the FA Cup this year seriously IMO.
When you say klopp has made you competitive, what do you define as competitive? Getting to a champions league final? Benitez got you to two in 3 years. Fighting for the title? Rodgers got you 2nd and still within a chance of winning it on the last day. The highest you have finished under klopp is 4th.
Liverpool fans have been brain washed so much by the media that klopp has invented the wheel. So the football is exciting and Klopp has a few beers and sings with you guys, but football under Evans and Rodgers was just as good as it is now. The difference is klopp acts exactly like a Liverpool supporter on the "terraces" and you lot get sucked into it big time.
They are used to not winning anything.
To be fair, Liverpool fans worshipped BR and RB as well. You’re barking up the wrong tree here.
They win the Alternate League Table every year.
Along with the hearts of the nation (apparently)
Can a loss be a win?
They've lost momentum some what.
Salah and Mane were ridiculously good last year and whatever they couldn't was finished by Firmino. So yes, the front 3 in normal form will affect the overall game now.
Added to that Salah had a great season last year.
When you have a player in such form the others dig in and try to be at the same level.
Benitez is rated by Liverpool fans but that was over 8 years ago when even getting in the Top 4 was almost a given for Us you Chelsea and Arsenal. We're not brainwashed at all anyone with half a brain can see how Klopp has transformed our squad in comparison to recent years. God forbid supporters actually support their manager and team.
You've had SAF for 26 years most United fans have only known success and they seem incapable of understanding managers like SAF don't grow on trees. You need to give your manager time and back him in the transfer market and see what happens.
There's been a general slump in performance levels at top clubs across Europe, excluding Man City. It's something that could perhaps be attributed to the World Cup.
Except that one-season wonder by Rodgers, we've had almost 10 years of 6th, 7th and 8th place finishes. I think it's very odd that you somehow don't remember this.
Klopp has given us two CL seasons in a row now, two European cup finals and pretty much every transfer he makes has been succesful. It's hardly being "brainwashed" to be happy about our situation.
Either that or City are drugging everyone else. Wouldn't put it past the dopers.
I'm with Can23 on this one. Of course Klopp has transformed them. It's not delusional to refer to themselves as competitive. And we have forgotten what an anomaly Fergie was.
Hey, we've been just as abject as we were before!
Tbh Klopp is doing a good job, he has got his team playing good football and addressed some of the weaknesses in the team from last season.
You must be forgetting the Asian Cup.
Liverpool played Red Star, but United played Juventus, that's the difference...
Sorry couldn't resist.
Sorry couldn't resist.