More useful than Hojlund right now , but that is not saying much , if we are honest neither of them would get a regular start in the vast majority of teams in the league , certainly none of the top half teams.
11
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 38
- Goals
- 5
- Assists
- 2
- Yellow cards
- 1
Not as a 9. He’s worse than useless up there.
Not good enough.
You have a short memory
Worst striker we've had. 40mill is absurd
After being everyone’s favourite player against Southampton he’s suddenly not good enough. Hmm.
Good first half, and then faded in the second. If he can do the simple hold-up play like he did before the break, then he should start. Højlund is delivering the opposite of that.
He needs to stop dribbling entirely though. Every time he either runs into a defender or is caught from behind.
He needs to stop dribbling entirely though. Every time he either runs into a defender or is caught from behind.
Amorim is poor to play a false 9 with bloody Bruno Fernandes.
Would he play Bruno Fernandes at LM/LW with Messi at a False 9? It was players like Henry and David Villa playing LW/LM not Iniesta.
I knew the game was lost from the starting tactics.
Would he play Bruno Fernandes at LM/LW with Messi at a False 9? It was players like Henry and David Villa playing LW/LM not Iniesta.
I knew the game was lost from the starting tactics.
his shooting technique in the box is weird he always seem to hit a player in front of him. Still less of a donkey than Hojlund.
He's frustrating. He had some useful moments in that first half when he held up the ball and did a great job to win the penalty. Aside from that, he doesn't offer much of a goal threat. The only way to really get the best out of him is to have pacey players next to and around him. I feel like both him and Hojlund are half-players and both combined would get us somewhere a little bit closer to a real player.
He has some skill but he isnt what we need. We needed a goal score and instead we spunk £40m on zirkzee.
Not his fault our forward line is dire. Bruno can maybe play as a left sided 10 but both he and Zirkzee need runners/wide forwards who can beat a man and we currently have no one except Amad who can do this. Also teams are getting wise to how good Amad is and beginning to overload that area.
Much better than hojlund.
Out of the 2 hojlund should be sold first.
Out of the 2 hojlund should be sold first.
His finishing is shite, but goodness gracious, he brings 10x more to the team than Hojlund.
Helps our team more than Hojlund does but is pretty average himself. Average PL striker compared to a championship level striker are our options right now
Nice link-up, some nice passing also. He's not pulling up any trees but he is involved in our attacks, something that Hojlund struggles with.
Played as well as you'd expect. Decent game by his standards but it's low bar as we've scrapping bottom of the barrel for all our performances.
Lacks the tenacity and intensity of our forwards of the past but he is technically a decent player.
Miles better than Hojlund and should stay in a team for a while, even though he is far from great solution himself. But at least technically he is on another level and can make his teammates look better.
Not as bad as the other option, but zero goal threat
Probably his best overall game for us. But, still nowhere near good enough. I’d have given the performance 5/10. Neat hold up play but zero goalscoring threat.
8/10 on the Zirkzee scale
5/10 on the Centre Forward for MUFC scale
8/10 on the Zirkzee scale
5/10 on the Centre Forward for MUFC scale
Good first half. Invisible in the second half. I do wonder if he is simply not fit enough for the league. For that reason alone I would keep him and get him properly fit for next season. Not a huge fan, but there is something there.
Brings more to the table than Hojlund but is basically zero attacking threat. I like his neat little one two stuff but then I get frustrated when he gets space to run into and he's just runs point blank into whoever he's supposed to be taking on.
If he plays for me he needs to be in on of the 10 roles behind an actual striker.
If he plays for me he needs to be in on of the 10 roles behind an actual striker.
Did you not know ? The longer a player doesn’t play , the better he getsYou have a short memory
If he scores v Rangers it’ll be ok again. Opinions on here are usually based on the last appearance
Didn’t see the game but heard he did alright. Hope he can build on it.
4 goals in 31 games though. We’re really struggling up front between him and Hojlund. In fairness 19 of those were sub appearances but still, not great.
4 goals in 31 games though. We’re really struggling up front between him and Hojlund. In fairness 19 of those were sub appearances but still, not great.
Whilst I don't think Zirkzee and Hojlund are playing to the required standard, it's hard to look past just how shocking we are in build up play, there's just nothing.
Yes that’s correct. It’s been noticeable for years that we depend more on the wingers to score as well. Now we’re playing a system that basically has no wide players.
Basically this, he offers something to the team while Hojlund offers nothing. Neither are good enough number 9s currently for us and the fact that they are our 2 options is utterly horrendous.
Even 4 in 12 is hardly great, our entire frontline at this point is probably being outscored in the league by Salah alone.
And 2 of those in a game where Rashford also scored 2 and most people here, and those at the club have decided he isnt good enough. Also in that game we had one of our only dominating performances against a team that were struggling.
On a normal day or season, his performance today would be a bad Martial game that people would be disappointed with. From what we’ve seen from him and our strikers this season, especially in recent weeks from Hojlund, this was a great performance.
That’s how bad the standards have been lowered.
You can see he’s talented but was the wrong profile for this team.
That’s how bad the standards have been lowered.
You can see he’s talented but was the wrong profile for this team.
All the foreplay, but no penetration.
It’s not about better or worse than Hojlund, they’re both not convincing but ultimately they’re very different players.
If we are spending a lot of time in the opposition half and controlling possession, then play Zirkzee. But when we’re being forced deep like we were today, we have one less runner on the break in the spaces that open up.
He individually did well today but it just meant that it was only Dalot making runs in behind. Garnacho coming one added an option but by then we were losing and Brighton had dropped back a bit.
Brighton had very little to worry about in general as they pressed us high.
If we are spending a lot of time in the opposition half and controlling possession, then play Zirkzee. But when we’re being forced deep like we were today, we have one less runner on the break in the spaces that open up.
He individually did well today but it just meant that it was only Dalot making runs in behind. Garnacho coming one added an option but by then we were losing and Brighton had dropped back a bit.
Brighton had very little to worry about in general as they pressed us high.
Trying to be the perfect fit in a dysfunctional team must be a nightmare.
But new signings should always get a year. So he did ok today. 5/10 which makes him one of the better ones in a red shirt.
But new signings should always get a year. So he did ok today. 5/10 which makes him one of the better ones in a red shirt.
He just needs runners man. Amad and Dalot were the only potential runners and every Dalot run ends in nothing anyways.
Also put a shock collar on him in training and buzz him every time he doesn’t shoot around the box. Just make him shoot
Also put a shock collar on him in training and buzz him every time he doesn’t shoot around the box. Just make him shoot
Problem is you can make the excuse for a load of our squad that they would be better with different players around them.
Thought he did well first half.....
Decent 1st half but we’ll be lucky to get anything more than 8-10 goals from him in a season. Add in our wing backs who haven’t scored all season along with Ugarte and Mainoo the team has far too many starting players that are not a goal scoring threat.
Last edited:
Todays first goal we conceded highlights the problem playing Zirkzee as a 9
Baleba got possession deep in Brightons half when he dropped into Brightons backline, Amorims instruction is for one of the wide centre halves to jump into midfield on Pedro which leaves a huge gap behind. Baleba puts the ball inside Mazraoui where De Light was previously covering and off Mitouma runs through on goal and centres for Minteh to score.
The whole shit show for that goal starts with Zirkzee who never bothered closing Baleba who had all the time in the world to pick that pass as well as De Light for continuing the jump when it was a long ball behind with zero pressure on the passer and Mazraoui going to sleep.
Its like playing an offside line how can you start that jump from defence when there is zero pressure being put on the passer of the ball.
Baleba got possession deep in Brightons half when he dropped into Brightons backline, Amorims instruction is for one of the wide centre halves to jump into midfield on Pedro which leaves a huge gap behind. Baleba puts the ball inside Mazraoui where De Light was previously covering and off Mitouma runs through on goal and centres for Minteh to score.
The whole shit show for that goal starts with Zirkzee who never bothered closing Baleba who had all the time in the world to pick that pass as well as De Light for continuing the jump when it was a long ball behind with zero pressure on the passer and Mazraoui going to sleep.
Its like playing an offside line how can you start that jump from defence when there is zero pressure being put on the passer of the ball.