James Rodriguez | joins Bayern Munich | 2 year loan

James Rodriguez - should we go for him?

  • Yes

    Votes: 404 34.6%
  • No

    Votes: 565 48.4%
  • I hate Silly Season

    Votes: 198 17.0%

  • Total voters
    1,167
Status
Not open for further replies.
If this go through, does that mean it's the end for Mata?
Last tweet looks promising, for us who think he'd be a great signing.
 
If this go through, does that mean it's the end for Mata?
Last tweet looks promising, for us who think he'd be a great signing.

I hope we sign him and keep Mata
 
I'd be over the moon with James signing, I wouldn't get rid of any of our attacking options. Rooney is clearly leaving so he can fill his squad role.
 
If this go through, does that mean it's the end for Mata?
Last tweet looks promising, for us who think he'd be a great signing.
When was the last time James played on the wing and when was the last time Mata played as a #10? Also James is no doubt a tidy player but it would mean Pogba playing in a 2 man central midfield.
 
When was the last time James played on the wing and when was the last time Mata played as a #10? Also James is no doubt a tidy player but it would mean Pogba playing in a 2 man central midfield.

Mata or Micky don't really play as RW, even if they start there in the lineup.
They drift in, while Valencia covers the wing aswell as the rb, I don't see why James can't play in that role.
 
It's got to the stage now (early June lol) that I'd now go for this. The idea of him and Morata might be good for us

--------------De Gea--------------
Valencia--Bailly--Rojo--Darmian
------Herrera------Pogba------
Mata---------James---------Mhkitaryan
--------------Morata--------------
 
It's got to the stage now (early June lol) that I'd now go for this. The idea of him and Morata might be good for us

--------------De Gea--------------
Valencia--Bailly--Rojo--Darmian
------Herrera------Pogba------
Mata---------James---------Mhkitaryan
--------------Morata--------------
Replace Mata with a good winger and that would be pretty tasty.
 
--------------------DDG
Valencia----Bailly-----New/Rojo--Shaw/Darmian
--------------Fabinho
---------Herrera-----Pogba
Valencia :lol:---James---Martial/new
------------Rashford/new


Valencia covers the entire right side, so we won't need, or buy, a proper old school rw, in my opinion.
 
Replace Mata with a good winger and that would be pretty tasty.

Darmain is hard to watch surely we are not going to be subjected to another season of watching him boot the ball anywhere.
 
Having a very good game vs Spain if anyone's interested in having a look.

Also, Morata should come on in the second half.
 
If this go through, does that mean it's the end for Mata?
Last tweet looks promising, for us who think he'd be a great signing.

Mata does not play as a no.10 under Moruinho.

James is replacing Rooney/Fellaini if he comes.
 
James Rodriguez - should we go for him?
  1. Yes
    347 vote(s)
    33.6%
  2. No
    513 vote(s)
    49.7%
I'm genuinely shocked half of you think we shouldn't buy James Rodriguez if we get the chance.

I just changed my vote to yes, at the time I voted no because I thought we were signing Griezmann but now going for James makes more sense.
 
From Guardian article today:

Madrid are also keen to sell James Rodríguez, with the Colombia forward thought to be available for around £60m, although there is less enthusiasm for that pursuit at Old Trafford.
 
He's a good player, and very good to watch. The trouble is he frequently disappears, an issue if you're playing him as a forward, a bigger issue if he's part of a 3 man midfield. He's also looked on the podgy side of fit for periods at Madrid. Maybe that's partly because he isn't a first choice at Madrid, certainly he usually looks good when he's playing for Colombia.
 
He's a good player, and very good to watch. The trouble is he frequently disappears, an issue if you're playing him as a forward, a bigger issue if he's part of a 3 man midfield. He's also looked on the podgy side of fit for periods at Madrid. Maybe that's partly because he isn't a first choice at Madrid, certainly he usually looks good when he's playing for Colombia.

Can't afford to have another attacker like that.
 
Don't think this is happening now. You'd imagine that if we intended to sign him, we'd be negotiating the deals for him and Morata simulatenously. So far, the majority of the reports have been regarding Morata and there's been virtually nothing concrete on James (as far as I know).
 
Hmmm, 17 goals and 18 assists in 2014/2015. If Mourinho can get him to produce even clos to these numbers, he will be a great signing for us. He also represents great value over Griezman, perhaps a better player for us as well.

Get him Ed!!!
 
Don't think this is happening now. You'd imagine that if we intended to sign him, we'd be negotiating the deals for him and Morata simulatenously. So far, the majority of the reports have been regarding Morata and there's been virtually nothing concrete on James (as far as I know).

Yeah, wouldn't disagree with that.
 
Don't think this is happening now. You'd imagine that if we intended to sign him, we'd be negotiating the deals for him and Morata simulatenously. So far, the majority of the reports have been regarding Morata and there's been virtually nothing concrete on James (as far as I know).

Spanish press is just an advertising venue for Perez. They NEED to sell Morata to make space for Mbappe.
 
If Griezmann is not coming he makes a lot of sense. Him Fabinho and Pogba will be a great core centrally.
 
Swung in the corner for colombias goal, Morata scored for spain too and DDG was not in goal in a 2-2 draw
 
I just changed my vote to yes, at the time I voted no because I thought we were signing Griezmann but now going for James makes more sense.

Oh, I didn't realize how long this had been up. It does make sense that people would be sceptical about him when it looked certain we would get Griezmann. Now, though, there should be no doubt.
 
If we could land James and Morata for 100m pounds would that be good business?

Replaces Ibra and rooney from a squad perspective, and gives us more options up front, and leaves some gun powder to address other positions over the summer
 
If we could land James and Morata for 100m pounds would that be good business?

Replaces Ibra and rooney from a squad perspective, and gives us more options up front, and leaves some gun powder to address other positions over the summer
You ain't getting them for £100M
 
James Rodriguez - should we go for him?
  1. Yes
    347 vote(s)
    33.6%
  2. No
    513 vote(s)
    49.7%
I'm genuinely shocked half of you think we shouldn't buy James Rodriguez if we get the chance.

I'am shocked the results off that poll don't add up to 100% :lol:
 
I don't want him at a no.10. I think I would prefer Mkhi as a No.10 and get quality wingers instead. If James can fulfill that role then great, but otherwise we should look elsewhere.

I'am shocked the results off that poll don't add up to 100% :lol:
There's a 3rd option he didn't include.
 
Its a pretty crazy world when Real Madrid are trying to sell two of their bench players for 140,000,000

Evra
Nani
Fletcher
Hernandez
Welbeck
30m

Without Welbeck its 14m
 
Its a pretty crazy world when Real Madrid are trying to sell two of their bench players for 140,000,000

Evra
Nani
Fletcher
Hernandez
Welbeck
30m

Without Welbeck its 14m

You can thank Moyes and LVG for their atrocious dealings in the transfer window. Both of them dont have a clue how to build a squad.
 
Its a pretty crazy world when Real Madrid are trying to sell two of their bench players for 140,000,000

Evra
Nani
Fletcher
Hernandez
Welbeck
30m

Without Welbeck its 14m
We did pretty good business on Depay and Schneiderlin, two players who weren't getting game time and surplus to requirements.

James and Morata are both young with bags of potential. They'd improve most teams but when you have as much talent as Madrid do then this happens. Its not like Madrid brought them in for pennies and sell on for much higher.
 
Actually getting a mupperection thinking about James and Morata. The two of those for 100m would be money well spent IMO.
 
It's got to the stage now (early June lol) that I'd now go for this. The idea of him and Morata might be good for us

--------------De Gea--------------
Valencia--Bailly--Rojo--Darmian
------Herrera------Pogba------
Mata---------James---------Mhkitaryan
--------------Morata--------------

I don't think Mata or Mkhitaryan are wingers tbh I think they're both better as a 10. But Mata in particular should not be on the wing it's not good enough. I'd rather be looking at this...

---------------De Gea----------------
Valencia--Bailly--Lindelof--Darmian
----------------Fabinho---------------
-----------Herrera---Pogba----------
Mkhitaryan-----Morata------Perisic

4 signings. No number 10, no Rodriguez.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.