krautrøck
Full Member
- Joined
- May 6, 2019
- Messages
- 1,083
- Supports
- FC Bayer 05 Uerdingen
Howard: "Nurse!"
Great post.I'd love for us to sign Sancho but it is worth remembering that United have missed out on lots of players in the past and it has mostly not stopped us being successful. It is also not really a reflection on Woodward or the current negotiation team. A lot of it is economics, politics, bureaucracy and what the player wants. Here are a few examples:
- Gascoigne [source]:
Paul Gascoigne has said one of the greatest regrets of his playing career was to have turned down Manchester United. On the other side of that coin, United's manager, Sir Alex Ferguson, has long maintained that "not getting Gazza" was the biggest disappointment of his managerial career. Gascoigne, 41, said he was shown around United's training ground as a young player but when he left Newcastle United in 1988 it was for Tottenham instead.
- Shearer [source]:
"I sat down with both Kevin Keegan and Sir Alex on the same day, in a house in Cheshire, believe it or not," said Shearer. "I spoke to Kevin Keegan in the morning, talks had gone really really well, very positive."....And Sir Alex's first question was 'am I seeing you first, or second?'. And I said I saw Kevin this morning, and he said 'basically I've got no chance, then'. In other words he wanted to see me first and he was disappointed he didn't do that. But I thought the talks went extremely well, I was really impressed with what he had to say." Shearer then revealed he made the demand about penalties, which was met with a stony-faced Ferguson.
- Ronaldinho [source]:
“I remember two or three that were possibly coming,” Scholes recalled on the BBC’s Savage Social podcast earlier this week. “I think the one that stands out is Ronaldinho. He was away on pre-season and we were as close as announcing him and giving him a number but I think he ended up changing his mind at the last minute and signing for Barcelona".
- Toni Kroos [source]:
"I knew before that Manchester wanted me," Kroos said. "And Moyes underlined that absolutely. It was a really nice afternoon with very nice people. We talked a lot about United's footballing plan which convinced me. In the end, we agreed to do it. We agreed verbally.".
- Fabregas [source]:
"After the week I had to take my chance, I had Manchester City, United and then I spoke to Mourinho – which I didn’t think would ever happen."
- Robben [source]:
"I had a very good conversation with him (Ferguson) over dinner in Manchester and we spoke about football and life. I also went and had a good look around the training ground and everything was good, but after I went back to PSV nothing happened. There was no real contact and the deal didn't happen....Had Manchester United offered me a deal straight after I met them, I would have signed there, but it didn't happen and I have got no regrets."
- Gareth Bale [source]:
And Ferguson claims that Bale would have been a United player in but for Southampton’s decision to reject their bid for the youngster in January 2007. “We were disappointed in Southampton at the time because we were first there, but they never came back to us,” Ferguson said. “It was not the boy who turned us down, it was Southampton, then a few weeks later he signed for Tottenham Hotspur".
- Sneijder [source]
On United's interest in his services, the Dutch playmaker told Galatasaray Dergisi: "We had some talks with Alex Ferguson back in 2010. "They [United] contacted the club after our Treble season but too much money was asked for. And I was also happy at Inter so I decided to stay. Manchester United are a fantastic club and they kept showing interest after that year but not as determined as before."
- Patrick Kluivert [source]:
"It won't be the last time this kind of thing happens but players we really want we usually get," Ferguson said. "We were led to believe he wanted to speak to us, but you know what agents are like. Maybe he doesn't know how big a club Manchester United is."
- Gary Lineker [source]:
"Right at the 11th hour it suddenly appeared that Spurs might not be able to do the deal, financially," his answer read. "That's when my agent spoke with Alex Ferguson, who was keen to take me to Old Trafford. "It was close to being done, but then Tottenham came back and said they could do it".
- Eden Hazard [source]:
“I had a chance to sign for Manchester United, Man City, Tottenham, but I made the right decision,”
- Lewandowski [source]:
Dortmund managed to keep Lewandowski for another two seasons, but he admits he was interested to move to Old Trafford after they Ferguson had shown interest. “I was speaking with him [Ferguson] after two years at Dortmund and at that time I was really thinking about a move to Manchester United,” Lewandowski told The Guardian. “Because of Ferguson and because of Manchester United. Borussia Dortmund said: ‘No, that’s that.’ That was the first time I was thinking about the move because if you get a phone call from Sir Alex Ferguson, for a young player it was something amazing. That was a special day for me.”
This is it. There's been a lot of chests puffed and bullishness in the media from Dortmund's side, yet none of it has been from Sancho. It would've been very easy for this to be put to bed by Sancho making a statement that he intends to stay. The fact we're getting all this bluster without any definitive statement would suggest Dortmund are either worried that he'll still go, or they have already accepted it and are just trying to squeeze out an extra few quid.
Regardless of anything else coming out. Anything from that Norwegian git Keane punched, from the italian on Twitter, anything from Zorc or Dorc or Bjork...
Ultimately if it's true that Sancho is the number 1 target and the one United are giving sole focus to and throwing everything behind, then it'll get done. Basically if they're going balls-deep for him. Not sure I personally buy that line, which is why I think next Summer is more likely. But if it is true then United will pay up by October 4th and he'll come.
The common denominator in that though? Sir Alex.I'd love for us to sign Sancho but it is worth remembering that United have missed out on lots of players in the past and it has mostly not stopped us being successful. It is also not really a reflection on Woodward or the current negotiation team. A lot of it is economics, politics, bureaucracy and what the player wants. Here are a few examples:
- Gascoigne [source]:
Paul Gascoigne has said one of the greatest regrets of his playing career was to have turned down Manchester United. On the other side of that coin, United's manager, Sir Alex Ferguson, has long maintained that "not getting Gazza" was the biggest disappointment of his managerial career. Gascoigne, 41, said he was shown around United's training ground as a young player but when he left Newcastle United in 1988 it was for Tottenham instead.
- Shearer [source]:
"I sat down with both Kevin Keegan and Sir Alex on the same day, in a house in Cheshire, believe it or not," said Shearer. "I spoke to Kevin Keegan in the morning, talks had gone really really well, very positive."....And Sir Alex's first question was 'am I seeing you first, or second?'. And I said I saw Kevin this morning, and he said 'basically I've got no chance, then'. In other words he wanted to see me first and he was disappointed he didn't do that. But I thought the talks went extremely well, I was really impressed with what he had to say." Shearer then revealed he made the demand about penalties, which was met with a stony-faced Ferguson.
- Ronaldinho [source]:
“I remember two or three that were possibly coming,” Scholes recalled on the BBC’s Savage Social podcast earlier this week. “I think the one that stands out is Ronaldinho. He was away on pre-season and we were as close as announcing him and giving him a number but I think he ended up changing his mind at the last minute and signing for Barcelona".
- Toni Kroos [source]:
"I knew before that Manchester wanted me," Kroos said. "And Moyes underlined that absolutely. It was a really nice afternoon with very nice people. We talked a lot about United's footballing plan which convinced me. In the end, we agreed to do it. We agreed verbally.".
- Fabregas [source]:
"After the week I had to take my chance, I had Manchester City, United and then I spoke to Mourinho – which I didn’t think would ever happen."
- Robben [source]:
"I had a very good conversation with him (Ferguson) over dinner in Manchester and we spoke about football and life. I also went and had a good look around the training ground and everything was good, but after I went back to PSV nothing happened. There was no real contact and the deal didn't happen....Had Manchester United offered me a deal straight after I met them, I would have signed there, but it didn't happen and I have got no regrets."
- Gareth Bale [source]:
And Ferguson claims that Bale would have been a United player in but for Southampton’s decision to reject their bid for the youngster in January 2007. “We were disappointed in Southampton at the time because we were first there, but they never came back to us,” Ferguson said. “It was not the boy who turned us down, it was Southampton, then a few weeks later he signed for Tottenham Hotspur".
- Sneijder [source]
On United's interest in his services, the Dutch playmaker told Galatasaray Dergisi: "We had some talks with Alex Ferguson back in 2010. "They [United] contacted the club after our Treble season but too much money was asked for. And I was also happy at Inter so I decided to stay. Manchester United are a fantastic club and they kept showing interest after that year but not as determined as before."
- Patrick Kluivert [source]:
"It won't be the last time this kind of thing happens but players we really want we usually get," Ferguson said. "We were led to believe he wanted to speak to us, but you know what agents are like. Maybe he doesn't know how big a club Manchester United is."
- Gary Lineker [source]:
"Right at the 11th hour it suddenly appeared that Spurs might not be able to do the deal, financially," his answer read. "That's when my agent spoke with Alex Ferguson, who was keen to take me to Old Trafford. "It was close to being done, but then Tottenham came back and said they could do it".
- Eden Hazard [source]:
“I had a chance to sign for Manchester United, Man City, Tottenham, but I made the right decision,”
- Lewandowski [source]:
Dortmund managed to keep Lewandowski for another two seasons, but he admits he was interested to move to Old Trafford after they Ferguson had shown interest. “I was speaking with him [Ferguson] after two years at Dortmund and at that time I was really thinking about a move to Manchester United,” Lewandowski told The Guardian. “Because of Ferguson and because of Manchester United. Borussia Dortmund said: ‘No, that’s that.’ That was the first time I was thinking about the move because if you get a phone call from Sir Alex Ferguson, for a young player it was something amazing. That was a special day for me.”
Anyway. What's the common trait of Liverpool won the League with record breaking points, and PSG, Lyon, Bayern, and Barcelona in CL semifinal?
They all don't have Sancho.
So missing out on him is supposedly not a big deal to be a top team.
This is what I was getting at. Lot of confusion about possible wages that doesnt quite add up, so taking the reports about a possible wage cut with a respectably sized pinch of salt.
Widely spoken about that we’ve agreed terms with him. That’s the thing to pay attention to, not the wage cut waffle.
well saidI understand your frustration but you have to remember where you are. You are writing in a forum dedicated to Manchester United and you have to be aware that for example the sentiment that the Sancho transfer won't happen this summer is not really what people want to hear. You basically have to be extra careful not to step on people's toes if you actually want them to listen to you. And if you think no proper discussion can be had just don't post because what you are doing now is simply counterproductive and agitates people even more so they won't listen at all to "the brigade of german fans invading the caf". There is a reason I don't have a lot of posts because I feel a proper discussion usually takes time and oftentimes I don't think it is worth it. So if all you can contribute is "you're all a bunch of idiots haha" maybe just think it to yourself, however warranted it may be.
The common denominator in that though? Sir Alex.
Yeah, of course How can not everyone see it? I mean look at Dortmund, they are so desperate, desperation is all over them. Don't you see it?
Regarding the “Sancho then” tweet.
Kroos was a Moyes targetThe common denominator in that though? Sir Alex.
Regarding the “Sancho then” tweet.
I think our chances of signing him are higher than not. I also think if we don’t sign him, the club have the perfect excuse this season, as do all clubs.Yeah it's so clear he's our number 1 target I can't see us missing out on him. There will be more cries of not backing the manager than there ever was under Mourinho and that's not something the club are going to want off the back of a positive season.
Think it'll take a while longer than first expected, but will get done eventually, and probably before either ours or Dortmunds seasons begin.
Mikhi, Auba and Dembele all kicked up a fuss and got a move.
Sorry Uncle Bob, please remind me again which point I missed last time? I don't even recognise you as a poster.You've completely missed the point, again.
It means feck all.
But they were still sold when the club initially refused?for the fee that Dortmund wanted
Still, the common theme amongst those players is Sir Alex. Who, whatever the outcome of a given transfer, would absolutely have us challenging the next season.Kroos was a Moyes target
He followed up on it and said it was positive information though.
There's probably more to that, but guess we'll never know. Still it doesn't change the fact that both sides and especially PSG had benefited from loan + purchase agreement.Monaco wanted 180m-190m (I give you a spanish report) from both PSG and Real Madrid, one paid the other didn't, so no there was no little extra for PSG. The difference was that PSG convinced Mbappé to pick them.
Yeah, of course How can not everyone see it? I mean look at Dortmund, they are so desperate, desperation is all over them. Don't you see it?
It means feck all. It's a pretty simple statement to make, he joins in on the bandwagon due to the amount of noise around the transfer, he then backs off a bit with his "i had information".
Think he is just playing around for shits and giggles?
What if we can't agree on a structured deal and he says he wants to go but Dortmund don't sanction the transfer?I don't see how Sancho benefits trying to agitate for a move if Dortmund don't budge from their valuation.
It's an interesting situation. Say Sancho starts forcing a move, but Dortmund refuses to sell short of their €120m evaluation. Now it's a conundrum. If they don't sell they're left with a disgruntled player, if they bench him for a season he will lose his value and it may prove detrimental to them in the long run. If they keep playing him, will he be as committed. Young players will think twice about commiting knowing they will potentially miss out of a dream move due to Dortmund asking for an exuberant amount of money.cause it wouldn't work. Dortmund are renowned for ignoring the player's plea and stick to their own guns.
Being close on a fee with only the structure being the issue is huge news though
Regarding the “Sancho then” tweet.
Honestly Dortmund made more money on them than they were worth imo, so not the best of examples.Mikhi, Auba and Dembele all kicked up a fuss and got a move.
But they werent for sale, chairs were thrown. 2 went on strike and forced Dortmunds hands.Honestly Dortmund made more money on them than they were worth imo, so not the best of examples.
It's an interesting situation. Say Sancho starts forcing a move, but Dortmund refuses to sell short of their €120m evaluation. Now it's a conundrum. If they don't sell they're left with a disgruntled player, if they bench him for a season he will lose his value and it may prove detrimental to them in the long run. If they keep playing him, will he be as committed. Young players will think twice about commiting knowing they will potentially miss out of a dream move due to Dortmund asking for an exuberant amount of money.
Of course it's always possible to come to some sort of an arrangement between the player and the club.
Just food for thought, nothing more.
If Dortmund want him to stay, if he’s happy to stay and you’ll get more next year then why the hell are Dortmund even entertaining the idea of a sale? It’s utter madness. The lady doth protest too much, as they say in the shires.
Promising him to sell when certain conditions are met was probably part of the bargain when they signed him.
Promising him to sell when certain conditions are met was probably part of the bargain when they signed him.
Can't ever be wrong when you communicate in one character tweets. I think he has evolved to the next level of sports journalism.
What conditions are they, besides a club paying an exaggerated fee for his services?