Israel - Palestine Discussion | Post Respectfully | Discuss more, tweet less

[VorZakone]

 

[Red in STL]

They are not equivalents in status or any other way. Hamas has no embassy here.

Maybe not, but not taking action on both sides will just encourage the other IMO, it doesn't necessarily have to be equal action but both side carry blame for their actions thus far and both sides need some accounting for what they have done

 

[Ish]

Really is sickening to the core.

 

[berbatrick]

A good response for Israel is usually 10X. Which means 14,000.

They must have reached 5,000+ by now. This last 500 (allegedly) was a big step forward. Will they take it all the way?

 

[RedDevil@84]

Intentional then. They've murdered more than 500 helpless people, is what they've done. It's an unforgivable crime.

Well, when you have the power, you can say "oops" and offer blood money.

 

[VorZakone]

Such a mass casualty event, just before Biden's visit.

 

[Mickeza]

If there is it's too late and arbitrary. It's disgusting and it was inevitable.

I mean western leaders quite literally rolled out the red carpet for them to do this shit by continually saying “Israel has a right to defend herself” as they commit war crime after war crime. We all knew what was coming and unfortunately I fear there is even worse to come.

 

[sullydnl]

 

[MDFC Manager]

A good response for Israel is usually 10X. Which means 14,000.

They must have reached 5,000+ by now. This last 500 (allegedly) was a big step forward. Will they take it all the way?

I think they'd like to reach the numbers before papa Biden arrives.

 

[sullydnl]

 

[kafta]

This one is just too much. Too much. Just sickening.

 

[E-mal]

That makes it even worse, heartless and stupid.

 

[VivaObertan]

Thanks for sharing this, I just donated to MAP. What a shit day for humanity.

 

[nimic]

That makes it even worse, heartless and stupid.

Yeah there's no good side here. Either they cruelly ordered the evacuation of a hospital and then bombed it despite no evacuation taking place, or they just bombed arbitrarily bombed a hospital. The best case scenario for Israel, beyond this being some incredible Hamas false flag (which I very much doubt they are capable of), is that it was simply a mistake. So the best case scenario is that they accidentally bombed a hospital.

Also they definitely did order the evacuation of many hospitals in Northern Gaza, whether or not they specifically ordered this one.

 

[E-mal]

Lets at least show the same dilligence to both sides, it doesn't show what that tweet is claiming. Twitter osint nerds can probably match what kind of weapon makes that sound pretty quick though, assuming the sound is legit.

What is your point exactly ? That this doesnt sound like a an airstrike?

 

[Sly]

Genuinely I can’t see that being tolerated

It can't be tolerated. Israel must suffer consequences. It's a dispicable attack.

 

[mariachi-19]

Israel just did more damage to Israel than Hamas ever could.

 

[TheReligion]

It can't be tolerated. Israel must suffer consequences. It's a dispicable attack.

Bidens visit will be interesting now

 

[Rampant Red Rodriguez]

Anyone who still sides with israel is nothing but a terrorist sympathiser.

 

[TheReligion]

Israel just did more damage to Israel than Hamas ever could.

Very good point

 

[Sly]

Bidens visit will be interesting now

Arab nations reaction as well.

 

[NicolaSacco]

Such a mass casualty event, just before Biden's visit.

Biden must be fuming at this. Hopefully it gives him the opportunity to be more forceful when he Susan’s to Netanyahu

 

[africanspur]

If this was Israel, unfortunate timing considering this earlier statement:

All Gaza targets approved at highest level of military, says Israel

Every Gaza target has been “approved at the highest level” of military, according to an Israeli official.
They added that the campaign to eliminate the terrorist group Hamas could take months or even years.

 

[RedTiger]

 

[Sly]

On CNN Portugal, the breaking news are saying that Israel claims it was a failed Hamas rocket launch

 

[E-mal]

Yeah there's no good side here. Either they cruelly ordered the evacuation of a hospital and then bombed it despite no evacuation taking place, or they just bombed arbitrarily bombed a hospital. The best case scenario for Israel, beyond this being some incredible Hamas false flag (which I very much doubt they are capable of), is that it was simply a mistake. So the best case scenario is that they accidentally bombed a hospital.

Also they definitely did order the evacuation of many hospitals in Northern Gaza, whether or not they specifically ordered this one.

Your strawman approach to justifying this as a mistake makes me sick, apologies to all your sensitivities but I disagree with your attempt to justifying this as a possible mistake. I have no horse in this matter, but this makes me sick because I am a medical doctor and cant imagine getting in harms way while doing my job innocently. This is absolutely abhorent.

 

[Pogue Mahone]

Yeah there's no good side here. Either they cruelly ordered the evacuation of a hospital and then bombed it despite no evacuation taking place, or they just bombed arbitrarily bombed a hospital. The best case scenario for Israel, beyond this being some incredible Hamas false flag (which I very much doubt they are capable of), is that it was simply a mistake. So the best case scenario is that they accidentally bombed a hospital.

Also they definitely did order the evacuation of many hospitals in Northern Gaza, whether or not they specifically ordered this one.

You can’t evacuate a hospital anyway. Any big hospital will have a number of people in ITU who are too sick to move (or, at least, moving them would carry an unacceptable risk of killing them) And that’s in normal conditions. Can’t imagine what they’re dealing with at a hospital in the middle of a war zone.

 

[space]

Absolute insanity what is happening. A fecking hospital

 

[nimic]

On CNN Portugal, the breaking news are saying that Israel claims it was a failed Hamas rocket launch

Do they even have any rockets capable of doing that much damage?

 

[Semper Fudge]

Your strawman approach to justifying this as a mistake makes me sick, apologies to all your sensitivities but I disagree with your attempt to justifying this as a possible mistake. I have no horse in this matter, but this makes me sick because I am a medical doctor and cant imagine getting in harms way while doing my job innocently. This is absolutely abhorent.

What? How have you read that and thought that he's justifying it?

 

[africanspur]

Your strawman approach to justifying this as a mistake makes me sick, apologies to all your sensitivities but I disagree with your attempt to justifying this as a possible mistake. I have no horse in this matter, but this makes me sick because I am a medical doctor and cant imagine getting in harms way while doing my job innocently. This is absolutely abhorent.

I think you may want to reread that post if that is what you think they've written.

 

[Sly]

Do they even have any rockets capable of doing that much damage?

Have serious doubts. Let's see how this develops

 

[ScholesyTheWise]

[Assuming it was blown up by the IDF]
Yes, this is the watershed moment. It's obviously a massive massive shame and scandal, and a loss of lives that should have been avoided.

If this doesn't stop now I'd be surprised.

by the way, while posting I just heard a gun fire that sounded like it was from outside my house.
I wonder what's going on in the streets.

This might incite an internal riot as well...

 

[WeePat]

I really think this is that moment.

Israel are finished now after that. The rest of the world won’t allow any more.

Which insane itself as this bombing is just the latest in a long long line Israeli aggression against Palestine. If the global community has allowed Israel to flatten and pulverise Palestine with impunity all these years, they won’t step in now.

 

[space]

On CNN Portugal, the breaking news are saying that Israel claims it was a failed Hamas rocket launch

Yeah like they always say every single time. I’m sure all the pro genocide folk will lap it up though

 

[MDFC Manager]

Do they even have any rockets capable of doing that much damage?

Would be such a precise (mis)hit as well, bang into a hospital.

 

[nimic]

You can’t evacuate a hospital anyway. Any big hospital will have a number of people in ITU who are too sick to move (or, at least, moving them would carry an unacceptable risk of killing them) And that’s in normal conditions. Can’t imagine what they’re dealing with at a hospital in the middle of a war zone.

Yeah, it's awful.

It felt very black humour'y when the caption under a picture in Nrk.no (Norwegian state broadcaster) was something to the effect of "An injured person is carried into a hospital after an alleged Israeli air strike on a hospital".

 

[nimic]

Your strawman approach to justifying this as a mistake makes me sick, apologies to all your sensitivities but I disagree with your attempt to justifying this as a possible mistake. I have no horse in this matter, but this makes me sick because I am a medical doctor and cant imagine getting in harms way while doing my job innocently. This is absolutely abhorent.

Come again?

 

[Pogue Mahone]

[Assuming it was blown up by the IDF]
Yes, this is the watershed moment. It's obviously a massive massive shame and scandal, and a loss of lives that should have been avoided.

If this doesn't stop now I'd be surprised.

by the way, while posting I just heard a gun fire that sounded like it was from outside my house.
I wonder what's going on in the streets.

This might incite an internal riot as well...

Has there been any kind of street protests against the assault on Gaza in Israel so far? I’d imagine there’s a huge risk of escalation if that happened?

 

[Murder on Zidanes Floor]

So?

You scrabbled about on Google to quickly find a link to bolster your point after your first link was shown to be about a different news station. Your next link didn't help your point at all.

Not surprised tbh.