Look at today's game and you'd realise you had the blinkers on. This is no anomaly for Maguire. He's a clown.
5
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 31
- Clean sheets
- 17
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 9
- Status
He had 1 good season and a good world cup. The scouts who vetoed his signing under Mourinho need a massive payrise. It's sad they were then overruled because of fan pressure and a second clueless manager wanting him.
Absolutely moronic by Southgate to play him in both games.
Southgate’s a fecking spanner for playing him. He needed a prolonged spell out of the spotlight and a gradual reintroduction in easy matches if there’s any hope of rebuilding some confidence. Throwing a rusty Harry Maguire into a potentially toxic environment like tonight’s game will end him. Which fecking sucks for United because there’s a good chance he’ll be needed for us before the season’s out.
It's pointless to criticize him anymore, Southgate set him up for more failures here.
The only people in the world who can't see it are Southgate and himself.
He’s not even mediocre, he’s quite terrible at this point.
Although I’m not sure about everyone feeling so sorry for him. It’s not like he’s had some awful life, he’s an Uber rich footballer that’s been playing like shit for years and turned himself into a meme. Not really anyone else to blame but himself, and the way he’s represented the club as it’s captain has been a joke.
At the end of the day he’ll still have an incredible life and family. He’ll be fine long after he’s left our club.
Yes.
He was poor defensively against Italy, just that he wasn't punished for it and the bad moments were spread out over a quiet game. He got some plaudits for just staying on the left side moving the ball yet when he was called upon he let Scamacca get a close range header early on, just watch the replay he's clumsily trying to hold him off but can't. Gets caught high up the pitch and gives Italy a 3vs2 but luckily the guy ran too far and was offside in the end. Then he gets beat just outside the box and just performs a rugby tackle and concedes a dangerous free kick.
Here today when he's called upon he gives away the ball and then just clumsily again fouls the player to give away a penalty.
Seem like Southgate is trying to play him into form and give him some confidence out left of a back three, he should be able to stay relatively free from harms way but he's been an absolutely liability in both games even there with all the protection and running around him.
Feel sorry for the guy but I think he may have peaked physically around 27-30 for such a big lad, yes he was slow but had just enough. He's been moving around like a sloth ever since he came back with no training in our 4-2 Leicester defeat.
Here today when he's called upon he gives away the ball and then just clumsily again fouls the player to give away a penalty.
Seem like Southgate is trying to play him into form and give him some confidence out left of a back three, he should be able to stay relatively free from harms way but he's been an absolutely liability in both games even there with all the protection and running around him.
Feel sorry for the guy but I think he may have peaked physically around 27-30 for such a big lad, yes he was slow but had just enough. He's been moving around like a sloth ever since he came back with no training in our 4-2 Leicester defeat.
Last edited:
Chris Smalling did better.
With any luck.
I know he's not always been this bad, but it's amazing to think he ever had anyone convinced he was good enough.
All I can hope is if one of Varane/Martinez get injured then Lindelof gets the nod before Maguire. Maguire reintroduction to our team would likely be the downfall of our season.
I wish we'd have had the foresight to try flog him this summer just gone before his reputation deteriorates any further, rather than have him play the opening 2 games, ETH to realise he's awful and then have him sat on the bench all season.
All I can hope is if one of Varane/Martinez get injured then Lindelof gets the nod before Maguire. Maguire reintroduction to our team would likely be the downfall of our season.
I wish we'd have had the foresight to try flog him this summer just gone before his reputation deteriorates any further, rather than have him play the opening 2 games, ETH to realise he's awful and then have him sat on the bench all season.
Lindelöf is bloody awful as well. You should have seen Sweden v Serbia the other day. If Varane gets injured we are fecked. If Martinez gets injured I would play Shaw in his place.
The last time he played well against an easy team, he scored and he celebrated like he scored against peak Barcelona in a champions league final.
The issue is that he has too much confidence. He showed that in Greece, and he is showing that in every opportunity he can. He is an average player who believes he is Beckenbauer.
I feel sorry for him to the extent that he has been painfully out of form for months and is massively in the spotlight. His comments in interviews do not help though and cut any real sympathy I have short - instead of recognising he may not be in the best place right now, which is perfectly fine and would actually be refreshing to hear, he is on the defensive reframing his performances and his stature in the game inviting more criticism.
Massively relived for him that England managed to turn this around. Hopefully they hold on now
All the time in the world to head a cross and he heads it straight back to an unmarked Germany player. He cannot even get the basics right.
Smalling is much better on the ball as well.
On top of being a far superior defender, cheers Ole.
And Leicester and us still conceded a shit ton of goals when he was playing well. Even his best season with us saw us conceding more goals than we’ve ever conceded under LvG/Mourinho.
That was Southgates doing. And Ole fell for it hook, line and sinker
Yes. Not really any getting around that. I tried.
I may be more sympathetic if he wasn't the captain, and if he didn't keep giving completely tone deaf interviews. He needs to see a sports psychologist.
For club and country I think he's won 1 out the last 14 games he's started.
And that was at home to Norwich 3-2.
He's cursed.
And that was at home to Norwich 3-2.
He's cursed.
Nah? Okie.
Chris Smalling had not put his team in danger with insipid passing as many times in his entire career as Herry Maguire did in 2022 alone.
He knew his limitations and he either played it simply to the midfield, or the better defender on the ball that was next to him, sometimes he hoofed it.
Literally all of this is far better than Harry Maguire thinking he’s Rio Ferdinand, feck that, Maguire is garbage on the ball, he doesn’t know it, that’s a problem.
He’s so shit at defending it’s unbelievable we payed £80m for him, just simple stuff like tackling or blocking he can’t do not even to mention the world class stuff.
I have never seen a CB that loses concentration as much as this guy. Half his errors are unforced.
That's confidence/prolonged bad form, there's no way in hell Smalling is better with the ball. Sadly, there's no way either that Maguire is worth 70 million more than Smalling when they both have very clear strengths and very clear weaknesses. To be fair, at least Smalling had/has fantastic pace to rectify any mistakes.
Another slab head masterclass.
Maguire is far better on the ball
The problem is that he's doing it soooooo slow
Why is he being played when he's not only in bad form, but he's not playing for his club team? Southgate has a lot to answer for.
Leicester carried out the biggest heist in the history of the sport when they got us to stump up £80 million for him.
Far better on the ball yet keeps costing his teams goals every other match by showing himself to be clueless on the ball, sure thing, makes sense.
Maybe Maguire is actually crap on the ball and people just stick to some false made up narrative.
Nice rant. You’re still wrong.
Someone’s created a false made up narrative in this thread, that’s for sure.
Smalling recognizes his own weaknesses and for that reason he moves the ball on to better players.
Maguire either can't or won't acknowledge his own weaknesses (he's actually not that good on the ball) and so he continues to get himself into trouble and the team pays for it.
- Status