Obviously his head probably isnt right at the moment, but nobody can say he as been ok the opening two games, he has been an utter shambles. Overall last season I thought he did ok, I do think he can do better....but a lot better, I am not so sure
I can see why we went for Maguire, but thought not a great move at the time. This sounds worse than I mean it, but to me he has always been a fantastic championship style defender that has the added ability of being decent on the ball. For me he isnt a leader or captain, never has been, he isnt going to organise the defence, bark at players and grab them by the coat tails like greta captains we have had in the past, he seems better at leading off the pitch....that isnt a captain. Thee fee is someting we should have walked away from, I can see why Leicester wouldnt budge but for that fee you expect a world class centre back. He isnt world class as a captain, he isnt quick enough pace or turning wise, he doesnt read the game brilliantly, he is good on the ball but not excellent. He is world class in terms of strength and aerially.....again, a fantastic championship style defender.
Saying all that, I do think he can be despite an atrociously high fee a very good defender for us....but not the leader more the Vidic to a RIo, Bruce to a Pallister, JOhnsen to a STam. Lindelof is never ever the right partner for him. This is why I am absolutely bewildered we are concentrating on signing a left back over a centre back. For me, even with Sancho and a left back....no centre back this window, bar Mengi/Tuanzabe or Bailly stepping up big time, no top four