Honestly, although I support Milan, I never looked highly at Donarrumma at least performance wise. Yes, he has huge potential for an 18 year old; that is rarely seen. Yes, he is really talented and has confidence, but potential doesnt mean you are good at the time being. I think that he wasnt even in the top 25 goalkeepers in the world last season, and was horrendous in some matches. He definitely single-handedly cost Milan several points and is so often shaky that he doesnt infuse confidence in the heart of a Milan supporter. Yet Milan gave him their full trust because they werent doing well to begin with and so wanted someone to look up to and build their team around. The fans just went crazy and just ignored every mistake he did and idolized him. It isnt wrong to do that when your team is doing poor as Milan have been, but the result was overhyping not of his potential which is undoubtedly there, but overhyping of the effect he has on the team. I think Milan would have done better with any average goalkeeper you can name now because of the mistakes he did and because of the lack of safety the defenders felt with him no matter how much Milan fans try to deny it.
Yet Donarrumma was never doubted not even for one second. Many other players with huge potential like David Calabria and Locatelli ( who by the way is also 18 years old) had some great matches/performances but Milan as club and fans never praised them as much, and never trusted them as much. And here's what spited me, Locatelli and Calabria dont play in the GK position which is very critical when it comes to mistakes. They play in positions where it would be OK to make a mistake or two, and yet the coach wouldnt give them as much confidence. The fans and the club focused so much on Donarrumma that the fans did a special chant for him although he has been playing for merely two seasons and they never do that for any other Milan player. Many even nicknamed him God. All that was just growing this aura around him that certainly made him somewhat cocky deep inside. He even went on to absorb this attention to begin the badge-kissing, relish the captaincy of Milan which he should have never dreamed of having, and just sweet-talking about being in Milan forever and so on. The situation was really so silly all around in my opinion, but Milan wanted a hero through the unbearable poor times and so he became already their Buffon. The media obviously took from there and every good thing he did was magnified 100 times, and every bad thing he did was ignored or downplayed. He wasnt Milan's hero anymore but Italy's.
Here we come in the beginning of this season and Milan felt hope for the first time in probably a decade with money flowing in. Imagine how frustrated Milan fans were for the past decade and imagine then how much ecstatic they felt when money started finally pouring in and most of all a better management took over. Nothing was going to go bad no matter what in, their minds. The LAST THING a Milan fan would have imagined especially after last season's story with Donnarumma was that he among all would pull the most stupid and selfish move that would shake their pride in this season and be the big black mark in the start of it. Yes I am one of the 0.001% of fans that never really praised Donarrumma past season, but no matter how you look at it, this never made sense. It's so unfathomable that I sometimes honestly wondered ( if only I didnt know better) if this was just a huge trick by all sides to keep making Donarrumma the God he is and give Milan more money out of him in the case of selling him this summer or after, while at the same time selling a story of his departure for the fans. Its not about whether he has the right or not, its not about footballers needing to be protected or not. No matter how you looked at it, this was his first professional contract after completing 18. This is the team that gave him a chance that not many teams would, this is the fanbase that made him a God, and he is the one that acted as an angel that would be their savior.
....And yet even if you ignore all that, why in HELL would he not sign a contract for five million euros ?? This is Italy where paying five million means 10 million with taxes. Even if we pretend he doesnt believe in the Milan project, even if he hates Milan, you can just sign the contract and there would still be much chances for you to move on in the future. It's for his own good to remain at such a young age in the same team, anyway, and gain more experience and have all his mistakes ignored because he is everyone's idol. Hell F*ck, even if he wants he could make a deal like many players and extend his contract and still leave but at the very least get some money back for the team that trusted you so that they can have leverage in the negotiations. Sometimes as I said earlier I really dont know if this all is not a trick because it never makes sense. Even in the worst case scenario that he could possibly claim, he shouldnt act in this selfish manner. This ceases to be football; it's that simple. This is what makes Milan fans so angry. He could claim the worst case scenario and yet he still couldnt justify acting the way he did.
But it doesnt end here; after all that's happened, the Milan management make the worst possible decision in giving him 6 million per year which is 12 million after and even worse giving his loudmouth brother a contract worth a million as well ? And with all these concessions, put a release clause of 50 million ? Even if he was actually THE best goalkeeper in the world ALREADY, he doesnt deserve this. All the money they could possibly make from him would be balanced by all the money they'll be wasting on him. And trust me there's BIG possibility that it will be wasted because how on earth could he justify his wages ? Also how on earth could he guarantee good performance after all the beef that has happened between him and the club. The atmosphere is toxic now all over. The deal makes zero sense. I cant see this not ending with Milan selling him this summer even if they extend his contract first. This whole fiasco of a saga was so confusing that it bordered on fake in my mind at times. But since reality is there in front of us unfolding, I have to believe it and say that this is the worst deal ever for Milan and could backfire a lot. The window has started very well, so why not sell this kid even if for less than 50 million, even if for 25-30 million euros and just move on without toxicity in the environment?
Yes I will say again, I am biased in that I was one of the rare people that never really praised Donnarrumma, but I think most Milan fans would agree on how terrible this deal is, even those who like him because it gives nothing for Milan and yet gives everything for the other side.