No he's not.
He's there to describe what he sees... or commentate.
We've been dog shite... he's called it, correctly.
Gary Neville
- Thread starter jymufc20
- Start date
He's there to describe what he sees... or commentate.
We've been dog shite... he's called it, correctly.
No. No one match is enough to draw that conclusion. Any team can have a poor performance.
He's saying he's given up on this group of players and doesnt enjoy watching any of it so we should scrap the entire thing.
He's not saying "United have played poorly at the back and might not get a winner" he's saying "I dont like being here watching United because I've already decided on the players and I dont care about any of them"
Meh, everything he said was correct imo. Besides he's gone in far harder on Arsenal when they struggled under Wenger, calling their players a disgrace and embarrassment etc.
This could go on all day. People should think for themselves, but even if they did base their perspective on Gary’s comments, they wouldn’t be far wrong in this instance.
Well they would if they follow what he said. If a United fan listens to Neville today and says "yeah he's right!" then what happens in the summer when obviously we can expect 3 or 4 signings and 3 or 4 going the other way and its unrealistic to expect anymore?
Even if all of those are good signings and we get rid of the right 3 or 4 players, one poor result near the start of the season and its "Ole should have got rid of the entire lot like Neville said". Ole brought a feel good factor and spirit back to the club, Neville is taking a dump on it because Mourinho isnt there anymore.
Last edited:
@GifLord thanks. There was actually more where he called the team awful, despondent, says he prefers to watch Huddersfield etc but the video captures his mood.
Yeah just seen the video skipped there's almost a minute missing.
Gonna post a proper in a few minutes
edit: Updated
Last edited:
Surprisingly he doesn't criticize the English lot as much as they deserve.
There lies some of my problems with him. He is biased as hell.
There lies some of my problems with him. He is biased as hell.
Someone like Arsene Wenger would be a much better pundit imo.
You don't have to hire us. I'd love more managers as pundits actually.
He made a good point
He sounds completely distraught and at the end of his tether. Got to respect what he says as he's seen it all, he should go in and help ole.
Even in that short clip he calls Shaw embarrassing.
He's not wrong but listening to him bitch and moan for the last 35 minutes was a bit fecking tiring.
shows he cares and worried about us, unlike some people who think we will be back next season
He never lays into them like he does certain players.
The Lingard and Rashfords have been just as bad this season. Probably much worse than a certain Frenchman.
And its the continued sustained attacks between games that bothers me the most.
On the bright side, Gary and his boys are going to Wembely. Salford just won.
He talks the most shit talk about our defense, which includes Smalling, Jones and Shaw so I dont think so. I dont think hes biased towards Lingard and some others because they're English. If anything its because he likes him
Bit like being on the Caf, I’d struggle to hear any United fan talk about us at the moment.
He's right about how bad we are, but he never talks about the English lads Jones/Smalling/Young/Shaw/Rashford. Did the same thing with Rooney, said nothing while millions of fans were screaming at their TV's.
I don’t think Neville can be criticised for what he said today. His commentary would have carried absolutely no validity if he’d tried flowering up that shower of sh*te any differently to the total car crash of a performance that it was.
He rarely mentions specific people other than Pogba does he?
I dont think he's every called him out by name either
Exactly. If he tried to make out like things were rosey people would find fault with that too (and be more in the right if anything). Some people can't handle anything other than exactly what they think so they want this impartialness.
Not that I've heard. We need United people in the media to stop giving guys like Shaw/Rashford a free ride, step up or your done.
When you make your co commentator uncomfortable for a whole game you know you’re pushing the boundaries quite a bit.
He didn’t hold back. Can you blame him? He’s 100% right
He didn’t hold back. Can you blame him? He’s 100% right
There's a difference between talking bad about the defense as a collective and having a go at individual players.
At least you admit he is biased though.
It probably does not make good TV though they should probably not have him commentate on United matches.
Pogba is the easy target.
He will leave. We will still be poor and we will find another target.
Not sure why Neville gets so much shit from United fans. He only says what we’re all thinking
Not sure it's the right approach with a captive audience personally. Not everyone wants to listen to it for the hundredth time.
Think we just need this season to end tbh.
For sure he is, but not towards "every English player". He never gives Smalling credit for example. Just constantly complains about all the defenders.
He has a bias towards the players he likes, which probably includes Lingard
To be fair it's doing wonders for non-United fans so the captive audience is there.
He was probably a bit harsher today because, like us all, he could see the final nail being hammered in. I’m hoping by 5pm next Sunday Ole let’s rip in the same way. The season is over, he no longer needs the bunch of w*nkers and I’m desperately hoping he gives a withering no holds barred interview to echo the sentiment of us fans.
And Pogba won’t be much better at Madrid
I am glad he suffered a meltdown. Keane did it before him a game or two back. Our fans are sheep who will support this tripe through thick and thin. At least our old guard has our back.
The only thing he pisses me off is his England player's bias. It makes him lose credibility, something we can't afford at this delicate stage of our club.
The only thing he pisses me off is his England player's bias. It makes him lose credibility, something we can't afford at this delicate stage of our club.
And he has players he doesn't like in that United team.
The criticism is laced with so much bias it's hard to take it seriously.
You can convince yourself of that. If it helps you sleep at night.
I just don’t see him being a ballon d’or contender
How can he change? He’s been crap and barely gets out of second gear for us. Ok he’ll have good players around him but so?
Don’t we all?
We just don’t like him saying it