Nope, he said he was not changing his predictions about odds of who will win EPL based on us signing Ronaldo. He basically said Ronaldo signing didn't change anything. Which is bullshit and which he got laughed at for, by other people on that video. I am saying Ronaldo signing, while it cannot guarantee winning, changes EVERYTHING and drastically increases our odds. How are these two things the same?
Gary Neville - Pundit
- Thread starter Jamie Shawcross
- Start date
OMG, we just signed Sancho, Varane and goddamned Cristiano Ronaldo and you are still saying fecking Pool is above us? Seriously? The same Pool that couldn't score a goal against 10-men Chelsea, for 50 minutes today? That is some serious defeatist shit, mate. Sorry, but it really is
Its his opinion. And we all know his opinion on predicting winners cannot be relied upon. Just like ours. He's trying to downplay it just as some of us downplay/overestimate the squad. But deep inside he want United to win the league for sure. Thats why I like to listen to Rio and Keane more because often times they speak plainly.
That’s not what he said. He said signing Ronaldo puts United closer to Chelsea/City but not enough for him to think they’re favourites for the title ahead of either of them. Which I think most fans would agree with, not sure why so many are misunderstanding what he’s saying
How can anyone take him seriously at this point? He wrote Varane, Sancho and Kane would win the PL Title in the summer. Utd have gone on to sign Ronaldo who not only scores as much as Kane but is a born fecking winner. Something which Kane knows feck all about.
I mean less than 2 weeks ago when they were doing the Overlap Debate, he kept harping about Utd lacking a 30 goal a season CF to win the PL. Now, he’s backtracking. What a clown.
Funny how Hasselbaink asks him “So, what will win Utd the PL title then?”. Instead of answering the question, he turned it on Hasselbaink
I mean less than 2 weeks ago when they were doing the Overlap Debate, he kept harping about Utd lacking a 30 goal a season CF to win the PL. Now, he’s backtracking. What a clown.
Funny how Hasselbaink asks him “So, what will win Utd the PL title then?”. Instead of answering the question, he turned it on Hasselbaink
Potato-potahto. Sure, signing Ronaldo at Man United doesn't put us above Chelsea, because Lukaku is such a world star! Haha! My God, our group psyche has really been depressed at United, in the last 8 years, hasn't it? Feck Chelsea and feck Tuchel, we are Man goddamn United, we have Ronaldo the GOAT and Pogba and Bruno and Varane and Sancho and Greenwood and De Gea and Maguire and Luke Shaw. And Garry Nevill talks out of his ass.
He's going to give ole excuses as long as either of them have their current jobs.
Gary Neville knows his onions, but he's not impartial. He's capable of delivering good analysis as long as he's not talking about his former mates, colleagues or friends.
United should win something important this year, else Ole should walk.
United should win something important this year, else Ole should walk.
I think Neville desperately wants Utd to win the league, of course he does. On the other hand, hes not going to come out and say Ole has to win it, because its his mate and he just will not criticise him, should he win nothing.... He's not going to say anything which leads to him having to criticise OGS is my point
I also dont think CR7 will win you the title, but of course youll be closer. I 100% think you should have gone for Kane instead though earlier in the window
I also dont think CR7 will win you the title, but of course youll be closer. I 100% think you should have gone for Kane instead though earlier in the window
You must be joking, you saying we have no squad depth?!
Agree with what he said - I don’t think we’ll win it either
City walked it last year and we still didn’t fix the midfield
City walked it last year and we still didn’t fix the midfield
absolutely. Not a chance in hell he is going to ever criticise OGS in public. Which is why he wont ever say "ole has to win something this year"
While I get why everyone is critical of him saying Ronaldo will not change much and him subconsciously thinking ole is not up to the task and holding us back (perhaps true perhaps not we'll find out by the end of the season or maybe even sooner by December)this is the best answer he could give regarding our chances
Him openly coming out and putting us as the main title challengers would put massive strain on a young squad who are challenging for the first time (though presence of winners like Ronaldo and varane will be a massive help) and seeing as he's a former player who played with ole would only exacerbate the problem in the eyes of fans and the media
We don't know how young lads like Sancho would perform under scrutiny and pressure so its better not to risk it now
It will also cause outrage over ole with pitchforks coming out for every hiccup we may make during the season with is surely not conducive to a sustained title challenge
So whether he does it intentionally or not let's hope he keeps it that way (for now atleast)
Him openly coming out and putting us as the main title challengers would put massive strain on a young squad who are challenging for the first time (though presence of winners like Ronaldo and varane will be a massive help) and seeing as he's a former player who played with ole would only exacerbate the problem in the eyes of fans and the media
We don't know how young lads like Sancho would perform under scrutiny and pressure so its better not to risk it now
It will also cause outrage over ole with pitchforks coming out for every hiccup we may make during the season with is surely not conducive to a sustained title challenge
So whether he does it intentionally or not let's hope he keeps it that way (for now atleast)
I think Nev's a shit pundit when it comes to anything Utd or England but seeing the first 4mins of the video, what exactly did people find outrageous? Says Ronaldo brings us closer to the title, he desperately hopes we win but if he had to put his house on the line - he'd put it on City or Chelsea?
Is there seriously anyone here who has us favorites and gun to head, would put their house on us?
Is there seriously anyone here who has us favorites and gun to head, would put their house on us?
A horrible pundit... who you've then agreed with 100%.
I'm legit wondering if people actually watched the video or just started going odd based on comments here
I read this alot, and I don't know what it means - Levy is on record saying he won't sell to a domestic rival and he wouldn't even entertain offers of less than 160mm quid. What do you want us to do? Waste all summer with Levy for a player he won't at a price we won't conrtemplate. Your own club wouldn't go for Kane, who are you to say what United should have done? FFS
This.
I'm legit wondering if people actually watched the video or just started going odd based on comments here
Obviously he's struggling to be impartial here because Ole is his mate, and I do think in general he's a bit of a pessimist, so continuing to hedge his bets shouldn't really surprise anyone.
Calm down. That's Liverpool.
That post change points per game figure belies the truth though. They went on a brilliant run in the month after he joined, standard new manager bounce. The ppg went back to normal in the 10 or 15 games after that.
I agree with him. This place is RAWK level weird when it comes to Neville.
I just want people to admit the blantant truth here. Consciously or subconsciously, expectations are bing managed cause of who our manager is and I don't think that's acceptable. On Monday, Gary Neville said we would get 90-95 points guaranteed, if we signed Harry Kane cause he will get us 25-30 goals. We signed Cristiano Fecking Ronaldo and he says things are as they were.
The other point I want to make is that there's not much between the squads at the top. Sure we need a midifleder, Liverpool don't have any depth, City don't have a bloody striker and Chelsea while having depth in midfield, we are stronger in every other department. We like to make comments on our rivals squads. I was looking at our rivals forums last week. The unanimous opinion throughout was that they think the reason we won't challenge is because of our manager, they all admit we have a very strong squad. Won't get into a debate about the veracity of their argument but I am just trying to point out how people form opinions on the quality of the squad based on preconceived notions.
With the exception of City, the three of Chelsea, Liverpool and United should have similar aspirations for the title.
The other point I want to make is that there's not much between the squads at the top. Sure we need a midifleder, Liverpool don't have any depth, City don't have a bloody striker and Chelsea while having depth in midfield, we are stronger in every other department. We like to make comments on our rivals squads. I was looking at our rivals forums last week. The unanimous opinion throughout was that they think the reason we won't challenge is because of our manager, they all admit we have a very strong squad. Won't get into a debate about the veracity of their argument but I am just trying to point out how people form opinions on the quality of the squad based on preconceived notions.
With the exception of City, the three of Chelsea, Liverpool and United should have similar aspirations for the title.
Last edited:
"Signing Ronaldo absolutely brings them closer to winning the title." He says it twice in a row. Would he be a better pundit in your eyes if he changed his predictions from City/Chelsea/United to United/City/Chelsea based on the Ronnie signing?
I agree. I was speaking to a Chelsea fan yesterday who said he thought we had the best 11 in the premier league with the additions we have made this summer and you know what he’s right. That Utd 11 on paper is ridiculously good, even with the weaker midfield options. The simple reality Is Ole has to deliver big time this season and finishing behind Chelsea and Liverpool would be a substantial failure which I don’t think we should accept!
I would even accept finishing fourth. I predicted fourth in the prediction thread.
What shouldn't be accepted is us going into the last few games of the season long way behind the title contenders with no chance of winning. This team should challenge.
Last edited:
I don’t think there’s any scenario where 4th is acceptable this season, even if we are closer.
Maybe if there's some freakish scenario where top 4 are all in contention in the last couple of weeks.
But apart from that agree. I love Ole but he has to challenge for league and go deep in ECL. The squad we have is now pretty amazing.
That's what I am saying. In that kind of scenario, you can excuse finishing fourth.
Yeah I am more than happy to criticise Neville but what has he done wrong now? We aren’t the favourites to win it and signing Ronaldo makes us stronger. All fair points.
Don't think there's anything subconscious about it. To win the title, Ole needs to get the better of 2 of the best managers in the last decade or so and the top 2 in the world atm along with a 3rd manager who's absolutely brilliant himself. This will be true of any league where Pep and Klopp moved. Managers there would suddenly be up against insane quality and having a squad as good as them is no longer enough.
Why do you think people don't realize this? Are there a good chunk of posters who think Ole is as good as Pep and Klopp?
Some people seem to think a 36 year old Ronaldo is a cheat code and the league should be a doddle. Our squad is now on a similar level to Liverpool, Chelsea, and City, except they’ve got a bit more recent experience of winning titles. We’re certainly not favourites.
I’m good with that analysis. Roll on the first real test, as someone might say
You have made my point. The mental gymnastics about squads is simply that, gymnastics. With the exception of City, the other three squads are level. City's
isn't even perfect. The biggest difference between all the four contenders is that we have by some margin, the weakest coach and people are mentally accounting for it even of they refuse to admit it(including Neville). He will have to find it within himself to develop into a top coach.
I like Gary. Lad has to earn a crust. United will win something this year. Maybe not the league, but something nice and tinny and shiny.
He didn't say anything wrong. If anything, Hasselbank looked stupid when the question got flipped to him
Didn't have any issue with his pov, tbh.
City don't have Fred & Matic
I agree with Gary. We will not win the league (IMO, we won't even challenge) where we diverge is why?
It isn't just Neville, it is a lot of ex-players that this place gets all smooth brained over.
Did you deliberately ignore my first two sentences or is this a comprehension issue?