Gareth Bale

Status
Not open for further replies.
Did I hear a "we want Gareth Bale" chants from the crowd today?

Not sure about that.

We cried out for a direct player like Gareth today. Some people say he wouldn't fit in to our passing style of play but I think we also need someone who will just get on the ball and run at the defense when things aren't going our way.
 
Yep I can just imagine Bale is licking his lips at the prospect of playing for us.
 
I'm not sure what he would do in games like today. He suits more of a counter attack team.

When Madrid have all the possession vs Atletico, he doesn't really offer that much. Tonight we lacked creativity and any decent movement upfront. But I think a lot of decent strikers would solve the latter including Bale of course.

But I rather signing Bale than Ings for crying out loud.
 
Exactly, would rather we get someone who's able to create space even when there isn't any like Hazard does.
 
Did I hear a "we want Gareth Bale" chants from the crowd today?
Not that I heard. The only out of the usual chant I heard was "we want you to sign, we want you to sign, David De Gea, we want you to sign". No Gareth Bale stuff to the best of my knowledge.

Oh and yes, we are fecking desperate for someone like Bale. He's a monster coming forward. Not a player who runs, stops and passes to the right back.
 
Can't believe people are suggesting Nani as part of any potential swap deal with Madrid. He wouldn't get near their bench.

Bale would be brilliant here. Can win games on his own and not every game will be like today with the team defending on their 18 yard line. Young often gets the ball in a good bit of space but does nothing with it, Bale would be able to do something with that sort of space.
 
Can't believe people are suggesting Nani as part of any potential swap deal with Madrid. He wouldn't get near their bench.

Bale would be brilliant here. Can win games on his own and not every game will be like today with the team defending on their 18 yard line. Young often gets the ball in a good bit of space but does nothing with it, Bale would be able to do something with that sort of space.

Look at this way - if Hernandez can get playing time for Madrid, so can Nani.
 
Agreed. Only Ronaldo would warrant that sort of money.

Bale is a 50-60m player max.

Yeah, Real overpaid for him, Fair play Levy. His premier league experience may have a premium for a premier league club, but I'm in the same ballpark as you.
 
Look at this way - if Hernandez can get playing time for Madrid, so can Nani.
Maybe, but Hernandez only really has Benzema ahead of him whereas Nani would have Ronaldo, Bale, Rodriguez, Isco and Jese. I just think Nani is way too inconsistent and often brainless to do well there, or even here next season(though I wouldn't mind him getting one last chance).
 
Maybe, but Hernandez only really has Benzema ahead of him whereas Nani would have Ronaldo, Bale, Rodriguez, Isco and Jese. I just think Nani is way too inconsistent and often brainless to do well there, or even here next season(though I wouldn't mind him getting one last chance).

People always undersell Nani during these comparisons. I'm sure he would play if he were a Madrid player.
 
People always undersell Nani during these comparisons. I'm sure he would play if he were a Madrid player.
Fair enough. I don't think he would, there's at least 4 better players for a position on the wing at Madrid at the moment imo.
 
Agreed. Only Ronaldo would warrant that sort of money.

Bale is a 50-60m player max.

i know prices went to **** but feck me if Gareth Bale is a 50-60m player.....how much are worth Muller, Silva, Reus, Hazard etc. all players in similar position who are better then him. How many 50-60m players we have at this current time?
 
i know prices went to **** but feck me if Gareth Bale is a 50-60m player.....how much are worth Muller, Silva, Reus, Hazard etc. all players in similar position who are better then him. How many 50-60m players we have at this current time?

I don't think any of those players would cost as much as Bale, although Hazard and Reus may come close. Di Maria certainly isn't and never was a 60m player, and we should take his experience into account when contemplating buying Bale for 80 or more. The higher the price, the greater the expectations, and if they don't meet those inflated expectations, the greater the disappointment.
 
Bale is not a 100 million € player, but if PSG pays 50 million € for David Luiz, then the Premier League player of the year should cost much more than that.The good players must appear in the important games and he scored the winner in Copa del Rey + a very important goal in C.L final. The only swap that Madrid might be interested is De Gea+ money. In the same position is Jesé, who in my opinion is technically better that Bale
 
I don't think any of those players would cost as much as Bale, although Hazard and Reus may come close. Di Maria certainly isn't and never was a 60m player, and we should take his experience into account when contemplating buying Bale for 80 or more. The higher the price, the greater the expectations, and if they don't meet those inflated expectations, the greater the disappointment.

Neither do i but thats my point, im not talking how much would someone cost, im asking how much is someone worth. You say Di Maria was never 60m player, lets say i agree but Di Maria is better than Bale, yes he is awful this year but if anybody has a short memory all he needs to do is watch any game of Real Madrid from last season.
If real received a bid today for Bale worth 50+ there isnt one member of the board or Ancelotti who ever decides on transfers there who would said "we should keep him" and thats a sign of overpaying.
 
If Real Madrid are getting a transfer ban for the next transfer window then there's no way that they will sell Bale.

No one will pay £100m for Bale but i would pay £60m for him.
If he's available then we must do everything to get him because he would improve us to another level.
I would now pay £70m for him.
Did I hear a "we want Gareth Bale" chants from the crowd today?
I've heard nothing in the Stretford End.
I've heard only "We want you to sign, we want you to sign, David De Gea, We want you to sign".
 
Not sure about that.

We cried out for a direct player like Gareth today. Some people say he wouldn't fit in to our passing style of play but I think we also need someone who will just get on the ball and run at the defense when things aren't going our way.

Not that I heard. The only out of the usual chant I heard was "we want you to sign, we want you to sign, David De Gea, we want you to sign". No Gareth Bale stuff to the best of my knowledge.

Oh and yes, we are fecking desperate for someone like Bale. He's a monster coming forward. Not a player who runs, stops and passes to the right back.

I would now pay £70m for him.

I've heard nothing in the Stretford End.
I've heard only "We want you to sign, we want you to sign, David De Gea, We want you to sign".

I clearly got it wrong lads, thanks. As for Bale, while not my dream signing I think he'd add a lot that is sorely missing from our attack.
 
People say that Bale doesn't fit our system and etc etc. That doesn't really matter. Some of you are forgetting what he was doing to the premier league a few years ago - He was tearing it to pieces. He isn't suited to La Liga. La Liga is about flair and technical ability which he doesn't have. Yesterday we could of had a player of his quality and ability to take a long shot from 40 yards and take on players who park the bus - which Di Maria can do but he will be barged of the ball.
 
People say that Bale doesn't fit our system and etc etc. That doesn't really matter. Some of you are forgetting what he was doing to the premier league a few years ago - He was tearing it to pieces. He isn't suited to La Liga. La Liga is about flair and technical ability which he doesn't have. Yesterday we could of had a player of his quality and ability to take a long shot from 40 yards and take on players who park the bus - which Di Maria can do but he will be barged of the ball.

He's struggled against Atlético when they've parked the bus, it's not as simple as smashing one in from 40 yards.

Best way to break down a deep defence is by playing as many people who can play in tight spaces. Bale isn't one of those players, he'd be easily crowded out.
 
People say that Bale doesn't fit our system and etc etc. That doesn't really matter. Some of you are forgetting what he was doing to the premier league a few years ago - He was tearing it to pieces. He isn't suited to La Liga. La Liga is about flair and technical ability which he doesn't have. Yesterday we could of had a player of his quality and ability to take a long shot from 40 yards and take on players who park the bus - which Di Maria can do but he will be barged of the ball.
It's a good point but let's also remember he was performing so well in a spurs team that played a lot of counter attack football.
Would lvgs philosophy allow him the same space to exploit and other players the freedom to hit his runs with early balls?
I'm not suggesting lvg could not find a way to integrate his attributes into the team but it may involve using him in a different way to spurs did
 
Bale would be great signing. Id rather have Isco(slight possibility) or Modric(zero possibility).
 
It's a good point but let's also remember he was performing so well in a spurs team that played a lot of counter attack football.
Would lvgs philosophy allow him the same space to exploit and other players the freedom to hit his runs with early balls?
I'm not suggesting lvg could not find a way to integrate his attributes into the team but it may involve using him in a different way to spurs did
They would have had less emphasis on possession than us (it's impossible not to) but I'm pretty sure I remember a lot of complaints from Tottenham fans that Tottenham spent a lot of time passing from side to side, looking toothless until Bale stepped in. I also remember them attempting to play an extremely high line under Villas Boas. Almost laughably high, at times.
 
i know prices went to **** but feck me if Gareth Bale is a 50-60m player.....how much are worth Muller, Silva, Reus, Hazard etc. all players in similar position who are better then him. How many 50-60m players we have at this current time?

There are a lot of players that would fetch £50-60m. Most of them are already at top clubs though.

Bale would be worth almost any amount to us. The only top British talent in the laSt ten years.

It's not like we could use that £80m and buy another two top players. We really struggleto convince top players to come here. Frankly, we have very rarely done it.

Should change now we are no longer tights wads.
 
Bale would be great signing. Id rather have Isco(slight possibility) or Modric(zero possibility).

So we can keep passing the ball around a the box of a counter attacking team?

Why can't no one see we need goals in this side.
 
£100 for him would be madness, or outright stupidity on our part. That money can get you Pogba and Reus. Not that I believe the reports anyway, but we'll be absolute Ihni binni dimi diniwiny anitaime to spend that amount on any one player at this time.
 
There are a lot of players that would fetch £50-60m. Most of them are already at top clubs though.

Bale would be worth almost any amount to us. The only top British talent in the laSt ten years.

It's not like we could use that £80m and buy another two top players. We really struggleto convince top players to come here. Frankly, we have very rarely done it.

Should change now we are no longer tights wads.
That's silly. He's still young but he's going to turn 26. Without his electric pace, bale simply doesn't have that much in his tank. So it's hardly like he's going to be brilliant till 35. So yeah, his price is relevant. You never know,we might just get 3 peak years out of him.
 
So we can keep passing the ball around a the box of a counter attacking team?

Why can't no one see we need goals in this side.
Isco is more than passing. But don't want to go off topic in this Bale thread so ill leave it at that.

We need a goalscoring midfielder.

Ok but a creative player who can dribble past defenders won't do any harm.
 
£100 for him would be madness, or outright stupidity on our part. That money can get you Pogba and Reus. Not that I believe the reports anyway, but we'll be absolute Ihni binni dimi diniwiny anitaime to spend that amount on any one player at this time.

Quite correct. There are no guarantees irrespective of the size of the wages and transfer fees you pay, as we've unceremoniously found out with Di Maria and Falcao this year. We should be focusing on building a team that functions like an organism rather than a group of disparate individuals. Bale would be a good signing, but as I've been saying, it would need to be in the 50-60 range.
 
Isco is more than passing. But don't want to go off topic in this Bale thread so ill leave it at that.



Ok but a creative player who can dribble past defenders won't do any harm.

It would, if we are signing him over Gareth Bale (assuming both players are available).
 
There are a lot of players that would fetch £50-60m. Most of them are already at top clubs though.

Bale would be worth almost any amount to us. The only top British talent in the laSt ten years.

It's not like we could use that £80m and buy another two top players. We really struggleto convince top players to come here. Frankly, we have very rarely done it.

Should change now we are no longer tights wads.


in my eyes 50-60m should be only given for a highest caliber of players so there really isnt much of them around, there are plenty of players that clubs value for that amount but they are overrated and we would overpay them.

He isnt the top talent for a start and why should we buy him only because he is british? I love british players in general and i love them at United and if there was a choice between two similar players(one british one not) i would always pick the british but we shouldnt really buy british talent for any cost. I would rather have Reus then Bale in my team, he is better, cheaper and in that case the nationality doesnt really matter.

If you think we cant find the better way to spend 80m then to spend it on Bale then i think you are delusional. We could get at least 2 top players for that amount!
 
Not entirely sure what Perez was thinking. He probably saw a few Youtube clips of his last year at Spurs and thought he had the next galactico on his hands. In any case, that doesn't mean we have to spend the same on him as Madrid have a history of selling their players for less than they bought them for - well except Di Maria.
 
Not entirely sure what Perez was thinking. He probably saw a few Youtube clips of his last year at Spurs and thought he had the next galactico on his hands. In any case, that doesn't mean we have to spend the same on him as Madrid have a history of selling their players for less than they bought them for - well except Di Maria.

And Ozil the season before and got a healthy 20m for Morata just last year. They seem to be funding large chunks of their signings with sales now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.