Shakesy
WW Head of Recruiting
Cause we want him!Why should we? He didn’t play for us the last two years.
Cause we want him!Why should we? He didn’t play for us the last two years.
More huge than paying the damned deferred wages?
Sound logic.Cause we want him!
But this is the level we are at right now... I mean, I surely get your point but isn't now the time to be pragmatic and strive to stabilize our position and create a fundament to built future success on?ha ha, wouldn’t come near us would he?
Who would of absolute top quality, unless they are doing it for the manager/club combo? When you answer that, you realise why we won’t be pulling out of this deal.
Getting our plan B, or C will be a piece of piss, because they won’t be a top rated footballer; we’ll be battling the likes of Villa or Lyon for his signature.
So weird how the UK media have gone so quiet on this deal for weeks now. I know they get their info from briefs within the club so if they're not reporting anything it's because the clubs not telling them anything but you'd think they'd of been something in response to everything that's still coming out of Spain
But this is the level we are at right now... I mean, I surely get your point but isn't now the time to be pragmatic and strive to stabilize our position and create a fundament to built future success on?
The logic has never been my strong suit.Sound logic.
Even as a basis for future success you still want to add the highest quality available. You aren’t going to achieve future success filling the squad with warm bodies.But this is the level we are at right now... I mean, I surely get your point but isn't now the time to be pragmatic and strive to stabilize our position and create a fundament to built future success on?
You don’t say!The logic has never been my strong suit.
We can only hope. What worries me (and many others it seems) it that time is not only ticking for Barca. It is also ticking for us and the clubs that currently have "our" alternatives. Because the later in the window the worse those deals will get.Isn’t that what Ten Hag is doing with the left back, Eriksen, Martinez etc?
And it’s what he’ll do if De Jong falls through, he’ll simply target a lesser player in that position to help us build.
Getting De Jong would be like taking a shortcut to Ten Hag-ball, but if he can’t get the shortcut, he’ll surely take something else.
I think you are right. I would imagine the last thing United want to do really, is pay Barca more than his contract is worth just because Barca owe him money. How we fudge that, assuming we have any any appetite for it, or do it in a way that doesn't have knock ons elsewhere, should be interesting. Assuming that this is a crux of the problem of course.
One thing that is often overlooked in player threads is the whole team aspect of football, and the possibility that the "lesser quality" players we sign could in fact form a team that performs to a higher level than the sum of its parts.Even as a basis for future success you still want to add the highest quality available. You aren’t going to achieve future success filling the squad with warm bodies.
That would imply that only the best available players would improve us. Which I don't think is the case. Midfield is an issue for quite some time. And we lost 2 players in that area on top of all that. So if the question is whether to bring in one potentially very good player or two good ones, I think we are better off with two good ones as right now, we have only two 2.5 decent ones.Even as a basis for future success you still want to add the highest quality available. You aren’t going to achieve future success filling the squad with warm bodies.
Wink first United! Wink for god's sake.
Maybe, maybe not might be too late in the window by the time we get to that pointIsn’t that what Ten Hag is doing with the left back, Eriksen, Martinez etc?
And it’s what he’ll do if De Jong falls through, he’ll simply target a lesser player in that position to help us build.
Getting De Jong would be like taking a shortcut to Ten Hag-ball, but if he can’t get the shortcut, he’ll surely take something else.
Hope we are willing to take the same type of approach with some of our youngsters as Chelsea did with Mount and City did with Foden. We have a couple of good young midfielders that should be more than capable of some cameo appearances in the league and some of the early rounds of the league Cup. We need a midfielder, and have for a while, but would rather we get a decent one in than get a second rate midfielder that will take some of those opportunities away from our young lads.
We've tried winking! And longing glances. And surreptitious smiles. Blinking is where it's at.Fixed
But that’s not what the other guy is saying. You can say we should get FDJ, David Nunez, Harland etc but the brutal reality is that we are not competitive with the likes with Bayern, City or Liverpool. Elite players want to go there. They don’t want to come here because whether we admit it or not have been talent killers for the past few years. The highest quality we can get and build upon may not be the A listers. That’s not the same as saying we just fill the team with warm bodies.Even as a basis for future success you still want to add the highest quality available. You aren’t going to achieve future success filling the squad with warm bodies.
We almost certainly do, unless we believe the new manager is a moron, probably a few plan b’s.
The drop off in quality from De Jong though is going to be huge.
Oh my goodness, what’s this new obsession around here for ‘Plan B’ - I feel like I’m taking crazy pills.
Nobody can seriously suggest with all our data analysts, scouts and contact networks that we don’t have a list of alternative players in case this deal doesn’t materialise.
The reason we haven’t heard about it yet is because it’s not necessary yet. The club must have encouragement that FDJ will sign, we know Barca need to sell and Frenkie is the managers top target. When the deal is impossible we will hear about the next target. For goodness sake, it’s not that hard!
He recruited pretty much the whole womens team too. He’s also been used in onboarding and chaperoning new signings. It’s all experience and it’s more than good old Ed ever did.
Isn’t that what Ten Hag is doing with the left back, Eriksen, Martinez etc?
And it’s what he’ll do if De Jong falls through, he’ll simply target a lesser player in that position to help us build.
Getting De Jong would be like taking a shortcut to Ten Hag-ball, but if he can’t get the shortcut, he’ll surely take something else.
We've tried winking! And longing glances. And surreptitious smiles. Blinking is where it's at.
This summer has been a combination of all the worst bits of our transfer strategy in the last decade, and we’re all just making excuses for it.
I'm not sure that concerns them too much, they fail to pay him, he walks away on a free for a massive sign on bonus; they go under, the same happens.Why would Bernado Silva, or any top player for that matter, sign for a club that may not exist in a few years?
Surely in Barca's current position, they can't play hard ball?What is De Jong's true market value? Or rather, what is his worth for us? How much of a difference would he make? Surely, in our current position, we can't pay hard ball.
Isn't he worth the agreed fee + deferred wages?
You'd think so, but they apparently areSurely in Barca's current position, they can't play hard ball?
Alternatively they’re just dithering idiots in the transfer market which they’ve proven time and time againYou'd think so, but they apparently are
Never thought I'd see a club run worse than United, but Barcelona have somehow managed to do it convincinglyAlternatively they’re just dithering idiots in the transfer market which they’ve proven time and time again
You're right, might be a bit overkill for a club like United. Can I suggest Draxler to better match your ambitions?Not just top teams. He also seems to be a back up for PSG as well.
The only thing they currently have over us is a less competitive league (hence they're still in the CL) and being based in a warmer, nicer (?) city.Never thought I'd see a club run worse than United, but Barcelona have somehow managed to do it convincingly
Hopefully he want to come to United. But if not. Another really good super creative and offensive option is Jude Bellingham. 19 years of age with a MV : 80 mill euros
Both of De Jong and Bellingham are high self confidence players. They have a belief they can dribble whole opponent team players.
And they do and able to dribbler past really many players.
And both of them have goals in them too. Both have good end product.
Yeah Ten Hag shall go for De Jong. But if in somehow. He is not coming. The next and really close to a top level of a creative and offensive player is Bellingham.
Only for Bellingham. The closest to the top level as possible. Not Tielemans United have been link too.
Tielemans is really good too. But i think and believe as the full packet. Both mentality, physical and ball skill and flair. Tielemans is not up there with De JOng and Bellingham.
If not De Jong. The best alternative option is Jude Bellingham. Like De JOng. Bellingham has a dominace presence. A dominant player. A player that take control and dictate a lot = Super creative and offensive.
Jude Bellingham is my best recomendation. Beside Frenkie De JOng Ten Hag and United are chasing.
Remember that Eriksen is one year younger than De Bruyne and just as old as Salah.Eriksen is a shortcut, but we need help in the base of midfield as well. Martinez can play there if de Jong doesn‘t come, or we move for a secondary dlp target. Who that is I have no idea.
Malacia is a player to build on for sure.
This summer has been a combination of all the worst bits of our transfer strategy in the last decade, and we’re all just making excuses for it.