UNITED ACADEMY
New Member
- Joined
- Aug 14, 2018
- Messages
- 13,127
- Supports
- Erik ten Hag
Their exact position on the pitch is different from the role they serve within the team. If Fred is #8, then you need a very different #6 than FdJ. If De Jong is #6, you need a very different #8 than Fred. Basically if you have De Jong, you want a Kante type to be your #8. If Fred is your #8, we want a Tchouameni type to be our #6. Ten Hag used Lasse Schone next to him in 2018/19 who is a much more reserved player. Van de Beek was the 10 that year too. De Jong if anything had the most freedom despite being in the deeper role.
Just because one player plays as a deeper midfielder or in the #6 position in a specific team and another plays as an 8, doesn't mean they would operate the same roles would they be in the same team. Fred isn't anywhere near secure enough defensively or positionally to work next to Frenkie de Jong. We'd be incredibly easy to play through. It's the same reason why Ruben Neves next to Fred would be a not good idea. They aren't defensive mids.
My point was trying to tell you that FDJ wouldn't replace Fred because neither play the same role and position. There are 10x better chance of FDJ plays as no 6 with Fred as no 8 than FDJ replaces Fred in no 8 role in ETH system.