Gaming FM 17 Club Draft | Final update is out

What should we do transferwise?

  • Allow a fixed maximum number of transfers each summer

  • Let in-game managers make transfer each summer

  • Stick with original squad

Results are only viewable after voting.
I think the duplication of a club is a good idea so that we are literally the same across the board. Finances, stadium sizes the lot.

I'd say having our rep as the best in he game would be the best option though, just so our players dont up and leave after season one :lol:

It'd be interesting to see Manchester with 21 Old Trafford's to be honest
 
Samid said:
You mean the nation that won the World Cup as opposed to the nation that didn't win the World Cup?
Click to expand...

The nation that will forever live off that 1 tournament win as opposed to the nation the won 2.
 
1. Spontaneus1 - L. Messi, J. Rodriguez, PE. Hojbjerg, L. Modric

2. Skizzo - Neymar, D. Alli, Romagnoli, R. Lukaku

3. anant - Dybala, Weigl, Coutinho,Laporte

4. harms - O. Dembele, J. Boateng, Ze Gomes, M. Neuer

5. @2mufc0 - Bale, T. Muller, S. Busquets, Marquinhos

6. hbgreg - Martial, T. Lemar, Iheanacho, J. Brandt, Lewis Cook; Manager: Luis Enrique

7. ADJUDICATOR - Griezmann, Kante, Dier, Oblak, Gelson Martins; Manager: Jorge Jesus

8. limerickcitykid - Ronaldo, Koke, Higuain, J. Gimenez, M. Kovacic; Manager: Wenger

9. P-Nut0712 - Pogba, Kroos, Reus, Rashford, Sterling; Manager: Tuchel

10. iammemphis - A. Sanchez, Courtois, F. Anderson, A. Horta, John Stones, Manager: Jurgen Klopp

11. Party Boy - Donnarumma, K. Coman, K. Benzema, J. Tah, L. Goretzka Manager: Joachim Low

12. Igor Drefljak - Hazard, Ozil, Nainggolan, De Gea, Morata Manager: J. Moaninho

13. Damien - K. Mbappé, C. Pulisic, K. Havertz, B. Henrichs, A. Christensen Manager: Jardim

14. Samid - R. Sanches, M. Asensio, G. Barbosa, N. Sule, Angel Correa Manager: A. Cunte

15. JTW95 - H. Kane, Varane, D. Berardi, H. Bellerin, S. Umtiti; Manager: M. Pochettino

16. oneniltothearsenal - Verratti, G. Jesus, Bonucci, F. Bernardeschi, A. Rabiot; Manager: U. Emery

17. Red-Man-Walking - Suarez, Icardi, B. Silva, J. Kimmich, R. Neves; Manager: Ancelotti

18. Tuppet - Alaba, Lewandowski, Hummels, T. Alcântara, C. Azpilicueta; Manager: Guardiola

19. MJJ - Aguero, De Bruyne, A. Vidal, Di Maria, G. Pique; Manager: Simeone

20. mazhar13 - S. Niguez, L. Sane, P. E. Aubameyang, D. Rugani, Fabinho; Manager: M. Allegri
 
I'm a fecking idiot it turns out. Wanted a different position filled but sent 2 picks that had already been picked and ended up with the back up.

Note to self. Decide on picks when you've not been up for a stupid long time
 
1. Spontaneus1 - L. Messi, J. Rodriguez, PE. Hojbjerg, L. Modric

2. Skizzo - Neymar, D. Alli, Romagnoli, R. Lukaku

3. anant - Dybala, Weigl, Coutinho,Laporte

4. @harms - O. Dembele, J. Boateng, Ze Gomes, M. Neuer

5. 2mufc0 - Bale, T. Muller, S. Busquets, Marquinhos, Lacazette; Manager: R. Koeman

6. hbgreg - Martial, T. Lemar, Iheanacho, J. Brandt, L. Cook; Manager: L. Enrique

7. ADJUDICATOR - Griezmann, Kante, Dier, Oblak, G. Martins; Manager: J. Jesus

8. limerickcitykid - Ronaldo, Koke, Higuain, J. Gimenez, M. Kovacic; Manager: Wenger

9. P-Nut0712 - Pogba, Kroos, Reus, Rashford, Sterling; Manager: Tuchel

10. iammemphis - A. Sanchez, Courtois, F. Anderson, A. Horta, J. Stones, Manager: J. Klopp

11. Party Boy - Donnarumma, K. Coman, K. Benzema, J. Tah, L. Goretzka Manager: J. Low

12. Igor Drefljak - Hazard, Ozil, Nainggolan, De Gea, Morata Manager: J. Moaninho

13. Damien - K. Mbappé, C. Pulisic, K. Havertz, B. Henrichs, A. Christensen Manager: Jardim

14. Samid - R. Sanches, M. Asensio, G. Barbosa, N. Sule, A. Correa Manager: A. Cunte

15. JTW95 - H. Kane, Varane, D. Berardi, H. Bellerin, S. Umtiti; Manager: M. Pochettino

16. oneniltothearsenal - Verratti, G. Jesus, Bonucci, F. Bernardeschi, A. Rabiot; Manager: U. Emery

17. Red-Man-Walking - Suarez, Icardi, B. Silva, J. Kimmich, R. Neves; Manager: Ancelotti

18. Tuppet - Alaba, Lewandowski, Hummels, T. Alcântara, C. Azpilicueta; Manager: Guardiola

19. MJJ - Aguero, De Bruyne, A. Vidal, Di Maria, G. Pique; Manager: Simeone

20. mazhar13 - S. Niguez, L. Sane, P. E. Aubameyang, D. Rugani, Fabinho; Manager: M. Allegri
 
1. Spontaneus1 - L. Messi, J. Rodriguez, PE. Hojbjerg, L. Modric

2. Skizzo - Neymar, D. Alli, Romagnoli, R. Lukaku

3. @anant - Dybala, Weigl, Coutinho, Laporte

4. harms - O. Dembele, J. Boateng, Ze Gomes, M. Neuer, J. Mata; Manager: M. Bielsa

5. 2mufc0 - Bale, T. Muller, S. Busquets, Marquinhos, Lacazette; Manager: R. Koeman

6. hbgreg - Martial, T. Lemar, Iheanacho, J. Brandt, L. Cook; Manager: L. Enrique

7. ADJUDICATOR - Griezmann, Kante, Dier, Oblak, G. Martins; Manager: J. Jesus

8. limerickcitykid - Ronaldo, Koke, Higuain, J. Gimenez, M. Kovacic; Manager: Wenger

9. P-Nut0712 - Pogba, Kroos, Reus, Rashford, Sterling; Manager: Tuchel

10. iammemphis - A. Sanchez, Courtois, F. Anderson, A. Horta, J. Stones, Manager: J. Klopp

11. Party Boy - Donnarumma, K. Coman, K. Benzema, J. Tah, L. Goretzka Manager: J. Low

12. Igor Drefljak - Hazard, Ozil, Nainggolan, De Gea, Morata Manager: J. Moaninho

13. Damien - K. Mbappé, C. Pulisic, K. Havertz, B. Henrichs, A. Christensen Manager: Jardim

14. Samid - R. Sanches, M. Asensio, G. Barbosa, N. Sule, A. Correa Manager: A. Cunte

15. JTW95 - H. Kane, Varane, D. Berardi, H. Bellerin, S. Umtiti; Manager: M. Pochettino

16. oneniltothearsenal - Verratti, G. Jesus, Bonucci, F. Bernardeschi, A. Rabiot; Manager: U. Emery

17. Red-Man-Walking - Suarez, Icardi, B. Silva, J. Kimmich, R. Neves; Manager: Ancelotti

18. Tuppet - Alaba, Lewandowski, Hummels, T. Alcântara, C. Azpilicueta; Manager: Guardiola

19. MJJ - Aguero, De Bruyne, A. Vidal, Di Maria, G. Pique; Manager: Simeone

20. mazhar13 - S. Niguez, L. Sane, P. E. Aubameyang, D. Rugani, Fabinho; Manager: M. Allegri
 
1. Spontaneus1 - L. Messi, J. Rodriguez, PE. Hojbjerg, L. Modric

2. @Skizzo - Neymar, D. Alli, Romagnoli, R. Lukaku

3. anant - Dybala, Weigl, Coutinho, Laporte, J.Alba

4. harms - O. Dembele, J. Boateng, Ze Gomes, M. Neuer, J. Mata; Manager: M. Bielsa

5. 2mufc0 - Bale, T. Muller, S. Busquets, Marquinhos, Lacazette; Manager: R. Koeman

6. hbgreg - Martial, T. Lemar, Iheanacho, J. Brandt, L. Cook; Manager: L. Enrique

7. ADJUDICATOR - Griezmann, Kante, Dier, Oblak, G. Martins; Manager: J. Jesus

8. limerickcitykid - Ronaldo, Koke, Higuain, J. Gimenez, M. Kovacic; Manager: Wenger

9. P-Nut0712 - Pogba, Kroos, Reus, Rashford, Sterling; Manager: Tuchel

10. iammemphis - A. Sanchez, Courtois, F. Anderson, A. Horta, J. Stones, Manager: J. Klopp

11. Party Boy - Donnarumma, K. Coman, K. Benzema, J. Tah, L. Goretzka Manager: J. Low

12. Igor Drefljak - Hazard, Ozil, Nainggolan, De Gea, Morata Manager: J. Moaninho

13. Damien - K. Mbappé, C. Pulisic, K. Havertz, B. Henrichs, A. Christensen Manager: Jardim

14. Samid - R. Sanches, M. Asensio, G. Barbosa, N. Sule, A. Correa Manager: A. Cunte

15. JTW95 - H. Kane, Varane, D. Berardi, H. Bellerin, S. Umtiti; Manager: M. Pochettino

16. oneniltothearsenal - Verratti, G. Jesus, Bonucci, F. Bernardeschi, A. Rabiot; Manager: U. Emery

17. Red-Man-Walking - Suarez, Icardi, B. Silva, J. Kimmich, R. Neves; Manager: Ancelotti

18. Tuppet - Alaba, Lewandowski, Hummels, T. Alcântara, C. Azpilicueta; Manager: Guardiola

19. MJJ - Aguero, De Bruyne, A. Vidal, Di Maria, G. Pique; Manager: Simeone

20. mazhar13 - S. Niguez, L. Sane, P. E. Aubameyang, D. Rugani, Fabinho; Manager: M. Allegri

Will update Manager in an hour or so
 
@Macern I wouldn't duplicate the players btw. For instance I wanted Martial but haven't got him. My manager could go buy the real Martial if you duplicate them which is sort of getting away from the whole point.
 
I'd assume he'd delete the players.

It may be best creating a club with the highest rep, 150k stadium and then duplicate that 20 times. Let our managers pick our coaches.
Everything would be the same from finances to facilities.
 
I would delete all the leagues and clubs. Make a league, a club with equal resources- duplicate that. In a new country where it takes a day to become homegrown etc.
 
P-Nut0712 said:
@Macern I wouldn't duplicate the players btw. For instance I wanted Martial but haven't got him. My manager could go buy the real Martial if you duplicate them which is sort of getting away from the whole point.
Click to expand...
Yeah I didn't think of that. Won't duplicate them then but that also rules out CL play since it'd be pointless.
 
ADJUDICATOR said:
I would delete all the leagues and clubs. Make a league, a club with equal resources- duplicate that. In a new country where it takes a day to become homegrown etc.
Click to expand...
And play without continental tournaments? I'd rather create two leagues from which top 4 goes to CL, for example - and I'd leave the other clubs, as beating United or Madrid (albeit weakened) is also part of the fun, imo.
 
Macern said:
Yeah I didn't think of that. Won't duplicate them then but that also rules out CL play since it'd be pointless.
Click to expand...

Sack it like Harms say even though they're weakened it will still be good to beat em

EDIT: Also are we going the pm route? Because I need to start deciding on 5 players and in which order if so
 
P-Nut0712 said:
Sack it like Harms say even though they're weakened it will still be good to beat em

EDIT: Also are we going the pm route? Because I need to start deciding on 5 players and in which order if so
Click to expand...
Ok. And yeah we're doing the pm method as described in the op
 
EVERYONE START WORKING ON YOUR PMS AND SEND THEM IN ASAP ONCE SKIZZO AND SPONT HAVE MADE THEIR PICK
 
Igor Drefljak said:
Are we doing 5 names at once?
Also, what happens if I picked Messi first and somebody else did also
Click to expand...

Might not be a bad idea to block them so that the other teams in Europe keep some of their players and make the CL interesting
 
Damien said:
We doing just five names or are we doing what someone suggested earlier and have an a, b, c etc system going
Click to expand...

I think it's 5 to begin with in order of preference. So most important 1st.

If a couple are picked before you so you've put then 3rd and someone else has them 2nd you fill in the blanks afterwards
 
Damien said:
Wouldn't it depend which was first in the 'order', assuming that Macern is still gonna continue the 1-20, 20-1 thing but by himself going from our lists.
Click to expand...

I don't think that counts in the PMs
 
Picks sent.
 
iammemphis said:
So im just PMing 5 names? Won't that mean we have 10 players each? Why not 11 names?
Click to expand...
More likely to have way more multiple picks with 11 names which will be a ballache as some people will end up way behind others. With 5, some will be at a disadvantage if their names are picked before by someone else but shouldn't be too much of a setback.
 
Damien said:
More likely to have way more multiple picks with 11 names which will be a ballache as some people will end up way behind others. With 5, some will be at a disadvantage if their names are picked before by someone else but shouldn't be too much of a setback.
Click to expand...
Okay so my 5 names should be posted in order of who i want the most? If nobody else has picked these names will i get all 5?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.