Books Fantasy Reads

definitely he planned it from the beginning. There is a character who makes an entrance in every Cosmere book.



Tigana is awesome. One of the few fantasy books I gave a 5/5 vote in Goodreads. The story, characters and the writing are all excellent. Next to 'Best Served Cold' is my favorite standalone book in the genre.
While he does appear in all the books so far, there are other characters who have appeared in multiple books. In fact, Stormlight Archive seem to be the place where they are all seeming to pop up.

A character from Elantris makes an appearance in The Way of Kings along with a character from the Mistborn series.
 
Rereading the Farseer Trilogy and having read the entire Realm of the Elderlings saga, I have to say that the world building is absolutely amazing; the writing is wonderful; and the manner in which we learn of the different magic and the extent of it is just perfect.
 
Finished Hobb's new book
I liked this trilogy a lot, would like to read the 3 parts in one go at some point but i thought it was one of her better trilogies
She really doesn't leave a single thread hanging, she did a brilliant job of tying everything up without any cheap or throwaway conclusions.

I kind of loved the end, was dreading it the whole book but it was a good end for the character
 
How do people rate Hobb's trilogies?

For me it is: Liveship Traders > Farseer > Fitz and Fool > Tawny Man >>> Rain Wild.
 
How do people rate Hobb's trilogies?

For me it is: Liveship Traders > Farseer > Fitz and Fool > Tawny Man >>> Rain Wild.

I might swap farseer and fitz and the fool and i'd probably add an extra > to tawny man.
 
I need to give Liveship another try. Started it after reading the farseer trilogy but gave up after about 30 pages because I was desperate to read more Fitz stuff and read Tawny man series instead.

I like the sound of that Kings of the Wylde book someone recommended a couple of pages back too.
 
I've tried reading Sanderson many times, but I just find him so very not good. I've also been checking out lots of debutantes and lesser known authors recently. I've read a few dozen new authors and tbf there have been a lot of misses- but also a fair few hits. I'll review a few of my more recent (and perhaps lesser known) reads that I feel may be worth checking out.

Among Thieves- Douglas Hulick.

If you like Locke Lamora (particularly the first book), I'd recommend this. It’s mostly all contained in a city so don’t expect epic fantasy here, but our protagonist-antihero-thief, Drothe, is very Locke-esque. He must use his wits, his luck and the muscle of his best friend to survive when he suddenly finds himself the target of every thug, bandit, cutthroat and grey prince in the underworld. It’s a very fun read and, from what I remember, it's the first in a trilogy. I’m yet to read the others though. 7/10


The Emperor’s Blades- Brian Staveley.

Like the above, it’s the first in a trilogy and, like the above, I’ve only read the first. (Though I am currently half way through the second.) It follows three royal children, one trained to be an elite warrior, one trained as a highly-disciplined monk and one as a court politician. When their father, the emperor is slain, they suddenly find themselves surrounded by enemies and hunted. Their only chance of survival is to unravel the conspiracy behind the emperor’s death. But their allies are few, their enemies many and, to top it all off, a war is brewing…. 7/10


Steelhaven Trilogy- Richard Ford

Unlike the above, I have read all three in this series since its non-stop action makes it almost impossible to put down. It follows the lives of various characters in a city under siege and, although it’s very action packed, it is also surprisingly well written, albeit sometimes quite raw, and contains well-timed humour and wonderfully developed heroes and villains. It's swords and blood, which is just how I like my fantasy. 8/10


The Braided Path Trilogy- Chris Wooding

Chris Wooding is maybe not as unknown as some of the others on the list but I think (though could be wrong) TBP trilogy is his first step into fantasy. And it shows, as each book just gets progressively better and more polished. The world is beautiful, arty and exotic- and very different. The story is compelling, the pace is fast and the magic is cool. 7/10


Kings of the Wyld – Nicholas Eames

This is a debut novel for someone who has the potential to become one of my favourite fantasy writers if this book is anything to go by. It’s high fantasy, which is not usually my cup of tea- I’m rarely a fan of dragons and orcs etc in my books- but this is just such an amazing and fun read. It’s Joe Abercrombie meets Harmonquest, and it’s as funny as both. It has heart, it has suspense, it has adventure- and it is utterly unputdownable. The dry humour in it is just perfect. My only regret is that I read it too fast and he doesn’t have any other books for me to bury myself in- yet. I was sceptical at first as the blurb didn't sell it very well, but I gave it a shot and I'm glad I did. It's ace. 9/10


I’m also reading The Ninth Rain by Jen Williams and The Thousand Names by Django Wexler at the moment. Both seem to be pretty solid reads, particularly the former which I am really enjoying.

Just came here to say I am on the last 100 pages of the Braided Path trilogy and think this is just brilliant. Some good Shocks and twists and great worldbuilding with a bit off Horror thrown into the mix.
The Emperor`s Blades is another trilogy I highly appreciated.

I would also recommend to check out Luke Scull, Acacia trilogy by Durham, Echoes of Empire by Mark Barnes, Heart of the World trilogy by Col Buchanan and Long Price Quartet by Daniel Abraham.
Those are some of my favorites when it Comes to newer/lesser known authors/series.

Also Greg Keyes "Kingdoms of Thorne and Bone" is great. And Miles Cameron of course.
 
I started on that but gave up. Couldn't really get interested into Rain Wild and Liveship despite couple of attempts. Is the new trilogy linked to RW?
Wtf? Liveship Traders is easily the best minisaga in Realms.

Rain Wild Traders is quite awful, but quite important for the third Fitz trilogy. You'll be lost in the end of the second Fitz book if you haven't read Rain Wild.
I guess having read liveships helped (which is brilliant tbf) but i really wasn't lost in the slightest at the end of the second : /

Incidentally i skipped Rain Wilds because a friend read it and said it was terrible.
And his standards are spectacularly low so i knew it was going to be utterly dire

What is all this heresy?! :mad: All of the Realms of the Elderlings novels (Farseer, Liveships, Rainwilds) are f*cking great and you simply are forbidden to skip any part of it :nono:

I heard of the new Fitz&Fool trilogy only weeks ago, when the final novel came out. Feck yes! Take note, Mr. Martin and Mr. Rothfuss... there are authors who simply get their books done ffs!
...But now I started the final book already :(
 
I just started book 1 in Fitz and the Fool. Let's see how this goes without reading IT it RwC.
The Rain Wilds chronicles only play a role from the end of book 2 onwards. Knowledge of it isn't really required, but you won't have the warm feeling of recognizing the protagonists :p
 
I don't personally rank them in any order. To me every one of the 5 series of the Elderling Realms has something special to set it apart, and there are memorable and relatable characters in all of them.
 
I'm almost midway through Kings of the Wylde and I'm not overly enjoying it. The not at all thinly veiled allegory(not sure if that's the right word but it's too hot to think) of being in a rock band that's reforming is really bloody distracting. It's a bit like the western aesthetic from Red Country, but its just not working. The world building feels like just throwing loads of fantasy creatures in there and hoping for the best. It's not terrible, but feels a bit childish and every time I get into it it just gets distracting with it's former rock band shenanigans. Last bit I read they seemed to get attacked by punks or glam rockers.

Not sure if I'll finish it as I haven't much time for reading and don't want to waste it.
 
What is all this heresy?! :mad: All of the Realms of the Elderlings novels (Farseer, Liveships, Rainwilds) are f*cking great and you simply are forbidden to skip any part of it :nono:

I heard of the new Fitz&Fool trilogy only weeks ago, when the final novel came out. Feck yes! Take note, Mr. Martin and Mr. Rothfuss... there are authors who simply get their books done ffs!
...But now I started the final book already :(
Rain Wild is one of the worst fantasy sagas I have ever read.
 
Fool's Assassin
Fitz and the Fool #1

Tedious. I can understand character building, but this is like a reading a treatise for single parents. Just feels like Hobb needed a trilogy and had to fill in a book with mostly irrelevant details. Only about 15-20 pages actually moves the story and I really don't get the relevance of the rest. The father/daughter dynamics was stretched to death, and then the melodrama with the Fool. Hopefully rest of books will explain the relevance or just be of better quality.

Whatever scraps of plot that she progressed herein was dreadfully obvious and I was hoping for a good twist which disappointingly never materialised.

And chapter titles, what the heck, Robin? Why did you have to spoiler the chapter by giving it an obvious title? The moment I saw titles like "A Healing" and "The Raid" I predicted what will happen in that chapter and was sadly accurate.

4/10. Probably the worse FitzChivalry Farseer book of the lot.
 
Fool's Assassin
Fitz and the Fool #1

Tedious. I can understand character building, but this is like a reading a treatise for single parents. Just feels like Hobb needed a trilogy and had to fill in a book with mostly irrelevant details. Only about 15-20 pages actually moves the story and I really don't get the relevance of the rest. The father/daughter dynamics was stretched to death, and then the melodrama with the Fool. Hopefully rest of books will explain the relevance or just be of better quality.

Whatever scraps of plot that she progressed herein was dreadfully obvious and I was hoping for a good twist which disappointingly never materialised.

And chapter titles, what the heck, Robin? Why did you have to spoiler the chapter by giving it an obvious title? The moment I saw titles like "A Healing" and "The Raid" I predicted what will happen in that chapter and was sadly accurate.

4/10. Probably the worse FitzChivalry Farseer book of the lot.

I liked the relatively mundane plot, it just felt well earned on fitz's part and you knew it wouldn't last.
Thought it was a good introduction to Bee too.

I just kind of liked the slower pace compared with her other work. Felt fresh which is a good trick after reading 9+ books by the writer
 
I stumbled into this thread a couple of weeks ago, and I've spent the last couple of weeks reading the entire thread. It is fascinating the differences of opinion on the various series discussed here.I have read a good hunk of the series discussed in the thread, and just to give an idea of my tastes, I loved the Wheel of Time (found the series in 1995 and followed it to the end), love ASOIAF (not as much as WoT, but still way up there), loved everything Sanderson has written to date, all of Cook's Black Company books plus his Garrett, P.I series, most of the Realm of the Elderlings (skipped Rain Wild), and have yet to read Rothfuss because he is even slower than Martin. And for the record, I have read most of the Malazan books, including the 10-book Book of the Fallen twice, the first four Esslemont novels, and the first four Bauchelain and Korbal Broach novellas. I have refused to read the remaining Esslemont novels and Erikson novellas, and haven't bothered to continue with the Kharkanas Trilogy, because I decided I couldn't continue to be a masochist.

I didn't find much discussion on Steven Brust's Vlad Taltos series, which I also love. Is that series unfamiliar to most posters here?

I am currently reading Abercrombie and on book 2 of the First Law. Has anyone read the Demon Cycle by Peter Brett, and is it worth the time?
 
I really enjoyed the Demon Cycle books, though must say that I didn't like the later books in the series quiet as much. Worth a read though, purely because the world itself is interesting.
 
Almost finished with the Rain Wild chronicles and it's actually much better than I thought it would be given how much it's been slated.
It's not that bad even though it's not as good as the Liveships trilogy.
 
And for the record, I have read most of the Malazan books, including the 10-book Book of the Fallen twice, the first four Esslemont novels, and the first four Bauchelain and Korbal Broach novellas. I have refused to read the remaining Esslemont novels and Erikson novellas, and haven't bothered to continue with the Kharkanas Trilogy, because I decided I couldn't continue to be a masochist.

:lol: I've read all novellas except Bauchelain and Korbal Broach books. Started on the Kharkanas and Dancer trilogies and like them till date. They are standalone so it doesn't feel as heavy as the Malazan series. And since it's not finished, you get enough time between books to nake make it tedious.


Halfway through Book 2 in Fitz and Fool and like what I'm reading in this books so far.
 
What have you read, what do you like?
Read is a pretty long list. Almost everything mainstream that you can think of - ASOIAF, wot, kingkiller, first law, broken empire, ryria revelations, Dresden Files, mistborn, storm light archive, realm of Elderlings.

Couldn't get into malazan when I tried it the one time.

Looking for something which can be classified as light reading.
 
I really enjoyed the Demon Cycle books, though must say that I didn't like the later books in the series quiet as much. Worth a read though, purely because the world itself is interesting.
Demon Cycle is one of the most frustrating series I have ever read. The premise is fantastic - demons living in the centre of the planet and coming out at night to attack humanity, the knowledge of how to fight them properly lost - and the first book is brilliant. But then the books get progressively worse, the second is still pretty good, the third is alright, but the fourth is utter garbage. I was so mad after reading that fourth book, because the series had so much potential, and it was ruined beyond hope of redemption.
 
Read is a pretty long list. Almost everything mainstream that you can think of - ASOIAF, wot, kingkiller, first law, broken empire, ryria revelations, Dresden Files, mistborn, storm light archive, realm of Elderlings.

Couldn't get into malazan when I tried it the one time.

Looking for something which can be classified as light reading.
Read Gentleman Bastards or anything by Robin Hobb? Kings of the Wyld maybe.
 
Last edited:
The queen's Poisoner is fairly light reading and decent. It's the first in a completed trilogy and you might like it. I enjoyed them.
 
Read is a pretty long list. Almost everything mainstream that you can think of - ASOIAF, wot, kingkiller, first law, broken empire, ryria revelations, Dresden Files, mistborn, storm light archive, realm of Elderlings.

Couldn't get into malazan when I tried it the one time.

Looking for something which can be classified as light reading.
The Witcher saga by Sajkowski. Quite good and very different to anything else in the genre.
 
Read Gentleman Bastards or anything by Robin Hobb? Kings of the Wyld maybe.

Planning on reading Gentleman Bastards when the series is closer to completion. I am rereading Farseer Trilogy so want to take a break from Hobb.

The queen's Poisoner is fairly light reading and decent. It's the first in a completed trilogy and you might like it. I enjoyed them.

Will look at this. Thanks.

The Witcher saga by Sajkowski. Quite good and very different to anything else in the genre.

Is there a recommended reading order for the Witcher Saga?
 
Planning on reading Gentleman Bastards when the series is closer to completion. I am rereading Farseer Trilogy so want to take a break from Hobb.



Will look at this. Thanks.



Is there a recommended reading order for the Witcher Saga?
Yep. The Last Wish should be read first, then the other book of short stories, and then the 5 novels. Some people skip the two books of short stories and jump directly into novels, but I would recommend against it.
 
Looking for something which can be classified as light reading.

City of Stairs - A light read. Different and nice.
Aeronaut's Windlass - Steampunk by Jim Butcher. 1st in an uncompleted series though. Still good as standalone.
Tales of Ketty Jay - Light steampunk read.
Iron Druid Chronicles - Something like Dreseden but more outrageously fantasy (though story is not as good) but thouroughly entertaining, provided you don't expect too much of a critical output.
Johannes Cabal Necromancer - A kind of black comedy/satirical book. Excellent read.

None of them are critically good fantasy books. Just pass the time light read. More for time pass entertainment factor than serious books.
 
Yep. The Last Wish should be read first, then the other book of short stories, and then the 5 novels. Some people skip the two books of short stories and jump directly into novels, but I would recommend against it.
Thanks for this.
City of Stairs - A light read. Different and nice.
Aeronaut's Windlass - Steampunk by Jim Butcher. 1st in an uncompleted series though. Still good as standalone.
Tales of Ketty Jay - Light steampunk read.
Iron Druid Chronicles - Something like Dreseden but more outrageously fantasy (though story is not as good) but thouroughly entertaining, provided you don't expect too much of a critical output.
Johannes Cabal Necromancer - A kind of black comedy/satirical book. Excellent read.

None of them are critically good fantasy books. Just pass the time light read. More for time pass entertainment factor than serious books.

Thanks for the recommendations. Was looking for something like this only :D

If I am not mistaken Butcher wrote another series on a dare. If I am not mistaken the premise was Roman legions along with Pokémon or something like that. Is that Aero aunt's Windlass or some other series?
 
If I am not mistaken Butcher wrote another series on a dare. If I am not mistaken the premise was Roman legions along with Pokémon or something like that. Is that Aero aunt's Windlass or some other series?

Nah, this is good steampunk. It still lacks a bit of character and world building, but since this is just the first book...I can wait.

Necromancer is also very well written. Quirky, darkly comic and needs getting used to. I lived it.

Iron Druid is just a roller coaster of fantasy. It's Irish mythology based but you get a mix of Indian, Nordic, Greek and Japanese mythology thrown in for good measure. Like watching a CGI action movie and appreciating it despite a weak plot.
 
Last edited:
:D

If I am not mistaken Butcher wrote another series on a dare. If I am not mistaken the premise was Roman legions along with Pokémon or something like that. Is that Aero aunt's Windlass or some other series?

That's the Codex Alera series.
 
For someone like me who had hitherto read more serious fantasy like Wheel of Time and ASOIAF and Malazan,and Stormlight, and Elderlings, etc., the Codex Alera exploded on me like a bomb. It was action-packed from beginning to end. I couldn't put it down once I started. The story itself requires quite a bit of suspension of disbelief, but I didn't much care about the holes in the story, the books were so gripping. After the Codex Alera I gulped down the Dresden Files at the same breakneck speed and loved it. If you don't care about characters spending half a book thinking deep thoughts about philosophy, for 10 books, and you only want a rip-roaring story to enjoy, Jim Butcher's books are hard to beat. The Aeronaut's Windlass, the first book in his new series, is much more subdued than the two earlier series, but it looks like the following books could pick up steam. I can't wait for more Dresden and Aeronaut books.
 
Finally finished Fitz and the Fool trilogy

Overall a decent read, but falls short of a classic. The series feels bloated with more than required melodrama. The final book could have been at least a 100 pages shorter to make it a crisp story. Needlessly lengthy descriptions that somehow doesn't bring out true emotions. Like watching a Susan Sarandon movie. It irks me a lot as just when the action moves at a good pace, it gets bogged down in some descriptive suffering. For all the complexit of "dreams" it feels like the plot was very flaky and progresses quite linearly.

And you couldn't have asked for a more cliched ending than this.

6/10