He's off. He looked it in the replay.
FA Cup 5th round: 28/2/25 - 3/3/25
- Thread starter IRN-BRUno
- Start date
What's the point of the auto offside if we aren't shown anything - and I could see Sher was offside with the naked eye first time
Does Gordon miss the Carabou Cup final?
How is welbeck still playing? Feel like he's been around for decades
His first one was pretty brain-dead, too.
2 red cards? Tonali's bet is coming in boys
Ha meant to type stupid
That's easy win for Liverpool then.
Stupid offside, this rule is stupid.
It’s natural that the attackers chest will be leaning forwards because he’s going in the direction of the goal.
Here, both of Newcastle’s player feet were behind the defender, how does that constitue gaining an unfair advantage?
It’s natural that the attackers chest will be leaning forwards because he’s going in the direction of the goal.
Here, both of Newcastle’s player feet were behind the defender, how does that constitue gaining an unfair advantage?
This new offside detector looks just as "fast" as the old one.
Why does the ref have a microphone? Even if there are numpties in the crowd who don't know what the ref's hand signal mean, there are massive screens showing the decision.
Because he's ahead of the Brighton player. You can control or even score with your chest.
Offside is pretty simple.
Absolute belter of a game of football to be fair.
Think it was decided to add that recently. Feel like I read about it few days ago but thought it would only be added from July 1st.
Newcastle boo boys are back.
What's the point of it though? It's just one more technical thing that can go wrong and nobody needs to hear from the ref when there are big feck off screens to tell the crowd what is happening.
Not at Old Trafford there isn't.
Great game this!
It's any part of the body that can play the ball. Simple really.
He has a microphone to communicate with the other refs. They are trialing a new "feature" where ref explains the decision to the crowd, like it is in American sports. I think its intended audience is in the scouse areas.
That's fair but we all know what it means when the ref signals offside.
Change for the sake of change. Bleh!
Not surprised given who it is and who he plays for.
And as a red will miss League Cup Final? Idiot
I wonder if Brighton will be painted as pantomime villains if they go on to win this game, now…
Will lucky Liverpool now face Newcastle in league cup final without Gordon after that straight red?
Just like lucky United played Newcastle without Nick Pope.
It's Tony Gordon, let's not pretend Newcastle will be without prime Messi.
Wait till they bring in NFL microphones and such. It’s gonna get annoying.
I don't last when I push too hardI'd fancy my chances against any of these footballers in a pub fight. Weaklings can't even last a little push
Great save from Livramento!
Handball rules are so random.
That Wieffer shot clearly hit a sort of out stretched arm doesnt it? Not even checked.
That Wieffer shot clearly hit a sort of out stretched arm doesnt it? Not even checked.
A million replays,commentators egging it on and ref going over to the screen if that's against us.
I have no idea how that's not a pen. Clearly stops a shot on target with an out stretched arm.
What the (van) Hecke was that?
Yeah, I mean, I don't care whether it's a pen in this case, but why it's not even looked at...
They must just flip a coin I guess.
Pope wouldn't have saved either goals in the league cup final 2023.
ITV, Keane, Wright all fine it’s not “he has to out his hand somewhere?”
Yes, he could put it behind his body and not leaving it sticking it out.
Welbeck scores.
That guy Welbz
Great finish Danny!!