Erik ten Hag | Currently unemployed
- Thread starter Panther
- Start date
Is their potential better then us? We spend so much time downplaying our club it's untrue. We're not playing well, our team is awful, but on what planet does a manager or a player turn United down for RB?
If he does, good for him, but I'd be amazed.
How they doing this season?
On this planet. We also don't have any positive potential with this ownership and board. Smart ones will steer clear. We are all about history and there's no evidence based on recent years that we are a serious football club.
Think this is more ten Hag and his agent putting pressure on United to accept his terms.
Would not surprise me one bit.
I don't think he will go there but overtaking Dortmund would not be out of the equation. They are losing Haaland, Witsel, Can(?), Reus is really getting on like Hummels. Noise about Akanji not being happy, Brandt can be good then very average the next game. Reyna and Bellingham are their future stars but we all know Jude will be in the PL in a year or two.
Given a good budget he could clearly do it. But i'm sure it's bs and he's already agreed to join United.
There's no reason for Leipzig to sack their manager who saved their season after Marsch.
It could be a stepping stone to a huge club like Real or Bayern though. Managing us is pretty much career suicide at this point.
Surely if they were looking for easy clicks and to stir the pot they'd of said Dortmund. Because Leipzig only appointed Tedesco a few months ago and has done well including getting a very good result over Dortmund a few weeks ago.They read the caf ridiculing that they couldn't even name the German club and then named Leipzig
It's odd because it makes no sense to make up Leipzig links but also weird if it is true since they've recently got a new manager who's doing quite well.
The last job is the one that counts isn't it? Especially since the last two for these particular managers were considered step ups. They both lost stock in England but could re-emerge. Same thing with Espirito Santo after success with Wolves and failure with Spurs. Mulensteen didn't get any offers in England after failing at Fulham
Not really, as it didn't really destroy any of the last 4 permanent managers' careers despite their failures.
This unnamed Bundesliga club does sound like a massive bluff but I do like that ten Hag is making demands of the club.
We need a manager who has presence and who will be respected by the players. If more control gives him that the club should absolutely agree to it.
We need a manager who has presence and who will be respected by the players. If more control gives him that the club should absolutely agree to it.
I think its safe to say Solskjaer won't be getting any offers from a club in Europe's top leagues, but again you'd rightly argue he should never have managed us.
But them being dutch had nothing to do with their failures, or do you think they failed because of their nationality?
The only way I see Ten Hag choosing Red Bull over us is if he asked for certain control and the board didn't agreed.
Looking how we've been managed the last 10 years it's not surprising if a promising manager wants to skip us if he doesn't think he'll be given enough power to impact the team in the way he wants.
No way he goes to Leipzig over Man United. One is a step down, the other a step upwards. Even if there's a muddy puddle on that upwards step in which you'll sink in with your shoes.
Also, he already turned down Leipzig in the past.
Also, he already turned down Leipzig in the past.
We're a free hit these days, you can come in, completely feck up and people will still believe you if you say it's the board or the players.
I will give you Ole, but it's not like his career was going anywhere with Molde. Being a United manager will remain the highlight of his career. It's not something he will ever regret.
You would think so, he'd only look to leave Leipzig for Bayern in a few years anyway. United could be career defining work for him if he want's the challenge, and I'm sure Leipzig would still hire him if the United job goes to shit anyway.
Like anyone with an atom of ambition would choose Leipzig over United.
The leaks are briefings from ETH's camp to pressure United to accept his sporting demands. Personally I'm delighted he is taking such an approach, it let's us know how serious United are and if we can genuinely be hopeful of any meaningful change moving forward.
That's not common practice at top clubs at all. A manager doesn't provide his own list of options. At most, he'll provide player profiles for what he thinks the squad needs. Then the scouting apparatus gets to work to deliver options, and eventually, the top ones make it to high-level discussion within the club.
Consequently, that 'huge command' is largely limited to setting profile priorities and having a larger voice (possibly a veto) at those final discussions.
After all, the whole point of a well-structured DOF system is to not let the coach be the main voice in recruitment, to safeguard continuity and a more holistic outlook.
I doubt it. If Ten Hag wanted to do that, he wouldn't just bat every media question away and provide 'tactical' responses instead. I think it's rather journalists desperately trying to create stories.
It seems some of our ‘fans’ think otherwise
Moyes had to go to Sociedad because no-one else would touch him and is only rebuilding his reputation now at West Ham.
LvG didn't get another top level management gig until the NT turnstile came round again.
Mourinho has been on a downward slope ever since he left.
Ole doesn't even have a management career left to speak of after Ray Finkeling it here.
Can any of these guys say their time here didn't harm their reputation?
As a tactically ambitious coach I could see Ten Hag demand some kind of veto right. Signing an expensive player, who doesn't fit his football idea could cause endless headaches for him. Arguably the club needs to commit very hard to his ideas for things to work out well.
I mean, I definitely wouldn’t count his unsuccessful job at Fulham as a step up from Spurs a few years earlier tbh. He did better in the bigger job.
They have no ambition.
While I tend to agree with this we have the compounding factor of De Gea passing the ball to Maguire, AWB and McTominay and Fred. If we add 2-3 players comfortable in possession then everyone else's job gets easier too.
Has any manager every failed at a club and not seen their reputation suffer to some degree? That's the way it always has and should work. None of them really dropped off from their previous level apart from Mourinho and even he got a Champions league contender. LVG basically said he was retiring, but I'm sure if he wanted a job at a mid-table team in a decent European league he would have gotten it.
In terms of players needing to be comfortable on the ball goalkeeper is a distant last. Until we upgrade full backs, centre mids etc Gk can wait.
Yes but has any other top club around Europe appointed four failed managers in a row after winning the league?
AC Milan are on their ninth.
Moyes got a decent job at a good Spanish club means it wasn't career suicide. It just meant a top club won't touch him again, which was always the case.
LVG was always retiring. If he wanted a job in Germany or Holland, he would've got it.
Mourinho went to a club that has been on a similar level to United since SAF retired just a few months after he had been sacked. They were even a CL team that season and we were in the EL.
Ole didn't really have any noteworthy career, finishing 2nd and 3rd in the PL will remain the highlight of his career.
It may have harmed their reputation a bit, but the job was very far from being career suicide.
League season in Holland is only 34 games right? Hopefully PSV slip up soon and we only have another 2 weeks of this.
If ETH comes to Utd and fails it will damage his reputation and that’s why he’s doing right thing by setting out demands before he accepts it. Arnold, Murtough, Fletcher, Bout, Lawlor and numerous others won’t lose their jobs if it all goes wrong but ETH will.
watch him end up at Dortmund or Leipzig
If a manager turning down Manchester United for Borsussia Dortmund or RB Lepizig isn't a massive wake-up call and kick up the arse then I don't know what is. Protest time to oust our shithouse owners once and for all I'd say if it happens.