The Firestarter
Full Member
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2010
- Messages
- 30,274
Hyperloop is a solution to traffic problems in the same way flying cars are a solution to traffic problems. In that they aren't.Saying Hyperloop isn't a solution to anything is a bit short-sighted I feel. It's like saying cars aren't a solution to anything because we have horse carriages.
Reinvented? He created pizza in the first place!I bet he's reinvented the pizza
It’s surprising for me to say this but here is a amazing article on the great potential of the Hyperloop
I for one think Elon should go and discuss this at the closest Saudi embassy
As far as I understand the vision basically consists of two parts:Hyperloop is a solution to traffic problems in the same way flying cars are a solution to traffic problems. In that they aren't.
As far as I understand the vision basically consists of two parts:
1. Connect major cities to enable travel and cargo transports at far greater speeds
2. Building tunnel systems beneath huge cities to shift some traffic below the surface
Would you say current subway systems are a good thing and help reducing traffic on the streets? If yes, I can't see how you say that a Hyperloop network wouldn't have any benefits.
But for me the even bigger part is that it has the potential to make domestic flights obsolete and thus playing a significant part in reducing carbon emissions.
Just a german example: A flight from Munich to Berlin takes about 1 hour. Going by train takes 6 hours. Of course many people take a flight. If there would be a Hyperloop connection taking ~2 hours, I don't think anybody would decide to take the flight anymore.
If Musk manages to fullfil his greatest dream and really be the driving force and maybe single most responsible person for making us a inter-planetary species by creating permanent settlements on the Mars, will you still laugh about this comparison?Elon Musk being compared to Da Vinci, I'm constantly surprised by this forum.
Why do you think that?I think you've taken the absolute faintest whiff of what the concept is and run wild with it.
Yeah, for me his greatest achievement was selling the 7 houses he somehow found himself owning.but at least he's not like other billionaires that use their money to buy the 10th mansion,
Yeah being one of the most important persons in vastly reducing the biggest factor that will otherwise lead to a huge climate catastrophe is certainly no achievement.at the bit about “achievements and what he is doing for mankind” please stop it’s pathetic and very cult like
One-upping NASA and enabling further space exploration obviously neither.
Do you remember the time before people were able to drive their Teslas around space?
Why do you think that?
The part of connecting huge cities for very fast and carbon neutral travel and cargo transports was basically the pitch when Hyperloop was founded and how it was presented to universities (there were several competitions where universities around the world had the task to build the fastest pod).
And the huge tunnel systems (that could be used for Hyperloop pods) below big cities were the main argument I frequently heard then The Boring Company was founded.
I'm open to learn if you have differing information to share.
Musk may not be a sports star or actor but he's a celeb in his own right. And active on social media too.Not really involved in this debate but I just find the concept of an "Elon Musk fan" weird. He's not a sports star or an actor, just a bloke that has a couple of companies. Does Bill Gates have this type of following?
Leonardo Da Vinci was one of the most incredible humans to ever live, his breadth of actual expertise and talents were ridiculous. Musk is an intelligent business man, he has a talent for successfully building up companies. He is not going to be the 'single most responsible person for making us a inter-planetary species', because he is literally just running the companies that are trying to achieve these things. Deciding you want to go to Mars and then not actually doing any of the work involved and just milking engineers and other talented people for all they are worth is in no way comparable to the things Da Vinci did and the ideas he had himself, as one person.If Musk manages to fullfil his greatest dream and really be the driving force and maybe single most responsible person for making us a inter-planetary species by creating permanent settlements on the Mars, will you still laugh about this comparison?
I really think that kids in a few centuries will learn about Musk as one of the most important persons in the history of humankind.
You can laugh about this and we won't be able to judge this unfortunately, but I really believe it.
And just to say it again: I really don't like him as a person. I dislike most of his political statements and I hate his stance and comments on Covid.
But I only have respect and admiration for what he has achieved and how he contributed to drive our species forward.
Yes his tax evasion can be critized, he could donate much more money, but at least he's not like other billionaires that use their money to buy the 10th mansion, 5th yacht or 3rd private jet. He uses his money to continue building companies that benefit millions of people. According to himself and people close to him he works 70 to 80 hours every week. How can you not have respect for his work ethic and his achievements despite the issues regarding his personality?
I think the cultish following bizarre, but equally I find people's need to deride his company's acievements because he didn't singlehandedly design and build every component in the SpaceX rockets strange.
He's clearly an extremely talented businessman with great vision who is able to put together and motivate excellent teams and drive these advances. He's also obviously an attention-seeking, moany tax-dodging manchild with it.
This whole thread is strange.
Maybe not deriding his companies' achievements, more like they happened despite Musk rather than giving him any credit for it.I don’t really see many people deriding his companies’ achievements. I think most people congratulate them, but draw the distinction between the company’s achievement, eg landing a reusable rocket, and Musk’s achievement, founding/investing in/ being a figurehead of a company that landed a reusable rocket.
What gets my back up is both he and his fans would say there is no distinction, and his excuse for not paying taxes is particularly unpalatable for me.
I think the cultish following bizarre, but equally I find people's need to deride his company's acievements because he didn't singlehandedly design and build every component in the SpaceX rockets strange.
He's clearly an extremely talented businessman with great vision who is able to put together and motivate excellent teams and drive these advances. He's also obviously an attention-seeking, moany tax-dodging manchild with it.
This whole thread is strange.
It's not really the same though, there is one degree of separation between a football manager and their players, we have no real idea what Musk is coming up with himself and at what level. What actual novel ideas has he himself personally developed? I've no problem saying he's a great businessman, but I don't put much stock in that in terms of astounding humans.Maybe not deriding his companies' achievements, more like they happened despite Musk rather than giving him any credit for it.
Like people saying SAF's success was purely down to his team, not him.
His tax excuse is ridiculous, yet some almost see his approach as noble, not taking a salary.
He certainly provokes strong reactions.