lex talionis
Full Member
- Joined
- Jul 25, 2017
- Messages
- 16,053
His career with United will be short, but not soon forgotten. What a man.
Came in here to mention this. His face when he walked into the shot of the other players celebrating was hilariousMentioned it in the game thread, he gives a look as he goes to celebrate with Ronaldo that just says "feck me this guy takes the piss".
I’m baffled by all this talk of him being a real man, if only we’d signed him earlier etc. He’s become some sort of cult hero and I just find it really strange. I thought at the end of last season he was superb. EL final he was easily our best player for me and one of only a few who didn’t deserve to lose the game……but aside from that he’s done next to nothing, at all.
League and CL :-
Cavani 38 appearances 11 goals
Ronaldo 11 appearances 9 goals
I get not everyone has to be Ronaldo but he’s done less than A LOT of players have and somehow earned this Demi God recognition for what I’m not sure?
The only player I have any sort of regard for aside from actual footballing performances is Rashford, he’s done something special. I’m not sure anyone else including Cavani deserves any mention for human praise.
Youre all weird
You do seem to have an odd axe to grind with Cavani.I’m baffled by all this talk of him being a real man, if only we’d signed him earlier etc. He’s become some sort of cult hero and I just find it really strange. I thought at the end of last season he was superb. EL final he was easily our best player for me and one of only a few who didn’t deserve to lose the game……but aside from that he’s done next to nothing, at all.
League and CL :-
Cavani 38 appearances 11 goals
Ronaldo 11 appearances 9 goals
I get not everyone has to be Ronaldo but he’s done less than A LOT of players have and somehow earned this Demi God recognition for what I’m not sure?
The only player I have any sort of regard for aside from actual footballing performances is Rashford, he’s done something special. I’m not sure anyone else including Cavani deserves any mention for human praise.
Youre all weird
Nothing to grind with Edi….he’s fine. But that’s all. Nothing more. He hasn’t been great. He hasn’t been anything but he’s been fine. He’s had some good games. My axe is with people acting like he’s been anything more than that. People act like he deserves a statue and I’m thinking Scholes, Giggs, Becks, Ruud, RVP, Stam, Keane, Schmeichel, Bruce, Pallister, Evra, Vidic etc etc etc….like Cavani has done nothing at all. He’s been alright. He was underwhelming for most of last season but didn’t cost anything. Other than that had a good end to the season. Has done nothing yet this season.You do seem to have an odd axe to grind with Cavani.
What? I mean he’s fine but so what….he hasn’t done anything of note.Er no, you're weird. There's plenty to like about Edi.
I’m baffled by all this talk of him being a real man, if only we’d signed him earlier etc. He’s become some sort of cult hero and I just find it really strange. I thought at the end of last season he was superb. EL final he was easily our best player for me and one of only a few who didn’t deserve to lose the game……but aside from that he’s done next to nothing, at all.
League and CL :-
Cavani 38 appearances 11 goals
Ronaldo 11 appearances 9 goals
I get not everyone has to be Ronaldo but he’s done less than A LOT of players have and somehow earned this Demi God recognition for what I’m not sure?
The only player I have any sort of regard for aside from actual footballing performances is Rashford, he’s done something special. I’m not sure anyone else including Cavani deserves any mention for human praise.
Youre all weird
I’m baffled by all this talk of him being a real man, if only we’d signed him earlier etc. He’s become some sort of cult hero and I just find it really strange. I thought at the end of last season he was superb. EL final he was easily our best player for me and one of only a few who didn’t deserve to lose the game……but aside from that he’s done next to nothing, at all.
League and CL :-
Cavani 38 appearances 11 goals
Ronaldo 11 appearances 9 goals
I get not everyone has to be Ronaldo but he’s done less than A LOT of players have and somehow earned this Demi God recognition for what I’m not sure?
The only player I have any sort of regard for aside from actual footballing performances is Rashford, he’s done something special. I’m not sure anyone else including Cavani deserves any mention for human praise.
Youre all weird
What's weird about admiring one of the best strikers in the history of the game? A true proffessional he is. His career is almost over but he still works his socks off every single game and does everything he can for the team. I've never seen a striker who runs back as much as him, works as hard as him to win the ball back all over the pitch yet at the same time scores such an incredible amount of goals throughout his career.I’m baffled by all this talk of him being a real man, if only we’d signed him earlier etc. He’s become some sort of cult hero and I just find it really strange. I thought at the end of last season he was superb. EL final he was easily our best player for me and one of only a few who didn’t deserve to lose the game……but aside from that he’s done next to nothing, at all.
League and CL :-
Cavani 38 appearances 11 goals
Ronaldo 11 appearances 9 goals
I get not everyone has to be Ronaldo but he’s done less than A LOT of players have and somehow earned this Demi God recognition for what I’m not sure?
The only player I have any sort of regard for aside from actual footballing performances is Rashford, he’s done something special. I’m not sure anyone else including Cavani deserves any mention for human praise.
Youre all weird
He scores some important goals and has a fantastic work ethic. It’s easy to see why he’s a fan favouriteNothing to grind with Edi….he’s fine. But that’s all. Nothing more. He hasn’t been great. He hasn’t been anything but he’s been fine. He’s had some good games. My axe is with people acting like he’s been anything more than that. People act like he deserves a statue and I’m thinking Scholes, Giggs, Becks, Ruud, RVP, Stam, Keane, Schmeichel, Bruce, Pallister, Evra, Vidic etc etc etc….like Cavani has done nothing at all. He’s been alright. He was underwhelming for most of last season but didn’t cost anything. Other than that had a good end to the season. Has done nothing yet this season.
Everyone knew that his fitness after leaving PSG was super suspect and we signed him to be the perfect sub and impact to young squad in tough games. And he has delivered that role with his ethics and game performance. He ain't on that prime level anymore but can still be model pro.I’m baffled by all this talk of him being a real man, if only we’d signed him earlier etc. He’s become some sort of cult hero and I just find it really strange. I thought at the end of last season he was superb. EL final he was easily our best player for me and one of only a few who didn’t deserve to lose the game……but aside from that he’s done next to nothing, at all.
League and CL :-
Cavani 38 appearances 11 goals
Ronaldo 11 appearances 9 goals
I get not everyone has to be Ronaldo but he’s done less than A LOT of players have and somehow earned this Demi God recognition for what I’m not sure?
The only player I have any sort of regard for aside from actual footballing performances is Rashford, he’s done something special. I’m not sure anyone else including Cavani deserves any mention for human praise.
Youre all weird
He scores some important goals and has a fantastic work ethic. It’s easy to see why he’s a fan favourite
Not sure if youre old enough to remember Henrik Larssons time with Utd, but it's pretty much universally remembered in a very positive light.I’m baffled by all this talk of him being a real man, if only we’d signed him earlier etc. He’s become some sort of cult hero and I just find it really strange. I thought at the end of last season he was superb. EL final he was easily our best player for me and one of only a few who didn’t deserve to lose the game……but aside from that he’s done next to nothing, at all.
League and CL :-
Cavani 38 appearances 11 goals
Ronaldo 11 appearances 9 goals
I get not everyone has to be Ronaldo but he’s done less than A LOT of players have and somehow earned this Demi God recognition for what I’m not sure?
The only player I have any sort of regard for aside from actual footballing performances is Rashford, he’s done something special. I’m not sure anyone else including Cavani deserves any mention for human praise.
Youre all weird
What do you want him to do? Win a cl final in the middle of the season or what?What? I mean he’s fine but so what….he hasn’t done anything of note.
Baffles me though. I feel like I’m reading Bryan Robsons threadYou do one of these a week and we’re the weird ones?
What's weird about admiring one of the best strikers in the history of the game? A true proffessional he is. His career is almost over but he still works his socks off every single game and does everything he can for the team. I've never seen a striker who runs back as much as him, works as hard as him to win the ball back all over the pitch yet at the same time scores such an incredible amount of goals throughout his career.
Nope, we are not being weird we are simply showing gratitude to an all time great.
I’m baffled by all this talk of him being a real man, if only we’d signed him earlier etc
Baffles me though. I feel like I’m reading Bryan Robsons thread
Nothing to do with the week, certainly nothing to do with our bizarre manager’s bizarre comments. I didn’t think he was superb against Spurs though but his goal was a nice finish. It’s comments about him as if he’s some kind of super hero. Like he’s Bryan Robson. You might disagree, fine. No need to post whiney little responses. I’m asking genuine questions you don’t seem to like it. No worries it’s all opinions.You posted the same whiney post last week.
Since your post last week the manager has told you that rather than see his arse over being unfairly benched this season, he put in the best training performance he’d ever seen. He followed that up by being superb and scoring a lovely goal versus Spurs, and was subsequently benched again for Atalanta. Not a complaint from the man, just came on & worked his ass off like always.
Yet that week has caused you to come back again and whinge about Cavani? What the feck is wrong with you?
I see that from one side, but in terms of what he’s done purely for us…I’d reserve that for RVP for example.What's wrong with saying "we should have signed him earlier"? He was fantastic striker for a decade with insane work rate.
Nothing to do with the week, certainly nothing to do with our bizarre manager’s bizarre comments. I didn’t think he was superb against Spurs though but his goal was a nice finish. It’s comments about him as if he’s some kind of super hero. Like he’s Bryan Robson. You might disagree, fine. No need to post whiney little responses. I’m asking genuine questions you don’t seem to like it. No worries it’s all opinions.
How could you not think that when you look at his career and what he's showed when fully fit ? Your stats about his scoring while true, don't take into account the context of him having barely played at PSG the year before, him getting injured, him getting suspended and therefore losing match fitness and rhythm.I’m baffled by all this talk of him being a real man, if only we’d signed him earlier etc.
Yes….for me he will be remembered like Larsson. Like a good player in the twilight of his career who played for us for a while. The end.Not sure if youre old enough to remember Henrik Larssons time with Utd, but it's pretty much universally remembered in a very positive light.
He played the grand total of 7 league games for us, scoring 1 league goal.
Sometimes it's not all about the numbers on paper, although in that respect Cavani's numbers are more than respectable.
You always attack the poster when you disagree with them……You’re doing them on a weekly basis, simply because you can’t understand why you’re in the tiny minority, that’s the definition of being a whine.
You’re in the minority because you’re wrong. He’s a very likeable player, with an incredible attitude, and no-one talks about him like he’s Robbo ffs, that’s some daft strawman you’ve invented in your own brain.
Couldn't have said it better.Not sure if youre old enough to remember Henrik Larssons time with Utd, but it's pretty much universally remembered in a very positive light.
He played the grand total of 7 league games for us, scoring 1 league goal.
Sometimes it's not all about the numbers on paper, although in that respect Cavani's numbers are more than respectable.
You always attack the poster when you disagree with them……
I see that from one side, but in terms of what he’s done purely for us…I’d reserve that for RVP for example.
I’m looking at it from what he’s done for us….like I don’t look at Laurent Blanc and think I wish we’d have signed him earlier based on what he did for us, but if we had he’d no doubt have been superb. Same with Alexis Sanchez. If that makes sense.How could you not think that when you look at his career and what he's showed when fully fit ? Your stats about his scoring while true, don't take into account the context of him having barely played at PSG the year before, him getting injured, him getting suspended and therefore losing match fitness and rhythm.
A younger and fitter Cavani would have scored 35-40 goals each season for United.
Alexis Sanchez?RVP had one great season before he signed for us and was always a injury prone player.
Also when people say "we should have signed him years ago" they don't consider player's ManUtd contribution only, they consider what a player he was for a decade.
Clearly that's not what people think when they say "I wish he played for us before" I mean you cannot be serious with the way you understand a statement like that. @roonster09 explained it in details. You're creating a debate that doesn't even be there.I’m looking at it from what he’s done for us….like I don’t look at Laurent Blanc and think I wish we’d have signed him earlier based on what he did for us, but if we had he’d no doubt have been superb. Same with Alexis Sanchez. If that makes sense.
Alexis Sanchez?
If you look through he hasn’t actually scored that many important goals, defining goals or goals against our rivals at all.He scores some important goals and has a fantastic work ethic. It’s easy to see why he’s a fan favourite
But that to me then just becomes pointless. Laurent Blanc, Alexis Sanchez were both disasters for us. But if we’d have signed them earlier may not of been. It’s non relational to how they performed for us. I can see that being said for Zlatan for example. I think Cavani sits in between.Clearly that's not what people think when they say "I wish he played for us before" I mean you cannot be serious with the way you understand a statement like that. @roonster09 explained it in details. You're creating a debate that doesn't even be there.
I wish we had signed Bastian earlier, not the crock version Bayern gave. Another example of a player who was top class and fitter before arriving at Utd
That's all you're giving Cavani credit for? His movement alone makes the game easier for the likes of Bruno, Rashford and Greenwood as we saw last season, and I'm sure Ronaldo will benefit too.If you look through he hasn’t actually scored that many important goals, defining goals or goals against our rivals at all.
For me when I look through I find :-
Southampton x2
Spurs away last season
Fulham away to equalise
There’s probably more in the EL but we shouldn’t be playing in that and him not scoring any goals in CL is part of the reason we did.
I get his work ethic certainly but a team of runners doesn’t win you anything. Rooney ran around a lot but his all round game was world class and when I watch Cavani his link play and ability on the ball is not.
How have I attacked you? The post is a whine, you’re making whiney posts on a weekly basis because despite being in a teeny tiny minority you think you’re right.
Is that “attacking” you? Wtf
No…the poster said he scores important goals. It was in response to that.That's all you're giving Cavani credit for? His movement alone makes the game easier for the likes of Bruno, Rashford and Greenwood as we saw last season, and I'm sure Ronaldo will benefit too.
I think you're wayyyy overcomplicating things. It's a simple wish formulated by fans who appreciate the player. Nothing that deserves that much of a ridiculous dissection. I actually cannot believe that I had to precise all of that.But that to me then just becomes pointless. Laurent Blanc, Alexis Sanchez were both disasters for us. But if we’d have signed them earlier may not of been. It’s non relational to how they performed for us. I can see that being said for Zlatan for example. I think Cavani sits in between.
I see your outlook on it, it’s just so broad and baseless though, it could be said about any older player coming into the club regardless of how they played.
Same on Bastian….I barely remember he played for us based on his contribution.
You’re doing them on a weekly basis, simply because you can’t understand why you’re in the tiny minority, that’s the definition of being a whine
You do it all the time. You don’t like when someone disagrees with you. You try to attach some form of negative connotation to the poster. That’s weird also.
Also I’ve never said I’m right, I’m interested in why others think so highly of him. But everyone has an opinion and that’s fine. I’m not trying to change anyone’s. Just trying to understand and finding it hard.