I've said it a few times, but the combination of our dire defending and De Gea's world-class shot-stopping has meant that the focus has been on his strengths for the last few years. Should he have a more average season by his standards or, better still, our defence stops giving away so many good chances, then quite rightly the scrutiny will fall on the more average areas of his game. I'm not the only one who thought Romero was the better goalkeeper in Mou's first season. Penalties aside, I would expect the best keeper in the world to not be so mediocre at leaving his line, claiming crosses, organising his defence, and both distributing the ball through shorter throws and longer kicks. De Gea needs to improve in these aspects to fulfil his potential.
This isn't a reaction to yesterday, as my posting history will attest. By all means, get him signed up to the new contract, but get him a coach who is going to drill the weaker aspects of his game.