David de Gea | 2011-14 Performances

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't think he put a foot wrong at all today except that dodgy punch near the start. How that merits a 5.5 rating regardless of who's giving it i'd love to know. He made 2 world class stops that saved us at the death. No wonder people are given a perception of him when reading such drivel

Lets not get carried away ... the first was a very good save, the second was an exaggerated standard save you see from all keepers.:nono:
 
Lets not get carried away ... the first was a very good save, the second was an exaggerated standard save you see from all keepers.:nono:

After the way he's been treated and spoken of lately and to pull both of them saves off in the last few minutes at stamford bridge speaks volumes. I guess some people will never be pleased for him.
 
Let me understand. He was able to save it because, due to the shot and his actions, it was possible to save it?

This puts things in a new light.

err yes, in the most simplistic terms.

If the trajectory had been lower, it wouldn't have mattered whether he was moving or not .... he wouldn't have got it.

When the ball was struck he was already in motion and just RIGHT of centre.

Edit:
 
err yes, in the most simplistic terms.

If the trajectory had been lower, it wouldn't have mattered whether he was moving or not .... he wouldn't have got it.

When the ball was struck he was already in motion ad just left of centre.

Yes. That's right. If the ball was lower he'd have still flung himself at the top corner. Let it go. Seriously.
 
err yes, in the most simplistic terms.

If the trajectory had been lower, it wouldn't have mattered whether he was moving or not .... he wouldn't have got it.

When the ball was struck he was already in motion ad just left of centre.

You've picked a shot that is almost the definition of "postage stamp" and argued "what if it had been lower" as if you've made an argument for something. No one knows what your point is.
 
And we wonder why the press write this shit about De Gea. Idiots lap it up
 
bizarre from the telegraph, apparently he was at fault for the 2nd and 3rd goals :confused:

at the start of the second half, when Fernando Torres crossed perfectly from the right, De Gea chose not to attempt intervention.
He stood rooted to his line.
The ball landed at the feet of Mata who dispatched a volley too accurate and powerful for 10 keepers to stop. Particularly in the position De Gea adopted.

And while the third goal, a Luiz header that caught him leaden-footed as it looped off Ferdinand’s shoulder, spoke more of ill-fortune than incompetence, it summed up the edgy lack of certainty that seems to infect the United defence when he plays behind them.
 
That kinda comes under the incredible goalkeeping point, he moved to where he had to, showing excellent presence and ability to think on his feet...



Also look at how he punched it away from the danger area at least, rather than onto an attackers noggin.

:lol: just how he intended.

On the FK ... c'mon hands up who didn't think it was going in DdG top left? Its okay, don't worry the other kids won't laugh at you, ad if they do I'll give them lines.
 
It's kind of pathetic really that one slightly mishandled cross which didn't even lead to any danger is seen as a better indicator of a performace than two world class saves, at vital moments.
 
I think the most interesting to come from today is that he has now decided to punch balls until a time when he is comfortable at catching crosses and corners.

Probably a wise move. I remember Reina was similarly flappy at crosses in his first season and used to punch balls away quite a bit.
 
It was a sensational save, not only was it an amazing save, but it was in injury time at Stamford Bridge, our come back could have been in vain, a keeper under pressure who looking at his punch early on was probably a bundle of nerves.

That save could effectively kick start his season.

Let's hope he doesn't decide that now is the time to write a world-class childrens book, resulting in widespread public approval and plaudits being laid upon him. He would win many awards and will be continuously hounded by the press before his career as a footballer really has time to blossom :(.

I should send a letter to Fergie, really concerned now :(.
 
Pondlife you're like an exaggerated parody of a total and utter moron.

Except without the parody bit.
 
After the way he's been treated and spoken of lately and to pull both of them saves off in the last few minutes at stamford bridge speaks volumes. I guess some people will never be pleased for him.

The FK save was very important, not least because it saved a point but also as it will have given him some confidence, irrespective of what had gone before.

Saves like that are important if nothing else other than to give you the benefit of the doubt on any other errors.
 
It's becoming embarrassing now. They're just making stuff up.

Another one i read had that De Gea had home fans nerves "jangling" after punching two efforts. Surely can't be referring to Essien's which left him with little choice but to punch it over.
 
It's kind of pathetic really that one slightly mishandled cross which didn't even lead to any danger is seen as a better indicator of a performace than two world class saves, at vital moments.

Well, the press like to have their drama.

From a United fan's point of view, though, it is relevant. We know he's an incredibly talented keeper, but the important question is whether he can get on top of the whole high ball / physical challenges thing. Obviously he's still young and developing that part of his game, but were he not to improve it, it's potentially a career-stopper at United's level.
 
Sorry to interrupt whatever's going on, but here's a bigger version of that picture

1000x6pryo.jpg
 
After seeing it again on MOTD2... I maintain that that is a save that other keepers simply might not have been able to make. It was a stop only possible thanks to DDG's height (6ft4 if you believe wikipedia) agility and anticipation...

Loads of other keepers would have stayed rooted to the spot. Loads more wouldn't have been able to get a fingertip onto it... and from those that could, many still would have only been able to tip it into the net.

Simply put... it's a World Class Save.
 
Very good to see him out there looking confident. Very unfortunate timing for Lindegaard, but I'm excited for de Gea to get an extended run, especially in such a close title race. It will do wonders for him.
 
It's amazing that he's getting blamed for deflected goals, hopefully he just blocks the absurdity out and focuses on his game. His save from Mata's free-kick today was superb.
 
He got us a point today, there was nothing he could really do about any of their goals.

The two saves near towards the end where superb and he saved the point, that's all you can really ask of a Goalkeeper.
 
Joe Hard punched it straight onto Skrtel the other week, all was forgotten when he made a good save. Complete different story with De Gea however.

Watch Pool v Spurs tomorrow. Two of the most reliable keepers in the league.
Judge them with the same criteria as De Gea then compare the media ratings. Might be interesting because I see goalie shortcomings in nearly every game that are hardly mentioned unless they are major bloopers.
 
the media is obsessed with every details about de gea. even a poor punch could not save him from getting all the stick from the english journalist now. no way he was at fault for any of the 3 goals we conceded today.

the save from mata's freekick should boost his confidence now.
 
The save from Mata's freekick was almost Gordon Banks like and considering the situation, it was a world class save.

I always thought top corner shots, and that Mata freekick was curling into the very top corner -- was unsaveable unless you knew it was going there to start with.

He earned us a point.

He now needs to pop lots of pills (legal or otherwise) to bulk-up and work out at the gym to get his confidence for a more physical battle at the set plays.
 
I don't know why... but it reminded me a lot of this save from Barthez (though DDG's is infinitely better)

 
He started out a bit nervously, opting to punch an early ball which he could have easily collected in his sleep. However, ironically he grew into the game when Chelsea took the lead. He was unlucky with the 2nd and 3rd goal (Luiz's header was going nowhere till it took the deflection), and it was great that he didn't let his head drop. I hope he kicks on from here.

Finally, that save from Mata's free kick was absolutely brilliant. Yes most keepers would have guessed that Mata would aim for that corner, but few would have expected it to be that well struck. Anyone who takes a free kick like that would be expecting it to go in once it clears the wall.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.