My take on him is that he absolutely fantastic speed, strength, and power. When you give him space to run into, he will more often than not convert balls in behind into a real chance. The problem is that he seems to lack composure, decision-making, and technical ability. Moreover, it's very hard to be a good finisher if you lack technical ability. I think the most worrying aspect for Liverpool is that last night they actually would have seen him in his most favourable situation i.e. against a high line. Put him against a low block and he won't be able to make runs in behind. And he's not a Haaland because he doesn't seem to have the same preternatural poaching instincts.
Yes, he scores goals. But when you're the main #9 for one of the best teams in the league, you're always going to get chances. The issue isn't really how many he scores; the issue is that he should be scoring more than he is.