FC Ronaldo
Posts stuff that's been said before in tweet form
- Joined
- Aug 22, 2014
- Messages
- 12,032
He's just fantastic.
If we can find a proper fecking center back, he's the Carrick successor we are after.
I disagree. I don't like him in midfield as he gets overrun to easily. I wasn't a fan at all last season. He has been one of my players of the season for us at centre back and I think he should continue there.
Could well be. He's a good, intelligent passer of the ball.If we can find a proper fecking center back, he's the Carrick successor we are after.
I disagree. I don't like him in midfield as he gets overrun to easily. I wasn't a fan at all last season. He has been one of my players of the season for us at centre back and I think he should continue there.
He played DM when we were experimenting with a forward line of van Persie, di maria, Falcao and Rooney in a diamond. Even prime Keane would have trouble handling that.
Could well be. He's a good, intelligent passer of the ball.
He didn't show the positional discipline for the role when played there last season (he preferred to press the ball) but he seems intelligent enough to grow into the role.
His pace is a bit of issue but Carrick was never that mobile either, yet still coped.
Good one.He could be our Xavi and Herrera our Iniesta
No he's not. He's a better passer when playing in defence.If we can find a proper fecking center back, he's the Carrick successor we are after.
No he's not. He's a better passer when playing in defence.
For a number of reasons, he's definitely not good enough as a midfielder.
Exactly how I see it.I agree, coming out from the CB position into open grass allows him time on the ball to make his pass, I don't think he'd do that well in the hustle of midfield where he'd need to make his passes in a more crowded situation.
It's an unfair and early judgement based on his "first season" in a new league, in a different set up (mostly 4141, which offers far less help for the controlling midfielder than this 4231). I think if he had the same weaknesses exposed in his second season you could make that judgement, not when a new player, that has to acclamatide to a new much faster league, playing as the only controlling midfielder with Fellaini, Herrera, Mata and Young in front of him.No he's not. He's a better passer when playing in defence.
For a number of reasons, he's definitely not good enough as a midfielder.
He's been our worst player this season. I really can't figure out what people watch to come to any other conclusion than this.
There's this mythical idea that he's so good at passing it makes us better at playing out from the back, but when you actually pay attention to him, his passing is erratic at best and FAR too slow to be in any way effective. 90% of his passes are either ppointless or hospital balls. When peope have whined about our style of play this season, they basically describe what Blind does, but then at the same time praise Blind for doing it?
Him, Fellaini, Darmian and Lingard could go play for Sunderland and end up being the reason why they get relegated, rather than the reason why they don't. They all offer less to the team than any average mid table PL player would. Yet we put all four of them in expecting to still be able to play well.
Played the pass to Bojack and the pass to Mata for Rooneys. Such a tremendous player, the only one who will really force a pass forward alongside Carrick.
I've said before he gets far more focus and stick for tiny mistakes compared to Smallingbauer.
Future captain, first name on the sheet in a variety of positions and a top class CB partnership with Smalling, imo.
Based on our chase of Hummels and Ramos last summer, the plan must be for him to take Carrick's place in the squad after this season.
We'll still need someone else in there - I've been very disappointed for Herrera, but it seems he's just not a LVG player. If that's the case, he should move on and we need someone else like Gundogan in.
Played the pass to Bojack and the pass to Mata for Rooneys. Such a tremendous player, the only one who will really force a pass forward alongside Carrick.
I've said before he gets far more focus and stick for tiny mistakes compared to Smallingbauer.
Future captain, first name on the sheet in a variety of positions and a top class CB partnership with Smalling, imo.
Based on what? Any time they get properly tested they usually crumble.
Who tested them and when did they crumble? They've been our most effective partnership since Vidic and Ferdinand lost their legs.
He's been comfortably better than Stones and Otamendi this season, two £30m+ defenders. Credit to Blind for stepping up a level.
Wolfsburg? Newcastle? Arsenal? The three most noticeable games this season when the opposing team has actually tried to attack us instead of sitting back and using the coutner? (Though granted the Arsenal one can be put down to a crap tactics in general as well as other things).
I'd actually say vs Arsenal and Newcastle, Smalling was the worst of the two.