Brexit related judicial reviews: Supreme Court | Judgment: Prorogation was unlawful
- Thread starter owlo
- Start date
I stand corrected and will certainly bear that in mind next time. Apologies!
I actually think it was a shitty decision to broadcast this. He’s clearly got some sort of learning disability.
True but they've already broadcast Boris loads so it's not surprising.
Surely the Queen has the power to sack Boris, he lied to her.
fecking hell spanner. Class.
fecking outstanding
Yes
That guy didn't know what planet he was on. I do wonder about the BBC sometimes.The whole segment was embarrassing yeah.
A cross section of voters from Stoke, all white men under 30. One of them could barely speak, another had nothing to say, another said "I'm not a voter".
Just utter shite.
I'm pretty sure the shenanigans from a couple weeks ago passed a law that meant this isn't the case.
Good question. There also seems to be a belief that it will have taken Boris by surprise, but I'm sure he's seen it at least as a strong possibility and will have his next move ready, he just hasn't told us yet. I'd actually go so far as to say I'd be surprised if at least one of the judges hadn't given his people a wink as to how it might be going.
Yeah, we won't be leaving on October 31st.
You know what, I've been picked up on that before. Definite memory problems, thanks for the correction.
If BoJo decides to follow the law.
The queen is frightened of making any political decision.
I think that once it came out as being 11-0 last night boris would have guessed the probable trend
I don't think it's as much of a surprise as people were making out. I wasn't the only person to be calling it long ago. The force of it was surprising though.
Many people were surprised as they approached it as a political instead of legal question. I believe this is why @Ekkie Thump for example thought they would rule for the government.
@ the bold stuff. Nah.
she is not allowed to make political decisions
Why though? It's her government, their should be consequences for lying to her.
I agree. She should imprison them.
I will still say that despite four years of you being bellends to us and each other, you are still more than welcome back in the fold. Our European bonds are solid, even for teenage angsty rebellious bellendery.
Eh?
I expected an extension from the EU to be written in more formal language. Beggars can't be choosers I suppose.
Are you talking about the UK or Man Utd?
Second that, but if you really wish to stay I hope for no crap like "special treatment" or exemption from certain policies. Having said that, UK is leaving the EU anyway.
There will be a hug and a single free beer of choice available as well.
Can only speak for myself. I thought they'd without question find it justiciable but some might struggle to find enough proof of intent. That they found on the basis of effect alone surprised and pleased me. I'm still a tad suspicious they sidestepped intent for the sake of unanimity because there was less agreement to be found there. Hence in point 61 "We cannot speculate, in the absence of further evidence, upon what such reasons might have been.
It's heavily implied that the reasons offered were mendacious though.
Can someone please explain to me, like the simpleton I am, what was "unlawful" ?
Do we know what Boris said to the Queen that was a lie?
Do we know what Boris said to the Queen that was a lie?
Yes.