Bernardo Silva | Bouhafsi - 70m Euros, 5 year contract. Going to City CONFIRMED

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't think both of them can play on the same team, effectively ... can they?

Silva has played on the right this season. Griezmann has played up top for France and behind the striker for Atleti. Silva isn't a convential playmaker playing on the wing either, he's capable of staying out wide and running down the line, doesn't always look to come inside.
 
Even if we sign Griezmann and Silva, we'd still need a striker (unless we're planning to use Rashford as our main striker).

I'd be ok with Rashford being our main striker, I can see a situation in games when they're not going according to plan Rashford taken off Griezmann pushed further forward with someone like Mata coming on to add creativity
 
Add Fabinho to that and we'd be favourites for the league.
He looks City bound, I'd like to see us go for Gueye at Everton, he doesn't get a huge amount of credit but he's very good and very consistent.
 
Even if we sign Griezmann and Silva, we'd still need a striker (unless we're planning to use Rashford as our main striker).

We still would need one more direct winger with high work rate, Martialcan be used as a striker.
 
He looks City bound, I'd like to see us go for Gueye at Everton, he doesn't get a huge amount of credit but he's very good and very consistent.

And we must contest that, take the fight to the grave.
 
What would Silva's arrival mean for the likes of Mata, Mkhi?

Not seen much of him. Is he good enough to warrant prioritising his signing over a proper Carrick replacement?
 
What would Silva's arrival mean for the likes of Mata, Mkhi?

Not seen much of him. Is he good enough to warrant prioritising his signing over a proper Carrick replacement?
He's exquisite, we should do everything in our power to make sure he's a United player next season, he's that good. He'd take Mata's place in the starting 11 but I doubt he'd have much of an effect on Mkhitaryan's position. He'd bring our attack up a level, he's incredibly clever too, he's capable of making the passes only Pogba is capable of doing in our current team. Griezmann's the bigger name but Silva will be our most important signing IMO. He'll take us up a level, I'd bet my life on it. Never been so excited at the prospect of us signing someone.
 
I'd also like a LB. But if that were our summer we'd be a huge threat next season.

Definitely. Add to that list:

- Mourinho second season
- Fingers crossed Martial pulls his finger out
- Pogba running the show
- Bailly beast mode
 
We still would need one more direct winger with high work rate, Martialcan be used as a striker.

If this season is anything to go by, Jose prefers Rashford as the striker. It seems he might be willing to trust Martial on the left for another season, since we haven't really been linked with any proper wingers.
 
A proper Carrick replacement doesn't exist

True. But you know what I mean, a midfielder that's going to give us more protection. In a 3 man midfield, assuming Pogba and Silva start, who would be the third? Unless Herrera is converted to that role or TFM steps up considerably it would probably need to be another signing.
 
I wouldn't for one moment claim to be an expert on transfer targets or players. But if this lad is a better version of Mata, as some say, is it worth it? We desperately need killer wingers who will destroy guys with pace, not another pseudo-10
 
True. But you know what I mean, a midfielder that's going to give us more protection. In a 3 man midfield, assuming Pogba and Silva start, who would be the third? Unless Herrera is converted to that role or TFM steps up considerably it would probably need to be another signing.

Silva isn't a CM, he's a playmaker who can operate on the wings.
 
Man United should also scout some of Monoco's academy and lower level french clubs . The more Monaco sell the better they replace him with.
 
I wouldn't for one moment claim to be an expert on transfer targets or players. But if this lad is a better version of Mata, as some say, is it worth it? We desperately need killer wingers who will destroy guys with pace, not another pseudo-10

He's a different player to Mata. Mata constantly drifts inside, Silva is capable of staying out wide and beating players down the line. Also Silva is up there with the best when it comes to dribbling and ball retention, whilst Mata is more about movement and scoring goals.
 
True. But you know what I mean, a midfielder that's going to give us more protection. In a 3 man midfield, assuming Pogba and Silva start, who would be the third? Unless Herrera is converted to that role or TFM steps up considerably it would probably need to be another signing.

N'Zonzi or Fabinho

Signing Griezmann and Silva won't prevent us from a getting a proper midfielder

For example

--------N'Zonzi------Pogba----------
Silva-------Griezmann------Mkhitaryan
--------------Rashford-------------------

Or for the more difficult games

--------------N'Zonzi-----------------
--------Pogba-----Herrera-----------
Silva-------Griezmann------Mkhitaryan

In a dream scenario we would have a seriously strenghtend defence behind them aswell but it is less of a priority as our main problems are now improving our attack and replacing Carrick from that midfield.
 
Haven't kept track, why is Fabinho City bound?

Because of the so called enigma before he came to england is trying to sabotage our buisness , that man is cunning inside. We must take the fight to the grave.
 
So were the James rumours rubbish or is this rumour rubbish because we aren't getting greizmann and both of the lads that's for sure. Silly season is already truly upon us and the summer hasn't even started yet. I'd love silva more than either of the other two above fwiw. He hasn't hit his ceiling yet. He would do well in England.
 
Just thinking about it...:drool:

I think we won't sign a top striker though if Griezmann comes in, and to be honest, I'd be happy with a Hernandez coming in if we get both Silva and Griezmann.
Remember we have Ibra to come back who i think will stay on
 
Silva isn't a CM, he's a playmaker who can operate on the wings.

So it will be more like

------------------------CM
-------------Herrera------------Pogba
-----Silva

?

In that case is he really £70m worth of improvement over Mkhi/Mata? Certainly has a lot more years left in him.

Personally I would love to see us go with two strikers next season, in which case he could probably operate at the tip of a diamond.
 
So it will be more like

------------------------CM
-------------Herrera------------Pogba
-----Silva

?

In that case is he really £70m worth of improvement over Mkhi/Mata? Certainly has a lot more years left in him.

Personally I would love to see us go with two strikers next season, in which case he could probably operate at the tip of a diamond.


Diamond could be very intresting with the set of players we are linked with


--------------Rashford/ Martial---- Griezman/ Martial---

-------------------------Silva/Mata-----------------

---------------Pogba---------------MKh/ Herrera----------

------------------------Herrera/ new cm------------------
 
Diamond could be very intresting with the set of players we are linked with


Rashford/ Martial---- Griezman/ Martial

-------------------------Silva/Mata-----------------

---------------Pogba---------------MKh/ Herrera----------

------------------------Herrera/ new cm------------------
That looks alright actually.
 
Diamond could be very intresting with the set of players we are linked with


Rashford/ Martial---- Griezman/ Martial

-------------------------Silva/Mata-----------------

---------------Pogba---------------MKh/ Herrera----------

------------------------Herrera/ new cm------------------

It's the best way forward for us to get the best of the young talent we have at the club (Pogba/Rashford/Martial)
 
Diamond could be very intresting with the set of players we are linked with


--------------Rashford/ Martial---- Griezman/ Martial---

-------------------------Silva/Mata-----------------

---------------Pogba---------------MKh/ Herrera----------

------------------------Herrera/ new cm------------------

It's the best way forward for us to get the best of the young talent we have at the club (Pogba/Rashford/Martial)

The diamond will never happen. It wouldn't function very well in the Premier League. Anyway, I expect it's a case of Griezmann OR Silva.
 
The diamond will never happen. It wouldn't function very well in the Premier League. Anyway, I expect it's a case of Griezmann OR Silva.

We Played majority of games in a diamond in 2013 with saf and won the title, worked pretty well. Lots of creative players could make a pretty fluid system not a rigid diamond.
 
The diamond will never happen. It wouldn't function very well in the Premier League. Anyway, I expect it's a case of Griezmann OR Silva.

People said 3-5-2 would never work in the premier league.

If you got the right players then any system can work.

Also I don't think it's one or the other. Griezmann is a goalscorer and Silva is a creator.
 
People said 3-5-2 would never work in the premier league.

If you got the right players then any system can work.

Also I don't think it's one or the other. Griezmann is a goalscorer and Silva is a creator.

Yeah a 343 just won the title,
 
Status
Not open for further replies.