BBC: United hold talks with Mourinho

Would you be happy to see Jose Mourinho become next United manager?


  • Total voters
    1,749
Status
Not open for further replies.
If this is to happen then the fans need to voice their opinions tonight. If they sit idly and support blindly then LVG should stay because it's what they deserve. Otherwise let it be known that it's time for change.
 
Chelsea in 2004?
Really? He inherited a squad consisting of:
Up and comers in Huth, Johnson, Cole, Parker and Bridge all of whom at the time or thereabouts were tipped to be massive players.

Then he has Lampard, Terry, Duff, Makelele, Gallas, Geremi, Crespo, Gudjohnsen and Cudicini.

They already had deals in place for Robben and Cech and was given the freedom to bring in known entities (well to himself) in Carvalho, Ferreira and Tiago and of course his best piece of business in Drogba who was one of those players who could've gone either way.

I think he did a grand job at Chelsea obviously, but what he inherited was decent and the resources he had to add to it in his first and second season are there to be seen.

I think the setting is similar again, it's just that Chelsea he inherited were far better on the table. This team we have here is better than what they show, I think many would agree with that.
 
Other than the fact it isn't news, has no named sources or any quotes?

If it started with "My mate said..." it would be more of a news story than this is.
Journalists don't name their sources - it's pretty much rule number 1 in the journalist's handbook. Otherwise they'd soon have no sources.
 
I think Jose is far too competitive to enjoy PSG.

The Premier League of the next few years is shaping up to be one of the most competitive leagues in modern football history. His main rival for best manager of this generation Guardiola is at City. Wenger still at Arsenal, Klopp and Conte now in the league as well. The man truly, truly believes that he is a special one. I don't see him turning down the ultimate chance to prove it.

Disagree

Everywhere he's gone he's had a very good chance of winning the big trophies, coming to United would be his hardest job yet, not sure he's the type that relishes a challenge despite what he may want us to believe
 
Even if its saying what we know its still nice to hear! Sooner he is in the better. Lining up with de gea, ibra, mou, and potentially Sane, Joao Mario and whoever else is very exciting.
 
Disagree

Everywhere he's gone he's had a very good chance of winning the big trophies, coming to United would be his hardest job yet, not sure he's the type that relishes a challenge despite what he may want us to believe
he said recently he doesn't like having 3 or 4 tough games a season, it bores him. He wants to be here
 
Sky's story is totally without substance. Mourinho to United is very obviously not yet signed and sealed (the 'De Gea to leave' story being obvious evidence of that), but surely sometime after Saturday it will be.
 
Disagree

Everywhere he's gone he's had a very good chance of winning the big trophies, coming to United would be his hardest job yet, not sure he's the type that relishes a challenge despite what he may want us to believe
Porto in the champions league? Inter in the champions league? It would be no tougher here then it was at chelsea anyway. His first stint he had to compete with the invincibles arsenal team and a Fergie led United side, with Liverpool being a decent side. Second stint chelsea hadnt won the title in like 4 years with United and City dominating. At real Madrid he had Barca as the greatest ever side and a very strong atletico team (with very little else tbf). Saying he doesnt relish a challenge is ridiculous. United is perfectly in line with the others, money to spend, promising team with a bit of transfer work needed to complete the team.
 
It'll be his toughest gig yet. Overhaul of tactics,squad and sign 3-4 new players. He never had to work with a squad like this with very little experience of winning titles and such low morale. I still think it will be a tough first year for him.

I do agree with this.
The other thing which was touched on in the LVG OUT thread was that in 2 years, LVG has brain washed our players into keeping the ball and not taking any risks.
I am not sure how easy it will be to get those risk averse players to all of sudden play with the aim of scoring goals and that it's "okay to concede goals".
 
Mourinho knows it's not his place to announce any appointment. It not only would undermine United, it would also be sticking the knife into a friend.
 
Mourinho knows it's not his place to announce any appointment. It not only would undermine United, it would also be sticking the knife into a friend.

Indeed.
It'll be MUFC who first announce it. Not Jose himself.
Rather than interview Jose, they should try interviewing Woodward. He may spill the beans.
 
I do agree with this.
The other thing which was touched on in the LVG OUT thread was that in 2 years, LVG has brain washed our players into keeping the ball and not taking any risks.
I am not sure how easy it will be to get those risk averse players to all of sudden play with the aim of scoring goals and that it's "okay to concede goals".
Not sure I can picture Mourinho drumming into the players that it's OK to concede goals. But I think they'll be fine adapting to a more counteracting style, and forgetting absurd rules like not being allowed to play the ball or shoot with one touch.
 
Indeed.
It'll be MUFC who first announce it. Not Jose himself.
Rather than interview Jose, they should try interviewing Woodward. He may spill the beans.
After the Moyes sacking fiasco I'd be very surprised if he tells anyone anything they don't need to know.
 
Not sure I can picture Mourinho drumming into the players that it's OK to concede goals. But I think they'll be fine adapting to a more counteracting style, and forgetting absurd rules like not being allowed to play the ball or shoot with one touch.
Or dribble with the ball or passing forwards or crossing the ball.
 
Here are some reasons why United will probably stick with van Gaal. Hopefully I'll jinx it:

1 The upheaval involved in appointing new staff.
2 The expensive of such an upheaval, including payoffs to those dismissed.
3 The worry over Giggs leaving (the board will believe this is bad PR).
4 The worry over van Gaal, Giggs and others publicly slating the board.
5 The negative reflection towards Woodward's decision-making post-SAF.
6 The board's - and others' - ambiguous feeling about José being United boss.
7 The friendship between van Gaal and Woodward.
8 Van Gaal's expedient excuses for underperformance which nevertheless might be believed by Woodward & co.
9 Van Gaal's guilt-trip: that he wasn't given the right players/the players aren't up to scratch/the media assassination campaign etc etc.
10 The supposed 'near miss' ("5th/6th isn't far from 4th"); a Cup win supposedly heralding a new age of success under LVG.
11 Van Gaal's 'understanding' that he'd be given 3 years to succeed ("It's a process").
12 The club would rather pretend things are ok than take difficult decisions in order to actually make things ok.
13 The club's policy is that public relations only truly matter when it comes to sponsorship, not when the fans are discontent.
14 The club's amateurish and timid laissez-faire approach to major decision-making.
15 The complacent belief that revenues and attendances will remain large despite little footballing success.


There's more, surely; a lot more, sadly, than there are reasons why United will dismiss LVG. I suspect that - incredibly - the board would view such a dismissal as a risk. Fingers crossed that I'm utterly wrong and that the club is more professional and bold than I thought.

It's already done mate. In fact I'm so confident about it then I can bet anyone about it.

His situation is untenable now. No top 4, losing the support of players and I think OT will have the lowest crowd today in a long, long time. There's no chance that he's going to stay.
 
Pretty depressing that the FA cup has become a sideshow to the ongoing speculation about LvG/Mourinho. We're just stuck in no man's land right now.

Which is why they should have sacked him before the final, would have lifted the whole club. Joyce would have deserved to lead us out on Wembley more than the fraud.
 
I think it is impossible to imagine any scenario where he is not the boss going in to next season.

The venomous negativity surrounding the club and LVG these days has to change.
 
Early indications suggest it will be the lowest OT crowd for a century. I hope the ones in the stadium chant for jose.
 
Porto in the champions league? Inter in the champions league? It would be no tougher here then it was at chelsea anyway. His first stint he had to compete with the invincibles arsenal team and a Fergie led United side, with Liverpool being a decent side. Second stint chelsea hadnt won the title in like 4 years with United and City dominating. At real Madrid he had Barca as the greatest ever side and a very strong atletico team (with very little else tbf). Saying he doesnt relish a challenge is ridiculous. United is perfectly in line with the others, money to spend, promising team with a bit of transfer work needed to complete the team.

Winning the UCL at Porto and Inter just exceeded expectations make no mistake Serie A was a 1 team league when he went there so he was guaranteed league titles, before that he went to a Chelsea side with a blank chequebook and after Inter he went to Real Madrid a side with all the possibilities to do well despite Barca

Coming to United now is nothing like the challenge he faced when he went to Chelsea, Inter, Real and then Chelsea again
 
Some fans on the Everton forum seem convinced he's their's.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.