The evidence is simple biology. Some people find it more difficult to put weight on than others. It’s not some obscure suggestion that I’m the first person to raise, it’s a proven physiological fact. I even agreed with your larger point, so I’ve absolutely no idea why you’re trying to manufacture some disagreement.
16
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 1
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 0
- Status
The evidence is simple biology. Some people find it more difficult to put weight on than others. It’s not some obscure suggestion that I’m the first person to raise, it’s a proven physiological fact. I even agreed with your larger point, so I’ve absolutely no idea why you’re trying to manufacture some disagreement.
the gap between youth football and professional football is gigantic. Its a regular occurrence, that highly rated youngsters struggle to make the transition and end up in lower divisions. Its kind of pointless to predict how he is going to turn out one way or the other. The thing to learn from this is, that United had no plan what to do with him. Buying youngsters and sending them on random loan moves isn't a particularly successful strategy. Sending players on loan is fine, if its part of a longer strategy to develop a player, not some magic recipe. Young players need trust and stability.
Yeah right not rocket sciense to call it biology but when I said evidence is an actual evidence like something written to read or something or video to see. No one is denying the fact some people find it difficult to put weight on which I used Angel Gomes as example but Angel Gomes is not the same as Amad Diallo, thus why I asked you to provide evidence of your statement if Amad Diallo is considered in the category of ''some people''. Without evidence, people can easily just say, based on simple biology and physio, hey it's not impossible for Amad type of body to gained more muscle last summer, the only people that unable to do so is someone like Angel Gomes's physical body. The evidence? Nothing just me calling it as simple biology and proven physiological fact.
My word you’re being dumb
I asked you evidence to prove it why Amad Diallo is considered to be in the category of ''some people'' and you can't prove it. Rather than insulting, just admit it you are just guessing that Amad Diallo is one of those people who can't put weight on.
I literally did exactly that in the initial post you took some stupid umbrage with. You should probably have read all of the post.
I already told you that your initial post is irrelevant because using David Silva as example is not evidence because no one know if he even tries to put muscle when he doesn't need to since his other games are not raw. You are referring to biology and physiological and yet no evidence about it. If you can't provide evidence then agree and disagree rather than insulting.
I never once said Silva did or didn’t try to put on muscle. You’re trying to deflect than admit your original post had one moronic point (when I generally agreed with you! Mentioning Silva supported the point you were making!). Backing down is ok, doubling down when you balls up the point you’re trying to make is just Trumpian, own it. Nobody would think less of you for it.
Show me the way to Amad Diallo
You acted like you are absolutely right by calling my opinion as ''load of bollocks'' and ''moronic point''. I'm okay with that if I'm actually wrong since all I want to know is a clarity what is right but the reason why I'm deflecting it is because you haven't prove yourself that your statement was right, so why should I admit it?
Therefore, I asked you, can you provide evidence of how Amad is considered to be in the same category of ''some people don’t put on mass easily''? Yes or No? That's all I want to know.
If you can then I will admit it. If you can't prove yourself right then there is no clarity what is right and what is wrong means what you said is just pure different opinion, so why should I admit it if I don't know that you are right. You have no authority to act like you are absolutely right by calling different opinion as ''load of bollocks'' and ''moronic point''. If you want to gain the right to do that, prove it, don't just talk.
He created quite a few good chances for us by pressing the fullback and winning back the ball... I can recall that resulting in a goal for Ronaldo at least twice.
His Dortmund form counts for nothing now it is what he does in a Utd shirt that matters.
But we have to pay the fee based on what he did at pervious clubs, people are not from future to see what he will do at ManUtd to decide the fee.
Sure. Are you making your judgment for Sancho based on a disaster season where the coaching was horrendous, squad building was horrendous, each and every player was horrendous? Guess Varane is equivalent to Phil Jones and Ronaldo isn't a CL level player then.
We bought Sancho because of what he showed combined with the age he showed it at. He showed this in the CL and the Bundesliga after being incredibly hyped as a youth product with 0 professional football first. Amad is at that stage of a lot of hype with next to 0 professional football (or at least, has not done much in limited professional football). Sancho is only 21 years old. He'll be fine. He already showed a decently long period of very good form where he is integral to any positive way of attacking, however for literally any player, you also need a team that is in a positive eb and is set up to accept the player and get the best out of them.
That is fair enough and I have not written him off yet and as far as I am concerned he starts with a clean slate under a new coach next season.
He has had a full season in England now so he should know the physical demands so hopefully he steps up to the challenge.
Very good post.
As a Rangers fan, I’m surprised some still think Diallo can make it at United. Bellingham is a year younger than him. That's the kind of player you guys should be looking at if you want to compete at the top again, one of the best players we have come up against in Europe. Another standout we came up against was only 21 at the time and he's just about you sign for Liverpool. Diallo isn't even in their league.
Every time he had played for the first team he was always good and impactive. I am not sure why he did not perform well for Rangers but he has a lot of potentials. If ETH gives him the chance I believe he will flourish.
So all young players develop at the same rate and no player that isn't already world class at 21 can ever play for an elite club. Right.
People develop at different rates.
Or not at all
Well yeah, but it's a bit too harsh to expect dialo to be already a world class player.
The talent is there we just need to help him and wait to see if he can take the next step or not.
Both of those players are immense physically. Amad will take far longer to develop.
I didn't say ever, I had next season in mind. But I wouldn't say it's looking great in terms of making it at the elite level. Needs a good Championship loan next season.
Amad didn’t stand out in the Scottish League. He isn’t good enough, simple as that.
over the years players like Scholes, Zola, Modric, Messi and so many more have proved its not all about being a physical monster.
Diallo and Pellestri are two players who could provide wing options for us (and we are short there) and I am sure will be assessed pre season. Pellestri is a curious one because he has not been playing for Alaves but has been for Uruguay and playing well for them. Going forward I would like to see us develop this bracket of player in house rather than sending them to play at the bottom Of La Liga fodder or in the SPL. I think we now have a coach who can develop this type of player and that for me is exciting
Football is never as simple as that.
he maybe scored 2 goals but he wasn't really special at anything. They were decent cameos but his overall performances have gotten better in the minds of fans as time has passed. He didn't come across as an exciting youngster when he played
Kane didnt standout in the championship right.
Was he given a proper chance, though? These things can be all about momentum for young players, look at Rashford, for example.
Amad has been unfairly not been used even when he had performed for Ole. He hasn't played consistent football for nearly two years. I am sure if he gets football next season be it at loan he will perform.
Amad has good technique and footballing brain is why I believe he will be a very good player.
I don't think he's good enough at first team level. Think Pellistri has more potential
firstly, why is it unfair?
secondly why do you think he hasn't been used?
Does look to be getting bigger!
He'll be like a new signing
People love to mention likes of Messi and Scholes when it comes to physicality not being a major issue but they were the best of their generation or the best of all time level footballers.
Nobody could even get close to these two that’s why, they was always two steps ahead
That's my point. If you're gonna be built small you better be exceptionally amazing at what you do.
I still have belief in him. Clearly talented, and I’d love to see him in a ‘size doesn’t matter’ team that focuses first and foremost on touch and movement. He’s only about to turn 20 next month. Will be his first pre-season with us this year, and I look forward to seeing him under the new regime before a decision is made on him.
Amad PRiallo- Status