Does this include Muslims? Because that's an Abrahamic religion as well, but a muslim is unlikely to go far in presidential politics.
It's a shame in many ways that religion is such a big thing in the US. The propaganda that vaccines cause autism, climate change is a hoax, even gun politics has a religious hand in it.
Sad to say, but yes. With the exception of Kennedy, who was Catholic, and of course Obama - the US has never had anything but protestant, white males as Presidents (although quite a few of the early ones dabbled in Deism).