League Cup Semi-Final

Manchester United 0:2 Manchester City

Old Trafford

Kick-off
Wed, 6 January 2021 @ 7:45pm GMT
Status

Closed

Discussion Your Lineup Prediction

  • Status
    Not open for further replies.
    sunama said:
    They've been playing decent in the last couple of weeks BUT we have Ole and his luck.
    I'm confident, not in our team's ability to score goals, or Ole's ability to set us up to win or to defend against MCFC's attackers, but I am very confident that if necessary, we'll get a penalty that isn't a penalty if that is what is required to get a draw or win.
    We should've drawn the Villa match, but Ole and his luck ensured we got the win.

    If his luck can somehow get us a title win, then I'm all for it.

    I honestly can't see how MCFC can win this match for reasons stated above.
    Click to expand...

    I think this is unfair for Ole and the lads.

    Luck is of course the defining factor in Ole's tenure, but most of the times, United had always been unlucky in finishing chances, enough to win the games without the penalties.
     
    Honestly, I ain't bothered about this at all. Ain't felt this way about a Manchester derby since they had Samaras in their side.

    If Ole plays Bruno and he gets injured I won't give a s-t if we win 5-0. I've seen that before with a Kanchelskis hat trick!

    For the first time in nearly a decade we have a honest to God crack at the title. If we lose key players trying to win the f'n Carabao Cup I'm going to have a fit.
     
    Want us to go full strength in this game but then need to rest at least four of the first XI completely on Saturday, however gut feeling is we will still have the big guns on the bench then
     
    sunama said:
    They've been playing decent in the last couple of weeks BUT we have Ole and his luck.
    I'm confident, not in our team's ability to score goals, or Ole's ability to set us up to win or to defend against MCFC's attackers, but I am very confident that if necessary, we'll get a penalty that isn't a penalty if that is what is required to get a draw or win.
    We should've drawn the Villa match, but Ole and his luck ensured we got the win.

    If his luck can somehow get us a title win, then I'm all for it.

    I honestly can't see how MCFC can win this match for reasons stated above.
    Click to expand...
    Ah yes that lucky Ole that drew Man City instead of Brentford in this league Cup semi final..
     
    Go full strength for this game (if anyone knows what's our best team) and try to get in the final, please! Would be exciting to play a final again.
    Rotate and give play time to players in need vs Watford and EL games.
     
    It'll be another cagey affair I reckon.
    United sitting deep to protect against the overloads and City not over committing through fear of the counter.

    Be interesting to see if pogba keeps his place. He's worked harder of late but city are the last team you want nicking the ball off you in dangerous areas. I wonder if he's fully earned that trust yet. Wouldn't be surprised if he was a sub tbh

    With the rest and the Watford game after its certainly a good chance to go full strength. The final being later in the year is also something to look forward to, it's highly unlikely of course but a small chance of fans being involved would be fantastic
     
    I'd love to see a very much changed lineup with the likes of Pogba, Maguire, Rashford and Bruno getting a rest.
     
    I'm going to completely reverse my previous stance, which was that I didn't care much one way or another about the Carabao Cup.

    This now seems like a crucial moment, in combination with the Liverpool game and City's performance against Chelsea. Liverpool is faltering - there's a general realisation that they can now be dethroned. At the same time, most seem to expect that it will be City stepping into that space, and that we're now seeing them getting back to their expected level of play. Everyone acknowledges that United is in that picture, but there doesn't seem to be much belief yet that we truly belong there.

    What will effectively decide where the belief moves is the City and Liverpool games. If we come out of those creditably and not looking weaker than the opposition, that is going to define in people's minds where we are.
     
    De Gea has proven this season that he is still a better keeper than Henderson. However, I’d still play Dean here as he more than capable as the best young keeper in the world bar Donnarumma, and it would be very unfair to drop him for this one and the Watford game. I’d also play Matic as McT hasn’t been up to scratch since that brilliant Leeds performance. Aside from that, the team picks itself. It’s harsh on players like Donny, but he can start against Watford.

    Henderson
    AWB Bailly Maguire Shaw
    Fred Matic
    Rashford Bruno Pogba
    Martial

    If we’re on our game, we can beat these. We’ve done it before. Come on lads!
     
    I know its the carabo cup but do we not want to win some silverware? It would do the team a world of good and stop the semi final failure run. I would go with the same team. With Pogba on the left and Rushford on the right. Even De Gea in nets. We can rest players against Watford and Burnley
     
    I think this semi-final is important for our growing confidence.

    Having lost three semi-finals last year (Man City in the Carabao Cup, Chelsea in the FA Cup, Sevilla in the Europa league), I think it's vital we break that run and get to a final. Imagine if we lose and the headlines are that Ole loses four semi-finals in a row, he can't handle the pressure of landing a trophy, the team bottles it under pressure, etc. We need to avoid that and continue our good run of form.

    I'd like to field our strongest side and give us the best chance of winning.
     
    Would anyone play Bruno over the two cup games (city&watford)?

    I’m inclined to say rest him for the Burnley game. We need him for the league
     
    Play a strong team tomorrow, rest key players like Rashford, Bruno, Fred and perhaps Martial against Watford unless we need them and then strong team for Burnley.

    I agree with most we shouldn't disregard this cup as it's silverware and a big boost in squad morale to get to a final however the league is so tight right now so I hope we severely prioritise that, we actually have a chance of winning it this year, i think it will be between us and City to win it tbh.
     
    Whilst we're enjoying our current league position, we should remember that we're not even half way through the season yet, and whilst it's great to dream, and we should all make the most of the feeling that we're in a title race, a hell of a lot can happen between now and May in the league.

    Silverware is crucial for this side, and we're 2 wins away from that in this cup. Whilst it's always the 4th choice competition, there is a reason why the likes of City, and Chelsea under Jose, often go all out to win it. It breeds a winning mentality and culture and can be a huge mid-season boost in the other competitions, we don't want losing in semi-finals to become a thing for this team.

    I'd go full strength tomorrow, then rotate heavily at the weekend for the FA Cup. Leaves a week rest for key players before going back to league duty.
     
    youmeletsfly said:
    I'd love to see a very much changed lineup with the likes of Pogba, Maguire, Rashford and Bruno getting a rest.
    Click to expand...
    Do you realize that these are our best players and we are two wins away from a trophy? The confidence boost will be huge if we manage to get Ole his first trophy. Should play the best team imho and rotate the next one however, players can play more games together and players like Greenwood and McT could be enough to freshen the team ( for the next game)
     
    I hope we go with our strongest team for this. Full rotation against Watford, strongest team against Burnley / Liverpool and then we can do a small amount of rotation against Fulham + Sheff Utd.


    Best 11

    ----------------------De Gea------------------------
    AWB--------Bailly-------Maguire-------Shaw
    ----------------Fred------------Mctom
    --------------------------Pogba---------------------
    Rashford-----------Bruno-------------------Martial

    Very Fluid between that front 4 so the starting positions really don't matter.

    Hit them on the break.


    Watford 11

    --------------------Henderson-------------------------
    TFM---------Lindelof---------Axel--------------Telles
    --------------------------Matic---------------------------------
    -----------------Mctom--------Mata-------------------
    Pellistri-----------Greenwood----------------James

    Edit - Just saw Cavani is suspended so would play a youngster or even god forbid.... Lingard.
     
    Last edited:
    Poborsky's hair said:
    The confidence boost will be huge if we manage to get Ole his first trophy.
    Click to expand...
    I keep seeing this but it didn't do a lot for either Van Gaal or Mourinho.

    It's an academic debate anyway as obviously Ole is going to play his strongest team - picking Bruno at Everton pretty much confirms it - but I still can't buy into the idea that a League Cup win is somehow going to transform us.
     
    I don't expect many changes unless they are forced. I'd just go with the same team that played Villa unless I'm missing a tactical reason to play someone over Pogba or something. Hendo over de Gea or Telles over Shaw are really the only ones I could see Ole being tempted by.

    We will make plenty of changes against Watford. If we beat City first, I think we might even change the entire XI against Watford.

    If we lose this game, I'd expect most of the big players to have to play again in the FA Cup too.
     
    Siorac said:
    That'd be ridiculous. We have much more important games to come.
    Click to expand...
    Don't think going out of both cups in a week would be seen as the best way to approach those games though!

    Obviously, we shouldn't be losing the latter game even with a rotated side, but if we were gonna make 10-11 changes for example originally, but lost to City tomorrow... I think it would be more like 5-6 instead.
     
    Full strength tomorrow. Tactics are more important than anything. We don’t want to go 3 down like last time or like the Renties did the other night. If we get this right tactically we are likely to win then rest all key players for Watford.
     
    youmeletsfly said:
    I'd love to see a very much changed lineup with the likes of Pogba, Maguire, Rashford and Bruno getting a rest.
    Click to expand...

    No chance, it's a cup semi final against city and the next game is against championship Watford at home.

    The big players can be rested at the weekend.
     
    Havak said:
    I don't expect many changes unless they are forced. I'd just go with the same team that played Villa unless I'm missing a tactical reason to play someone over Pogba or something. Hendo over de Gea or Telles over Shaw are really the only ones I could see Ole being tempted by.

    We will make plenty of changes against Watford. If we beat City first, I think we might even change the entire XI against Watford.

    If we lose this game, I'd expect most of the big players to have to play again in the FA Cup too.
    Click to expand...

    Whatever the result tomorrow we need to rest the big players against Watford on Saturday night, the league games against Burnley & the scousers are more important than that one.
     
    croadyman said:
    Whatever the result tomorrow we need to rest the big players against Watford on Saturday night, the league games against Burnley & the scousers are more important than that one.
    Click to expand...
    Watford are shite so we're bound to lose ;)
     
    Lots of people saying they don't care about this tie and to concentrate on the league, yet they'll bash Ole for only getting to a semi if we fall in the league.
    Go strong with lots of players who run alot as city with have lots of the ball, Fred and Scott will start, Matic to come on if we're winning,
    Remember we're allowed to make 5 subs now so should make it easier for Ole.
    I want to win something this season.
    Come on utd
     
    Matthew84! said:
    Lots of people saying they don't care about this tie and to concentrate on the league, yet they'll bash Ole for only getting to a semi if we fall in the league.
    Go strong with lots of players who run alot as city with have lots of the ball, Fred and Scott will start, Matic to come on if we're winning,
    Remember we're allowed to make 5 subs now so should make it easier for Ole.
    I want to win something this season.
    Come on utd
    Click to expand...

    Yeah I want us to go strong for this as well, we can rest players on Sat
     
    It's only really De Gea I see coming out of the team, with 5 days rest and a chance to rest players against Watford, it's a no brainer. Reckon we'll get a win as well.
     
    Escobar said:
    Let's rest some players! I don't want to see a full strength line up
    Click to expand...
    They've just had 5 days rest, that's a 2 week holiday to them!

    We go full strength against city, then rotate a bit against Watford ready for Burnley.
     
    meamth said:
    I think this is unfair for Ole and the lads.

    Luck is of course the defining factor in Ole's tenure, but most of the times, United had always been unlucky in finishing chances, enough to win the games without the penalties.
    Click to expand...

    What does this even mean :wenger:

    Another one who thinks football is a game of chance, not a game of skill.
     
    With the semi-finals we've been in and getting knocked out of the CL, we need to win this piece of silverware, beating top teams on the way. Then our players will know we can be winners.
     
    Adam-Utd said:
    They've just had 5 days rest, that's a 2 week holiday to them!

    We go full strength against city, then rotate a bit against Watford ready for Burnley.
    Click to expand...
    This. I wasn't to bothered about this, knowing we are hitting form in the league, but the chance for silverware for alot of these young players and for Ole in particular is massively important.

    On the plus side, I reckon we have enough strength in depth to deal with Watford.
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.
Post-match discussion

Man of the Match

Luke Shaw image Luke Shaw 26% of 212 votes

Runners-up

Show more results

Player Ratings

5.1 Total Average Rating

Highest Rated Player

Lowest Rated Player

Compiled from 241 ratings.
Submit your ratings
View full results

Score Predictions

136,44,27
  • Man Utd win
  • Man City win
  • Draw

Detailed Results

  • 38% Man Utd 2:1 Man City
  • 10% Man Utd 1:2 Man City
  • 10% Man Utd 2:0 Man City
  • 9% Man Utd 1:1 Man City
  • 8% Man Utd 1:0 Man City
  • 7% Man Utd 3:1 Man City
  • 4% Man Utd 0:2 Man City
  • 3% Man Utd 2:2 Man City
  • 2% Man Utd 1:3 Man City
  • 2% Man Utd 2:3 Man City
  • 2% Man Utd 3:2 Man City
  • 1% Man Utd 3:0 Man City
  • 0% Man Utd 0:0 Man City
  • 0% Man Utd 0:1 Man City
  • 0% Man Utd 2:4 Man City
  • 0% Man Utd 0:3 Man City
  • 0% Man Utd 0:4 Man City
  • 0% Man Utd 0:5 Man City
  • 0% Man Utd 5:0 Man City
Compiled from 207 predictions.
Show more results Score Predictions League Table

Match Stats

  1. Man Utd
  2. Man City
Possession
40% 60%
Shots
11 12
Shots on Target
2 4
Corners
4 4
Fouls
9 6

Referee

Martin Atkinson

Man Utd Lineup

Substitutes

Lineup Predictions League Table View your Lineup Prediction