First window - Terrible
Second window - Desperate
Third window - We'll see. A good start with Shaw it seems
Second window - Desperate
Third window - We'll see. A good start with Shaw it seems
Woodward (old thread)
- Thread starter smallred
- Start date
- Status
Daniel Taylor in the Guardian. Although, as reported, Woodward wasn't asking their opinion just casually dropping it into the conversation that he thought United needed to sign a 'superstar'. TBF if he signed a superstar centre midfielder we'd all be on him like flies on much.
Ahh. Thanks for that! Been trying to flippin' remember where I saw it! Is this the piece which suggested why Cavani was linked or have I mixed it up?
This. There is a very good reason why he was given the job, he is oviously razor sharp and he will continue to adapt.
That and the fact he helped the Glazers buy the club, has been at the club since the take over, and he is 100% their man.
He's like that dude with the glasses from Banshee, he just gets the nod from Joel or Avram and who ever has pissed them off wakes up with no testicles or being fed into a sausage making machine.
Same piece. Although later on Twitter Daniel Taylor clarified Cesc was Woodwards top target.
Exactly.
I don't know how people can be blaming him for the departures of players like Vidic and Rio. It's clear that he's getting instruction from within the club, probably from our next manager, and he's going about it how a CEO should go about it.
If he can pull of the transfers that have been going round the press this summer, then I think he'd have done a good job overall. Let's give him a bit of time without the Moyes effect before prematurely judging him.
Now that you mention it he does remind of that guy from Banshee...you won't like to mess him around with him.
Thanks. Let's hope he can get his shirt-selling marquee player in a position we actually need one!
he seems to be upping the ante. making big decisions now. Thats what he is paid for.
woodward is vital this summer, as we don't have a manager, so it down to woodward to sort out the squad.
Woodward is doing a fabulous job,if Utd wants to get back to the top then there shouldn't be sentiments involved,and rio move proves that.
I wouldn't go that far, releasing Ferdinand hardly equates to a fabulous job.His performance can be judged a week before the start of the next campaign. He needs to sort out and strengthen the departments which are lacking in a time-frame which allows us to get everything sorted before the start of the season and not going into the first game with an incomplete team.
If we get the central defender, left-back, two central midfielders, left winger and get rid of certain players then I think he can judged well for this Summer. On the other hand, there's a long way to go yet.
What exactly has he done for you to say he is doing a "fabulous" job?
fabulous job?
What has he actually done? Told a clearly over the hill defender he's offski?
Briefed a couple of papers that we're after some ridiculous big names?
Maybe LVG is getting him to do his dirty work before he arrives.
I have a dream in my heart
Seeing President Roy
Keano for president
ROY ROY ROY
Seeing President Roy
Keano for president
ROY ROY ROY
He still makes me more nervous than Moyes.
Keane knows feck all. He just likes to have a dig wherever he can even though he knows nothing about what is actually happening behind the scenes. In fact, I reckon Keane might actually post on here under the name "Devilish".
Best thing he can do is let Van Gaal bring a director of football type person in.
Let Woodward bring do the finances (which he's clearly good at) and the football negotiation stuff to those who understand it (which he clearly can't)
Let Woodward bring do the finances (which he's clearly good at) and the football negotiation stuff to those who understand it (which he clearly can't)
So van Gaal will be expected to deliver top four next season.
Also, has Woodward essentially become our director of football?
That's what all our ex - chairman have been. So yes.
Which is another reason why a director of football makes sense.
Well I mean Gill worked in unison with Ferguson so this is somewhat different. We've Woodward travelling alone throughout Europe attempting to sign player's.
Sorry, but for me there's not a single thing this guy has done yet that indicates any particular level of competence.
OK, so the LVG thing may well be progressing, and hopefully it will all go through eventually, but the whole way the club has handled it is yet another shambles. As with everything Woody is involved with it's just weeks of endless newspaper stories and speculation, with the saying nothing while moving at glacial speed.
After the year we've had, the whole mindset of the club needs to change, and in order to this we need fast, decisive action from the top. I actually thnk his time working in corporate acquisitions is working against him - he's perfectly happy to just let things meander along for weeks on end while people get their houses in order at their own pace. This is not appropriate for a football club with a limited amount of time to get its shit together before the new season starts.
OK, so the LVG thing may well be progressing, and hopefully it will all go through eventually, but the whole way the club has handled it is yet another shambles. As with everything Woody is involved with it's just weeks of endless newspaper stories and speculation, with the saying nothing while moving at glacial speed.
After the year we've had, the whole mindset of the club needs to change, and in order to this we need fast, decisive action from the top. I actually thnk his time working in corporate acquisitions is working against him - he's perfectly happy to just let things meander along for weeks on end while people get their houses in order at their own pace. This is not appropriate for a football club with a limited amount of time to get its shit together before the new season starts.
How fast do you expect us to move? The season hasn't finished yet in a World Cup year. Be reasonable.
I agree wholeheartedly. I think we need a director of football and just let Ed concentrate on sponsorship deals, etc. He clearly hasn't a clue what he's doing. I just hope the deal for LvG is signed, sealed, and delivered or I see us missing out on him. People in the know think it is. So here's hoping.
he says we are going to spend this summer, lets hope he backs it up
The season has finished four days! You think we have total control over the press? You think the press aren't going to speculate on every move we make? We're hardly different from most big clubs, the only difference is that you're paying attention to Manchester United and not any others, and putting massive emphasis on every move we make.
Most people seem to be paying attention to all the mindless bullshit printed in the Twitter thread and treating it with credibility and then acting surprised when it doesn't come true.
Next three months are make or break for him.
Last season we could also blame Moyes. But having two disastrous summer windows in a row and the blame will be on him.
Last season we could also blame Moyes. But having two disastrous summer windows in a row and the blame will be on him.
We fired our manager a month ago!
I know this is new territory for us, but I've noticed most clubs don't spend this long sorting out having a manager. There's absolutely no reason we coulndn't have unveiled him a couple of weeks back, before he had to turn his attention to the world cup, if we'd moved fast enough to get it all wrapped up.
Man City and Chelsea announced Pellegrinni and Mourinho in June last year.
When everyone knew they would join in April and May.
Indeed. A modicum of calm would be a good thing. I have no doubt our various transfer sagas will run on all summer, as they always have.
They didn't have a) a World Cup taking up half the summer or b) a massive rebuilding job to do.
Even better of an example when you consider what we did in the same year...rushed a candidate into the job before the season had ended with basically no recruitment process.
That's the point though - it's not that I'm p[anicking that this won't happen, it very probably will.
But calm is the very last thing we need right now. We need radical action, and the action we need most is confirmatoin of a manager who is prepared to kick some ass.
I'm Confused as to why any of us would have a (balanced) opinion on him yet. I'll have a very firm one when I see our starting 11 in August mind - ask me then
You underestimate how long contracts need to take. Especially at that time, the club were still keeping their options open to other candidates (Ancelotti more than any other I'd imagine) it wasn't until very recently that LVG has been the main one in the frame.
A contract is by no means a sheet of paper, it has to detail and account for almost every situation that the manager will find himself in, at the very least it will be a 30 page document, then LVG's lawyers will have to read over every word, re-negotiate some things, our lawyers will have to do the same thing - it's a long and labourious task but thats why corporate lawyers get paid so much, any mistake even if its grammatical can hold up the process.
LVG keeps mentioning "process" and "time" each time a member of the press speak to him, drawing up and agreeing professional sports contracts take a very long time.
And no disrespect to other clubs who sack mangers all the time, they have less things to include in a contract in comparison to a manager at a club like United, image rights are concerned, club sponsorship cars etc. so their turn around is quicker.
It's quite ironic that after years of laughing at Madird (myself included) for have such terrible inner politics and squabbles we're turning into this ourselves. Sir Bobby didn't want Mounrinho, SAF picked Moyes, now LVG needs to keep Giggs on as assistant manager despite him having zero experience in the role because he knows "the united way" whatever that is. The delay in announcing LVG is most likely down to him wanting all of these elements ironed out before he arrives.
- Status