Who is our best player?

sullydnl

Ross Kemp's caf ID
Joined
Sep 13, 2012
Messages
34,808
Simple question, prompted by a difference of opinion in the Ronaldo thread. Who do you think our best player is?

Doesn't neccesarily have to be the one happens to be performing the best this season, more in general terms who you think is currently the best footballer in our squad.
 
Consistency will play a huge part in this decision - in which case, I’d have to say the goalie. Pogba is the ‘best’ for me though, has the most quality. But De Gea is easily the best when measured by a quality of performance multiplied by consistency of performance metric. After him, we start moving into ‘on their day’ territory.
 
  1. De Gea
  2. Bruno
  3. Sancho
  4. Pogba
  5. Cavani
Imo at least. Pogba is talented but isn't reliable. Sancho will come good but needs time and a half decent team.
 
If you were assembling an elite team and had to pick one from ours, I think I'd pick Varane.
 
sullydnl said:
Simple question, prompted by a difference of opinion in the Ronaldo thread. Who do you think our best player is?

Doesn't neccesarily have to be the one happens to be performing the best this season, more in general terms who you think is currently the best footballer in our squad.
Click to expand...
Interesting question - I'd probably go with DDG and Pogba, though Varane is also probably in with a shout?
 
Overall? Bruno.
Currently: De Gea
Best in a one-off game? Probably Pogba, although Bruno, De Gea & Cristiano* can all challenge him

* in CL
 
Obviously, over their career, it's Ronaldo. But in terms of their ability nowadays, I can't see beyond Varane, Pogba, De Gea or Fernandes.

I'd go with Varane. For what he's achieved in his career trophy wise, and the contribution he's made to those ability wise. And he's still at a high level now, although injuries and our overall form means we're yet to fully see it here so far.
 
Varane and Bruno are our best outfield players and Pogba is our most talented player. I had i high hopes for one of our academy player but not more but Sancho can only get better and if he gets to he’s form from previous seasons he’ll smash up the league!
 
It is hard to know. I would have said one from Bruno, Ronaldo, Sancho, Pogba, Varane, Maguire, Shaw before the season. Now everyone has been pretty poor for us this season.

I guess De Gea has been our best player so far. Fred been good too.
 
harms said:
Overall? Bruno.
Currently: De Gea
Best in a one-off game? Probably Pogba, although Bruno, De Gea & Cristiano* can all challenge him

* in CL
Click to expand...

Baffles the mind to think a squad like ours with these many stars can’t challenge for the title.

I agree Bruno as overall best and De Gea as lost consistent now

Pogba is the most talented by a mile but thoroughly inconsistent
 
DRJosh said:
Baffles the mind to think a squad like ours with these many stars can’t challenge for the title.

I agree Bruno as overall best and De Gea as lost consistent now

Pogba is the most talented by a mile but thoroughly inconsistent
Click to expand...
Because they are massively overrated.
 
None of our players would make a Premier League select 11 so who cares?
 
Pogba.

Our best performer Bruno. Which is also the reason to why we’re not winning shite for a while.
 
Pogba is our best player in the same way that street freestylers are world class footballers.
 
Fred!

Really though it’s Bruno and Varane. They stand out as close to world class quality without us winning anything. It’s good recruitment. DDG is great but he was so bad for too long. He’s not the answer. Still, Too many major questions in this team to be resolved. Pogba is a beautiful player on his day but he’s injured too much and doesn’t seem all that motivated to be here. Stick a few really intense players with a bit of quality into this team and I think we will majorly come on!
 
Is pogba really that good?

Sure on his days he's fantastic, but overall his United career is a trainwreck. He has more bad games then good ones, his trophy collections are also poor for a supposedly world clase player.

If he keeps the current trajectory by the time he retire he'll be just a foot note among the real greats.

Ronaldo on the other hand, this year is his only bad year considering all else. If he retires today he'd blow pogba out of the water. Hell i think he'd blow half the squad trophy count by himself
 
I think it's hard to look past Bruno as our best player, the sheer numbers this guy has racked up is impressive, I think he should be moved into a false 9 role.

I'd say DDG & Varane round out our top 3.
 
Pogba has played one game again and the hype train is back. Baffling.

Our best player is between Bruno, De Gea or Varane.
 
De Gea. This season no one else has been as consistently good as him.
 
I honestly think some people don’t even watch football.
 
We have a team of inconsistent players. So the question really should be that who is our most consistent player. The answer this season is DDG. Last season was Bruno. Rashford was our best player for short periods of time.
 
1. Varane
2. Bruno
For third spot it's quite close between Ronaldo, De Gea, Pogba, Sancho, Rashford,...
 
PP6. Bruno, De Gea, Varane + 1 make out the top 5.
 
Difficult one. All the players have badly underperformed for a long period at some point. A lot of calls for DDG but he was Sunday league for two years. Many others claim Bruno and ignore that he’s just getting back to form after 13 months of generally poor performances every week. If that’s not inconsistent, then it’s consistently poor over a long period.

I’d go Varane. As another poster said if you were building an elite team he would be the one you’d put in.
 
Pogba and Sancho are the best players, most talented, best footballers. But they have not been our best players in the regard that they have produced. De Gea is obviously up there. Maybe Varane too. Bruno is fighting for a spot as well.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.