Everything you say is correct, but it's not going to change in the future, so I'm not sure how it is relevant. The cost this summer will increase next summer. The other big clubs will improve over summer, so if we only buy two top players we will - at best - simply maintain the gap between us. What are you suggesting as an alternative? Waiting just postpones the inevitable doesn't it?
De Ligt it seems is going to Barca, I would prefer him over anyone though.
Vardy is an excellent finisher too, unlike Rashford and Lukaku, maybe the ship has sailed in terms of age but for a bargain price I would take him over Lukaku because he would have a useful and defined role in the squad.
Sancho is probably staying at Dortmund this summer, but yes we should try everything to get him.
I don't expect us to get anything close to what I said in my 'wish list', but this thread is about what we need rather than what we will likely get. My big worry is that we have lucked into getting Ole and if we don't back him and suffer a dip in form, he might get the sack then we're back to square one, trying to find a new manager, waiting for funds to appear and rebuilding for another few years. We have a similar revenue to Real Madrid, Ed and co refer to us as the biggest club in the world, yet we can't afford to buy as many players as Real this summer (rumoured 300MIL kitty) despite Real winning the last 3 CLs in a row.
Who is in need of the biggest rebuild?!
We seem to be agreeing on way more than we are disagreeing on. We both want us to be aggressive in the market, though both perhaps have different senses of the restrictions on this pursuit.
For me, we have lots of good players but few elite players. Only elite players will really close the gap on City and Liverpool. I don't count many players under 21 in that elite category; not Pellegrini, nor Pepe, nor Berge. They are very good prospects but I classify elite as either 1) world class or 2) damn near certainties to become world class. Sancho and De Ligt are two of a very small number of elite prospects (perhaps there's only 6 in the world and the other 4 are probably at Barca, Madrid, PSG and City; i.e. Dembele, Vinicius, Mbappe and Foden IMHO).
My restriction is price. I just don't see us going over £250m. It would defy historical precedent. We might be the second richest club in the world but we spent £58.05m last Summer, £178.52m the season before, £121.95m the year before and £128.07m the year before that. I don't see us jumping too high above those figures.
Your 'reality restriction' seems to be on competition. Why should De Ligt go to Barca? Yes, noises are strong but nothing's official. They aren't anywhere near as cash rich as us. He might want them but we have the ability to blow their offer out the water. They can go to 60m? feck it, we'll go up to 100m. Therefore it never goes past Ajax. If it does, we'll destroy them on wages.
Why should Sancho stay at Dortmund? Yes, they might want to wait to the Euros in the well founded hope he shines and all the English fans clamour for his signing; pushing the rich PL clubs to react. Maybe they want the Brexit effect to make Sancho even more valuable. Fine. But if we offer them £140m this Summer, you think they won't be tempted?
This is what I'm saying. Go all in for the elite players. Don't faff around getting a few very good players who could be good but could flop. We need the (basically) definites. We have enough good players. Get the game changers that make the likes of Real, City and Barca shudder.
Here's an example -
In 2017/2018 Summer, we signed Lukaku, Matic and Lindelöf for 147.96 and sold Januzaj for 7.65 while loaning out Pereira, Tuanzebe and Fosu Mensah. PSG signed Neymar for 199.80m (and got Mbappe on a loan to buy with a 40.50m initial fee with an extra 121.50m). I'd much rather us to have signed Neymar/Mbappe for £199.80m/£162m respectively and kept the loanees in and around the squad. Pereira and Fosu Mensah could've competed for Matic's place (and arguably developed their talent far better than they have) and Tuanzebe could have had a better season than Lindelöf's first with us (and potentially developed into a top class defender). Then the elite talent of Neymar or Mbappe would make everyone better and affirm a sense that 'we are Manchester United and we sign the very best in the world so feck you!'
We don't need lots more good players, we need a few greats and sure-fire potential greats. That's where I perceive we are at as a club. I also feel we've been too timid with youngsters in recent years; letting them atrophy in the U23s and poorly chosen loans where their motivation dies rather than putting them in sink or swim scenarios. Also, we haven't had enough world class players or strong leaders in recent years to take those around them to new heights. We've had too many Valencias and Freds as opposed to Cantonas, Keanes and Ronaldos. Nice players, good pros; don't get me wrong, but not true leaders or elite players.