Well, I'm not excited either. I'd rather add the DM signing to this window, but I doubt we can cope with that spending.Agree that a striker to replace Edi is definitely going to be the priority next summer, however even with a quick CB behind them I still have huge concerns about another season with McFred as the main midfield pivot
Well, I'm not excited either. I'd rather add the DM signing to this window, but I doubt we can cope with that spending.
Besides before adding any players to the midfield we must know what's happening with Pogba. If he's staying or not.
Would be silly to bring a dirty worker to partner Pogba and a summer later Paul leaves and we're left with no creativity in the double pivot at all.
Ideally I'd like him to stay. His vision and touch are world class. With quality behind him at CB and dynamo midfielder he'll produce France NT performances.Yeah the Pogba situation is clearly going to be the deciding factor with this position, like you say if he leaves we need more of a CM creator who can also provide the tempo in that area but IF he stayed then obviously we would require a proper DM
Are you kidding?) This would be fecking awesome.
Ideally I'd like him to stay. His vision and touch are world class. With quality behind him at CB and dynamo midfielder he'll produce France NT performances.
But it will be really hard to find that quality dynamo. On top of my head Kante and Modric are the type players that would fit next to him. While Kante doesn't posses the technical ability Modric has he balances with stamina and effort and same could be said for Modric - he doesn't have the stamina anymore, but he has the skill.
Watching France recently I just noticed that when in possession and when moving the ball there's always one player following the ball and giving that extra option. In midfield that's Kante while in attack that's Griezman. Pogba is not the one dictating. He's an outlet. When out of options they would pass him the ball and he would pull some visionary pass or wait until players get close to him and hold them off while a pass is available or try to evade pressure with skill and carry the ball forward. But he's not the one to demand the ball and demand tempo.
Fred is also that type of player but his quality is just not up there for my liking.
So many players we should sell, but I never seem to stumble upon rumours about clubs interested in our players. Seen those random tweets about Lazio wanting to loan Pereira and Milan wanting to loan Dalot. Lingard to West Ham seemed to go awfully silent...
Am I just imagining things or is it the same every damn summer? Our competitors seems to be able to get rid a lot easier than we do. Is it all down to our crazy salaries?
Thats it in a nutshell. We pay the most wages for mediocre players.So many players we should sell, but I never seem to stumble upon rumours about clubs interested in our players. Seen those random tweets about Lazio wanting to loan Pereira and Milan wanting to loan Dalot. Lingard to West Ham seemed to go awfully silent...
Am I just imagining things or is it the same every damn summer? Our competitors seems to be able to get rid a lot easier than we do. Is it all down to our crazy salaries?
We signed Matic who was very good in the role for the first 18months.....did we get France Pogba then? Obviously a player is going to be better with better players around them but I think its an excuse saying Pogba hasnt performed consistently to the levels we expect because of other players. Forget what he does for France, its international football for a start which is a different game there are many playes who have been much better for there country than club, Perisic is another one for me and there are also countless examples of the opposite. His vision and touch for us is sporadically world class and also sporadically sloppy in the wrong areas. You are even saying you can only think of TWO players that get the best out of Pogba, surely that says enough in itself
Yeah totally agree with that. But still there are doubts in which position does he play when in form and is he always the preferred option in big games in that same position. I still believe him and Fred are the best double pivot we could line up, although I wouldn't get upset if we get an upgrade on Fred. Someone better technically.All this talk of having the right players around Pogba to get the best out of him missed the point.
Pogba has been superb for us in periods where he's focused and mentally switched on. When he's motivated he's as good as any midfielder on the planet and at a major tournament, representing his country, it isn't particularly difficult or impressive management to keep him motivated.
The challenge with Pogba, is keeping him motivated and mentally switched on consistently throughout the course of a 50 game season, because it is those periods where he's not dialled in, more than the players around him, which impacts his game the most.
So, assuming we get Sancho…
A better partner for Maguire
A central midfielder that perfectly complements the remaining Pogba
That would be a good transfer window.
So, assuming we get Sancho…
A better partner for Maguire
A central midfielder that perfectly complements the remaining Pogba
That would be a good transfer window.
Sancho is almost done.
Varane would be great 50m
Sell Lingard and Matic to fund Rice.
Also Pereira back to Lazio and Dalot back Milan,
Sign RB if possible
Out
Dalot or WIlliams
Jones
Mata
Lingard
Pereira
Chong
£40m-ish
In
Romero
Camavinga
Sancho
Update observation. United definitely need a new top CB. A complete beast. Both with top acceleration and hard to beat one on one. And of course solid in the air too.
And i get the feeling United need a top RW more that a CF. In this case Sancho vs Haaland. If only pick one. I would pick Sancho. But the ideal and greedy mind. I would love to have both. Why Sancho over Haaland. Because i see Greenwood as CF in the mould of Van Persie and because of the extend one year of Cavani.
Compare Diallo. Really promising, but I don’t think he is ready to play regular as RW next season. And with Sancho as RW. Then you can move Greenwood as a CF option. Specialized Greenwood as a CF.
And last United need a top nr.8. United need a world class Paul Scholes. United haven’t win the league after Scholes and Sir Alex retirement.
There are Pogba or Bruno. Internally can solve the problems and need. Until the then. If United find a new Scholes or Bruno can reach Scholes level as nr.8. Then I think United will be good enough to win premier league. There was a clear and obvious reason why Sir Alex talked and convinced Paul Scholes to made a comeback and out of retirement. Then but of Sir Alex and Scholes retired at the top.
Sum up.
A top RW
A top CB
A top nr.8
Goalkeeper? Henderson and De Gea. Henderson doesn’t give me good confidence, that he is top goalkeeper. De Gea on his late career. I would try to swap Henderson for Villas Martinez.
Two clearly must have positions. RW + CB
If Paul Pogba or Bruno can reach Paul Scholes top consistent level. I think Bruno can. But Scholes was a genius on the pitch and top level. Even Iniesta said Scholes was one of the best CM. From another top LCM in Iniesta. You know how really good and important Scholes was for United. Scholes Vision, skills creative and football head is needed.
And goalkeeper. Maybe not must. But at this moment. Martinez from Aston Villa is clearly a better goalkeeper than De Gea and Henderson. And United as a top club. Always try to get the best players in each positions. To strength and make United better as a team. Always improvement.
There are only two matches left of the season. I think and believe what United need most.
But in the end. I got mine eyes first time in my life this season. I am afraid I will category Leeds Raphinha to must buy player. Every time I have watched. Raphinha really impress me.
In the ideal world it would be like this
Raphinha - Bruno - McTom - Sancho + Greenwood - Rashford
A potential future top 6 combination for United.
Adding Raphinha and Sancho on the wide side. It will be really hard to stop those 6 combination.
Raphinha had a good playing understanding with Bruno back in Lisboa. Adding with Sancho. Both of the will make life easier for United two CF upfront. Consistent top level service.
Sancho is pretty much concluded and noise around a possible Varane deal is fairly positive. The Trippier deal seems to have gone cold as we were expecting a Telles deal. Hopefully we still sell Lingard and Matic along with Dalot and Pereira, then we need to sell a keeper and I think a deal for Pogba with PSG would be beneficial for all parties.
That leaves the gaping hole in our midfield, we'll probably still have to waste another season playing one of McFred regularly but I'd love to see the money from Pogba and Henderson/De Gea go on two midfielders. If the plan is still to get a RB option then count me on the Dumfries bandwagon.
Rashford Cavani Sancho
Fernandes
Camavinga Pogba
Shaw Maguire Varane AWB
Henderson
We can challenge for the league with that team.
You know we take a few weeks per transaction and work in series, right? That lot would take us 10 windows!TRANSFERS
IN (260 - All prices in Euros)
Sancho (85)
Tielemans (60)
Varane (55)
Neves (40)
Trippier (20)
Heaton (0)
OUT (175)
Pogba (55)
Fred (25)
James (25)
Lingard (20)
Dalot (15)
De Gea (10)
Tuanzebe (10)
Williams (5)
A.Pereira (5)
Chong (5)
Mata (0)
Jones (0)
Romero (0)
J.Pereira (0)
Puigmal (0)
Taylor (0)
Traore (0)
Helm (0)
Carney (0)
LOAN
Pellistri
Mejbri
Garner
Galbraith
Mengi
Laird
Levitt
Elanga
Bernard
Devine
Kovar
TEAM
-----------------------------------------Cavani
-----------------------------------------Martial
Rashford------------------------Fernandes-------------------------------Sancho
--Diallo--------------------------Van de Beek---------------------------Greenwood
----------------------Neves----------------------------Tielemans
-----------------------Matic---------------------------McTominay
--Shaw----------Maguire----------------------------Varane---------Wan-Bissaka
--Telles------------Bailly------------------------------Lindelöf-------------Trippier
-------------------------------------Henderson
----------------------------------------Heaton
-----------------------------------------Grant
TRANSFERS
IN (260 - All prices in Euros)
Sancho (85)
Tielemans (60)
Varane (55)
Neves (40)
Trippier (20)
Heaton (0)
OUT (175)
Pogba (55)
Fred (25)
James (25)
Lingard (20)
Dalot (15)
De Gea (10)
Tuanzebe (10)
Williams (5)
A.Pereira (5)
Chong (5)
Mata (0)
Jones (0)
Romero (0)
J.Pereira (0)
Puigmal (0)
Taylor (0)
Traore (0)
Helm (0)
Carney (0)
LOAN
Pellistri
Mejbri
Garner
Galbraith
Mengi
Laird
Levitt
Elanga
Bernard
Devine
Kovar
TEAM
-----------------------------------------Cavani
-----------------------------------------Martial
Rashford------------------------Fernandes-------------------------------Sancho
--Diallo--------------------------Van de Beek---------------------------Greenwood
----------------------Neves----------------------------Tielemans
-----------------------Matic---------------------------McTominay
--Shaw----------Maguire----------------------------Varane---------Wan-Bissaka
--Telles------------Bailly------------------------------Lindelöf-------------Trippier
-------------------------------------Henderson
----------------------------------------Heaton
-----------------------------------------Grant