ThatsGreat
Full Member
- Joined
- Aug 1, 2016
- Messages
- 1,657
- Supports
- Arsenal
Unreal player, he was their best player at both ends of the pitch.
Can hardly say that as a reason for the difference between the two though. Van dijk made a difference to an awful back line the second he got there and is a main reason they are a functioning team. He is leagues above Smalling.
VVD is a better decision maker and that makes a lot of differenceHe is, but as is usual with Liverpool players he is being hyped up to be better than he is. In actual pure defending the difference is not that huge, they both play a similar way and have similar and fairly obvious flaws. Smalling in form and in a well functioning team can do pretty much everything VVD can defensively.
VVD is miles ahead on the ball and in his ability to organise and lead. He also seems to have more mental strength. I expect we are going to have a few shockers from Smalling now his confidence has been dented.
He's also way stronger and infinitely better in the air.VVD is a better decision maker and that makes a lot of difference
Best CB in the world on current form or at least on a par with Chiellini and Ramos... £70m+ well spent.
Frightening when you consider that he could have ended up at Man City.
Andy Robertson is 24 and arguably the best left back in the league, he's very good but he's not carrying the team by himself. He does bring valuable organisation to that defence which is probably his biggest asset.He's a such an asset to them. You can basically leave him alone in the box for crosses, and use the other CB as cover to the full backs. Is absolutely immense in the air.
That defense is 3 kids and him, and they've conceded like 5 goals all season. Mind boggling. So much better than I thought he'd be.
Van Dijk is a big reason why that team is a 'well functioning' team though.He is, but as is usual with Liverpool players he is being hyped up to be better than he is. In actual pure defending the difference is not that huge, they both play a similar way and have similar and fairly obvious flaws. Smalling in form and in a well functioning team can do pretty much everything VVD can defensively.
VVD is miles ahead on the ball and in his ability to organise and lead. He also seems to have more mental strength. I expect we are going to have a few shockers from Smalling now his confidence has been dented.
I tend to agree, but Virgil is an infinitely better name than Van Dyke. Doubly so in England.But... he's a big old unit though, innit.
So, doesn't like being drawn out of the middle. Needs Gomez rather than Lovren on the scene for the mobility.
Did you notice how shattered Alexander-Arsehole (I can't stand him) was in the 2nd half?
Also he fancies himself far too much, has got ''Virgil'' on his shirt & plays for Liverpool.
Not sure if seriousYup, he'll come good and you'll have the best No 6 in the league along with the best goalkeeper, the best CB, the best LB and the best front three.
Not sure if serious
Koulibaly is up there as well. I don't rate Ramos that highly as a defender. He's quite suspect when forced to defend.Best CB in the world on current form or at least on a par with Chiellini and Ramos... £70m+ well spent.
Best CB in the world on current form or at least on a par with Chiellini and Ramos... £70m+ well spent.
Van Dijk is a big reason why that team is a 'well functioning' team though.
Not really that mind boggling. Not many cbs if at all performing better than him.He is, he is leading the back line very well. Talk of him being the best CB in the world...mind boggling, and very Liverpool.
Andy Robertson is 24 and arguably the best left back in the league, he's very good but he's not carrying the team by himself. He does bring valuable organisation to that defence which is probably his biggest asset.
It's not a Liverpool thing. It's a parochial media thing that happens a lot in the Premier League. Some lazy ex-pro appreciates just how well Van Dijk is playing and cannot imagine any other defender matching him - mostly because they don't watch football anywhere else - and makes the proclamation.He is, he is leading the back line very well. Talk of him being the best CB in the world...mind boggling, and very Liverpool.
It is arguable, not mind boggling.He is, he is leading the back line very well. Talk of him being the best CB in the world...mind boggling, and very Liverpool.
It is arguable, not mind boggling.
Ha, I thought we were talking about performances, skills, talent and all that.22 caps, zero in major tournaments, part of a Holland team that failed to qualify for Euro 2016 and the last World Cup, 25 league games for Liverpool and zero trophies outside of Scotland makes it arguable? Because Liverpool made it to the champions final where they got comfortably beaten?
I'd say it's a symptom of the hysteria that surrounds the Premier League and football generally... Yes he's a good player, he hasn't actually achieved anything yet though, not even a full league season of games at Liverpool.
That book doesn't close though. The player's form and level is subject to constant change. And it's not really been that long that your team has been defensively solid. Although fair to say it has been very solid in recent times which is a testament to the manager (and players).All of Gomez, Robertson, Alisson and Van Dijk look like top class defenders that have closed the book on any hypothetical notions of wanting to improve on them.
It's a remarkable transformation of a backline that, a year ago, had Mignolet, Moreno, Lovren and Matip/Klavan as the starting players.
That book doesn't close though. The player's form and level is subject to constant change. And it's not really been that long that your team has been defensively solid. Although fair to say it has been very solid in recent times which is a testament to the manager (and players).
I've really liked what I've seen of him. Have to say it annoys me that Liverpool have signed the likes of Mane and VVD from other clubs in the PL despite our ability to easily out muscle them towards those deals.
True, you only have to look at their attack to see that .. last season blowing everybody away, sensational to watch, this season thus far it's a damp squib with the likes of Salah (last season the leagues best) a shadow of what they were.
Salah's overall game has still been pretty good this season and he's easily been our best attacker. His final ball has been the only thing really lacking (important part I know, but I think it'd be different if he'd just been average overall).
He's been doing stuff on his lonesome though with Shaqiri the only proper foil. He's been making the difference the past few weeks. If Firmino finally wakes up I think he's set to kick on again. He's not far behind his numbers from last season at this stage.
Firmino and mane have been much further from their level last season than salah has.
Salah's overall game has still been pretty good this season and he's easily been our best attacker. His final ball has been the only thing really lacking (important part I know, but I think it'd be different if he'd just been average overall).
He's been doing stuff on his lonesome though with Shaqiri the only proper foil. He's been making the difference the past few weeks. If Firmino finally wakes up I think he's set to kick on again. He's not far behind his numbers from last season at this stage.
Firmino and mane have been much further from their level last season than salah has.
Despite how much VVD cost, The total cost of our back four is ridiculously cheap for the 2nd best defensive team in the league. Or joint best if you look at goals conceded.
I mean less than 90m...
Poaching. Even his 1s touch, normally immaculate, has been off. His overall game has been uninspired to say the least.Hasn't Mane got like 6 goals so far this season (compared to 10ish last season)?
Not if you include the goalkeeper, which most people do when considering the entire defensive unit. In which case you've spent shit tons.