Transfer Tweets - Summer 2017 | Keep it on topic

Barcelona strongly linked to signing Dembele from Dortmund with all those Neymar €'s.

I'd post in that thread, but it's locked.

If this lad was available though, we'd be insane not to not try. He looks like the next €200m+ player in a year or two.
 
Barcelona strongly linked to signing Dembele from Dortmund with all those Neymar €'s.

I'd post in that thread, but it's locked.

If this lad was available though, we'd be insane not to not try. He looks like the next €200m+ player in a year or two.


What's amazing is that we have professional scouts working for us for a number of years who didn't spot Dembele's world class potential to the point of recommending him to purchase for a very reasonable price. Infact, I recall a large number of people on here state that he looked like an extraordinary talent. We really should be beating Dortmund for guys like this, instead of letting them become so valuable that we're competing (or not) one year down the line for big money.
 
He comes inside just like all our other wide men offering nothing new to what we have so whats the point

the point is he's better than what we have? or are we only buying players because they offer something new?

that seems to also be the reasoning people use to justify fellaini's existence on this planet despite whatever it is that he offers being wildly erratic and inconsistent
 
the point is he's better than what we have? or are we only buying players because they offer something new?

that seems to also be the reasoning people use to justify fellaini's existence on this planet despite whatever it is that he offers being wildly erratic and inconsistent
Hes had a good season in an OK league people seem to forget that, Micki was tearing it up in a much better league and struggled here. I don´t get this over rating players after 1 good season in an average league.
 
What's amazing is that we have professional scouts working for us for a number of years who didn't spot Dembele's world class potential to the point of recommending him to purchase for a very reasonable price. Infact, I recall a large number of people on here state that he looked like an extraordinary talent. We really should be beating Dortmund for guys like this, instead of letting them become so valuable that we're competing (or not) one year down the line for big money.

He personally refused every club and chose to sign for Dortmund. There's nothing any club can do in that situation. He made the right choice on hindsight for his development.
 
All this Mbappe, Dembele and Neymar talk is making me depressed :lol: I hope we pull off a brilliant singing out of arse.
 
I don't know, but Lemar looks like one of those playmaker that starts from wide but tends to move and play centrally, rather than the likes of Perisic, Moura, and even Dembele that tends to stay wide more. I may be wrong, but he looks more suited to those attacking midfielders that play for Arsenal. A Pires instead of a Giggs.

I believe United already have that type of players in Mata, Micky, Lingard even at lesser quality. With the rumour of Perisic, I think Mou looking for a different type that would stay wide and provide both pace and width.

Shame there isn't another player like Giggs out there, fast, skilful and a damn hard worker for the team. He was such an underrated player for us.
 
Not a tweet but apparently Mbappe injured his knee in the last game.

End of transfer talk this summer?
 
Not a tweet but apparently Mbappe injured his knee in the last game.

End of transfer talk this summer?

Nah. I saw the game and he was running around fine after he got the knee banged up. He later took another foul and it looked more like he was withdrawn to protect him. He looked like he wanted to come out, and the team also wanted to get him out. Our take on it is that he will definitely be sold soon.
 
Does anyone else not really care about 'tapping up'?

Don't get me wrong, when of your own teams players heads get turned, it's frustrating, but I don't really see how or why it is against the rules.

In any other line of work anyone can approach you and see if you'd like to work for them, you could have job interviews and everything.

Ultimately the player has a contract and unless it's winding down (in which case a sale is likely, though not guaranteed) , they'll have no choice but to fall back in line or risk being left out in the cold.

I just don't get the furore around it at all.

Of course the hypocrisy of Barca is hilarious though.
 
Does anyone else not really care about 'tapping up'?

Don't get me wrong, when of your own teams players heads get turned, it's frustrating, but I don't really see how or why it is against the rules.

In any other line of work anyone can approach you and see if you'd like to work for them, you could have job interviews and everything.

Ultimately the player has a contract and unless it's winding down (in which case a sale is likely, though not guaranteed) , they'll have no choice but to fall back in line or risk being left out in the cold.

I just don't get the furore around it at all.

Of course the hypocrisy of Barca is hilarious though.
I would think it's more due to unsettling of players minds to gain an unfair advantage. I do however think it's going on all the time to a certain extent. Instead of the player, clubs tap up agents or give exclusives to reporters.
 
I would think it's more due to unsettling of players minds to gain an unfair advantage. I do however think it's going on all the time to a certain extent. Instead of the player, clubs tap up agents or give exclusives to reporters.

Yeah I understand that, but isn't that just life?

If he's professional he'll get on with his job anyway, and as you say he'll know about interest anyway, so the rules don't really solve anything.