Transfer Tweets - Manchester United - 2022/23 | Follow the OP rules and check the quality of your sources before posting. STAY ON TOPIC!

[Sparky Rhiwabon]

Need to raise some funds for the first team I guess

 

[Tom Van Persie]

 

[Tom Van Persie]

 

[King7Eric]

I don't think Garner is the solution for our midfield from what I've seen of him. But to sell him before Fred is crazy. Fred ( and McT for that matter) have conclusively proven they can't make it here. Why not sell one of them before selling Garner?

 

[Sparky Rhiwabon]

I don't think Garner is the solution for our midfield from what I've seen of him. But to sell him before Fred is crazy. Fred ( and McT for that matter) have conclusively proven they can't make it here. Why not sell one of them before selling Garner?

We’d struggle to sell them for any money due to their wages compared to their ability. It would be a loan with us subsidising their wages at best

 

[SaboTaj]

I don't think Garner is the solution for our midfield from what I've seen of him. But to sell him before Fred is crazy. Fred ( and McT for that matter) have conclusively proven they can't make it here. Why not sell one of them before selling Garner?

Ye we should most definitely sell McTominay before anyone else.

 

[cyberman]

Need to raise some funds for the first team I guess

Finally. Not that I think he isn’t a good player but we would normally hold onto him until he’s 25 and sell him for nothing to Watford or somebody.
We need to be ruthless. We leave so much money on the table with players who the manager doesn’t want by keeping them for too long

 

[kirk buttercup]

I don't think Garner is the solution for our midfield from what I've seen of him. But to sell him before Fred is crazy. Fred ( and McT for that matter) have conclusively proven they can't make it here. Why not sell one of them before selling Garner?

Who would want them?

 

[Godfather]

Need to raise some funds for the first team I guess

Right decision. He needs first team football

 

[suhaylah]

Keep fred and Mctominay and sell Garner.. what a joke.

 

[King7Eric]

We’d struggle to sell them for any money due to their wages compared to their ability. It would be a loan with us subsidising their wages at best

Who would want them?

Surely some Italian, French or Spanish team will buy Fred for 5-10 million. He's a Brazilian international. Though yeah we'll probably need to subsidize his wages, but given he's only got a year left on his contract, I'd do it.

 

[Leg-End]

Are we really in a position to be selling midfielders right now?

 

[Judas]

I don't see him playing for us anytime soon, not entirely convinced he's good enough. I'd much rather he got a PL loan instead though, because you never know.

 

[sewey89]

Selling him with a buyback clause really isn't an issue. But we'll be ridiculed for it by idiots in our fanbase because a lot enjoy us being 'banter FC'

 

[Mickeza]

Selling him with a buyback clause really isn't an issue. But we'll be ridiculed for it by idiots in our fanbase because a lot enjoy us being 'banter FC'

Who then moan asking why we didn’t sign a winger after spending 160m quid. We need funds. Even without midfielders he’s 5th choice. 20m with a buy back makes perfect sense.

 

[sewey89]

Who then moan asking why we didn’t sign a winger after spending 160m quid. We need funds. Even without midfielders he’s 5th choice. 20m with a buy back makes perfect sense.

Yep, exactly. Some people just like to moan

 

[pacifictheme]

Yep, exactly. Some people just like to moan

I think some people were hoping he would break into the first team this season is where the frustration comes from.

 

[Lee565]

Need to raise some funds for the first team I guess

Sorry but why is he being sold instead of mctominay?

 

[sewey89]

I think some people were hoping he would break into the first team this season is where the frustration comes from.

Personally, I think that was more in hope than expectation. And the hope came from being tired of McFred.

Truth is, if we sign FDJ and Rabiot, that's 2 more CM's going ahead of him in the pecking order

 

[AndySmith1990]

I think some people were hoping he would break into the first team this season is where the frustration comes from.

If Ten Hag is happy to sell then obviously Garner isn't rated particularly highly.

We see loads of moaning about why players like Chong, Peirera etc are/were hanging around the club for so long, whilst Liverpool and Chelsea sell some nobodies we've never heard of for £15m. But then as soon as we're open to selling our own version of that (most other fans won't have a clue who Garner is) there is moaning about not giving them a proper chance first.

Can't win really

 

[jrdonald]

“Between £15m & £20m” … how much are Barca due Frenkie in deferred wages again? I don’t think I’ve seen the figure mentioned anywhere…

 

[Longshanks]

Oh good we are going to sell are only ball playing no 6 in the squad, genius not that we need one or anything.

 

[Dr. StrangeHate]

If Ten Hag is happy to sell then obviously Garner isn't rated particularly highly.

We see loads of moaning about why players like Chong, Peirera etc are/were hanging around the club for so long, whilst Liverpool and Chelsea sell some nobodies we've never heard of for £15m. But then as soon as we're open to selling our own version of that (most other fans won't have a clue who Garner is) there is moaning about not giving them a proper chance first.

Can't win really

Can't draw either.

 

[Catalandevil]

Sorry but why is he being sold instead of mctominay?

Because to sell a player you need a club that wants to sell and a club that wants to buy.

 

[Syphon Wallet]

Haven't seen much of Garner tbh, he must be bad to be sold before Mctominay.
Hopefully the extra cash actually leads to some signings, not lining the glazers pockets again.

 

[Nou_Camp99]

Sorry but why is he being sold instead of mctominay?

1. Nobody would have him.

2. Wages too high if they did

 

[Von Mistelroum]

Are we really in a position to be selling midfielders right now?

No, but we're not in a financial position to buy unless we sell. Have to sell players that someone might actually want.

 

[sparx99]

It’s basically Garner out to cover the Rabiot fee. Now I think Rabiot is a better player right now but there is definite value in homegrown players who love the club. Who knows whether Garner at 23-24 is the far superior player.

 

[Devil81]

Keep fred and Mctominay and sell Garner.. what a joke.

Clearly trying to raise funds.

Nobody would take Fred or Mctominay off us.

 

[OmarUnited4ever]

I don't think Garner is the solution for our midfield from what I've seen of him. But to sell him before Fred is crazy. Fred ( and McT for that matter) have conclusively proven they can't make it here. Why not sell one of them before selling Garner?

Garner has a good reputation from his loan stint last season, while the McFred duo are a known entity for being shit midfielders, so they aren't good assets to sell, unlike Garner.

The hope is McFred is replaced with new quality players and in the long term, McFred is let go for some nominal fee as I doubt anyone will pay anything for McFred

 

[Smores]

If Ten Hag is happy to sell then obviously Garner isn't rated particularly highly.

We see loads of moaning about why players like Chong, Peirera etc are/were hanging around the club for so long, whilst Liverpool and Chelsea sell some nobodies we've never heard of for £15m. But then as soon as we're open to selling our own version of that (most other fans won't have a clue who Garner is) there is moaning about not giving them a proper chance first.

Can't win really

That makes no sense. Garner has yet to be given a chance, Periera and Chong have had too many. It's not rocket science to figure out which is the sensible solution between those two paths.

Can people stop inventing random nonsense and accusing people of moaning about it.

 

[RedDevilQuebecois]

That is the kind of stuff that makes you want to punch a *insert something cute here*. Selling the kid before he has even played one game for us, are you joking?

Sell the Scottish fraud that is McTominay first.

 

[SouthernRedDev]

If he isn't showing enough for the manager, then sell him, its what other top clubs do. Its very different to the utd way of giving him a long contract and seeing if he comes good, in 5 years time. Most clubs have a high turnover of players that aren't too standard, it may also highlight to other in the club that simply being a Utd player isn't enough.

 

[TheReligion]

Can people stop inventing random nonsense and accusing people of moaning about it.

The same applies for people saying why aren’t we selling Fred and Mctominay .

You can’t sell players without buyers. Obviously there’s been interest in Garner.

 

[TheReligion]

That is the kind of stuff that makes you want to punch a *insert something cute here*. Selling the kid before he has even played one game for us, are you joking?

Sell the Scottish fraud that is McTominay first.

What’s Mctominay’s nationality got to do with anything?

 

[Judas]

The same applies for people saying why aren’t we selling Fred and Mctominay .

You can’t sell players without buyers. Obviously there’s been interest in Garner.

Exactly. This is why Smalling was first out of the door, not because he was the worst of the bunch, the opposite, teams saw him as worth buying.

 

[Kill 'em all]

That is the kind of stuff that makes you want to punch a *insert something cute here*. Selling the kid before he has even played one game for us, are you joking?

Sell the Scottish fraud that is McTominay first.

That's what City do and they make a lot of money out of it.

 

[cyberman]

That makes no sense. Garner has yet to be given a chance, Periera and Chong have had too many. It's not rocket science to figure out which is the sensible solution between those two paths.

Can people stop inventing random nonsense and accusing people of moaning about it.

He’ll have already been analysed to the highest degree by Ten Hag. Being given a chance is nonsense anyway, it’s not like players suddenly transform if they’re given a start. It’s not 2001 anymore when a manager could tell a player to go out and express themselves and then see what happens. The days of performing better in match days over training is over. You don’t need to flop in an EPL game for the manager to work out who you are

 

[Fr. Todd Unctious]

Clearly trying to raise funds.

Nobody would take Fred or Mctominay off us.

Is the correct answer. Only way teams will take a punt on Fred or McTominay is if they're getting them for free. We're stuck with both until their contracts run out unfortunately.


In relation to Garner I wonder will they have some sort of buy bacl clause in any deal

 

[OmarUnited4ever]

Ethan Laird goes to QPR on Loan