Given the financial restrictions all clubs are in and the need to stretch our resources, I’d be all for skipping Sancho this summer. If we have to use our entire budget on him, it leaves us too weak elsewhere.
What this team desperately requires is better depth. The first XI is really good, just overplayed, and we don’t have any real quality to provide variation off the bench. So it’s always just the same thing, which makes us easier to play against.
I would absolutely take Douglas Costa to provide variation to our front three, and go for a striker like Moussa Dembélé to increase competition for places. Rashford, Martial, Greenwood, Costa, Dembélé and James is a good mix. I’d also be interested in taking Brooks instead of Dembélé and having Greenwood be the back up striker when he isn’t playing wide right.
All this, coupled with the sales of Jones, Rojo, Smalling, Lingard, and Mata, should leave us enough cash to make the other three necessary signings:
A new CDM. Personally I would sign Thiago, but he seems Liverpool bound.
A new CB to partner Maguire.
A back up left back good enough to compete for a starting berth. Williams should be moved to back up right back.
Of the rest of our players:
Pereira sold or on loan. If we sign a CDM, we will have 6 central midfielders and the breakthrough spots should go to Garner and Mejbri.
Smalling, Jones and Rojo all sold.
Tuanzebe needs to show he can stay fit for a season and cut it in the PL. Should go out on loan.
Assuming we sign a new LB, Dalot should go out on loan. He’s too young and talented to cut our losses on just yet.
Lingard is part of a failed culture at the club and you can see that he’s been sidelined by Ole. The revolution should continue with his sale. No future here.
Mata provides something different, but it’s clear to see his legs are gone. This is player that is consummate professional though and who has much to teach young players. If he wants to play I think he should be released. Not sure how much time is left on his deal, probably a year, but he deserves a graceful exit. Ideally I’d have him on a pay as you play deal and have him doing his coaching badges to ultimately be integrated into the coaching pyramid somewhere.
James is one that has taken a lot of flack. He started so well, but struggled once the surprise factor was out of the way and defenders knew how to stop him. He’s young though, has a fantastic attitude and still plenty of potential. I’d definitely keep him around as a rotational option for another season. If he fails to kick on this coming season, I would consider a loan for him for next year.
Bailly is one that slips under the radar. He stays simply by virtue of the fact that he’s marginally better than Jones and Rojo, Tuanzebe is permacrocked and unproven, and Smalling wants away if he isn’t First choice. We can’t shift five CBs out in one summer, so Bailly stays as fourth choice behind Maguire, Lindelof, and new CB. But long term I have serious doubts he’s good enough.