How many chances do you give a player to show he's up to it?
Smalling: signed in 2010 & has never looked a United-standard CB. Fergie rarely played him there (obviously from assessing him from training sessions) & he signed him as the long-term successor to Rio. He's a poor man's Varane.
Jones: signed in 2011 & is famous for the kites he pulls & his injuries due to diving into stupid challenges - not his footballing ability.
I'm at a loss, as to why folk still maintain that our players are better or as good as our rivals. Performances tell the true story & its rediculous to claim our players are all top 4 standard - when they're not.
He already declined in last season and at times it was painful to watch him.
Spot on. Easy to say he never had pace to begin with but in truth he's still lost another yard or two which has killed him, he looks really shaky any time someone takes him on. Forces him into hacking them down because he knows if it's past him he's not getting back in time.
Had a great season last year. Probably better than Hummels who was in and out through injury, which is why I can't see them letting the Greek go. Ginter is decent cover but I'm not sure how Subotic has recovered.Is he any good? Weird that I don't think I've heard of him.
Is he any good? Weird that I don't think I've heard of him.
Means very little IMO.
Had a couple of good seasons with Werder Bremen, have struggled with injuries during his time at Dortmund.
Most likely reactions to the Xabi Alonso sale.
If clubs like Spurs and Everton want Welbs i suggest we take them for every penny they have, much like they've done to us over the years
With all the speculation regarding midfield (Vidal, Carvalho, Blind, De Jong) there doesn't seem to be anything about another defender, which we could do with strengthening too. Perhaps there is something going on under the radar to resolve this issue?
Indeed. Would be crazy.Why would we loan him to Spuds ? That would be stupid.
I'm sorry, but
Would rather loan than sell.Why would we loan him to Spuds ? That would be stupid.
How many chances do you give a player to show he's up to it?
Smalling: signed in 2010 & has never looked a United-standard CB. Fergie rarely played him there (obviously from assessing him from training sessions) & he signed him as the long-term successor to Rio. He's a poor man's Varane.
Jones: signed in 2011 & is famous for the kites he pulls & his injuries due to diving into stupid challenges - not his footballing ability.
I'm at a loss, as to why folk still maintain that our players are better or as good as our rivals. Performances tell the true story & its rediculous to claim our players are all top 4 standard - when they're not.
Please take these discussions elsewhere. If I want daft opinions, I'll search out the relevant thread.I'm with you here. I'd add Evans to the equation too, seems to have gone backwards. Thought he'd kick on and command a CB place after the great spell he had with Rio when we kept 14 clean sheets. Watching him against MK dons and in preseason he looks terrible, nothing to do with this new formation just due to the fact he cannot pass, players get past him with ease and he hardly dominates his box aerially. We are blessed with three average CBs. I actually think despite his naivety Blackett looks a better player and defender than any of these three.
Please take these discussions elsewhere. If I want daft opinions, I'll search out the relevant thread.
A lot of chatter on Twitter about Villa and Cleverly, probably bollocks - surely we need to add to our midfield?!
We need to add quality. Not much point having Cleverly sitting on the bench if the manager doesn't think he's up to the job of coming on as a sub.A lot of chatter on Twitter about Villa and Cleverly, probably bollocks - surely we need to add to our midfield?!
A lot of chatter on Twitter about Villa and Cleverly, probably bollocks - surely we need to add to our midfield?!