Personally, As a Bayern fan I could NEVER going to wax lyrical about him, regardless. . Not after the shambles of a league title defence whilst stacked and getting out of the German cup off a defeat by actual amateurs. Not withstanding his conflict with certain key players & bafflling ostracisng if a taoent like Zaragoza. I'm baffled how folks in here think someone with that level of failures with such a stacked Bayern could fair well with what's going on at United.
Thoughts on Tuchel as a potential United manager?
- Thread starter sullydnl
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
I never said he is the best thing since slice bread, nobody has. He’s a very good manager that is far more proven than Ten Hag; both in Europe and domestically. Defending away against Real Madrid with a slim lead in the final 15 minutes isn’t a worry, it’s common sense. He set them up to compete which they did well, but for some better passing in the final third they could have scored a couple more goals. The competition is very relevant, and the comparison of a cup match against a ‘decent prem team’ compared to Real Madrid is very funny. Let’s remember Tuchel got to multiple domestic finals with Chelsea.
Chelsea's sloppy seconds FC, pretty uninspiring choice
My major problem with him and Conte as well. They seem to have far too many public fallouts with players and managements. If we do get him its going to blow up spectacularly in our faces
Never thought I would defend a German so vehemently but harsh to blame him on Leverkusen having a freak season,unexpected cup defeats can happen just look at us losing to the likes of Southend,Coventry,MK Dons in the League Cup. Yet again that conflict with players and management is rearing it's ugly head. Maybe we should ask the Chelsea fans in here about their experience.
Oh who do you want then,give up with people sticking the boot in on every choice put forward. I mean it's going so well at the moment isn't it yet constantly turning our noses up
Multiple cup finals… so exactly like Ten Hag then.
Ah well, I guess this is what it’s all about anyway. Opinions.
But think I take the intel off the Bayern fan above who has watched them all season.
And who makes a very good point about their stacked squad in that league.
If Alonso and tuchel swapped jobs at the beginning of the season, I think it’s pretty safe bet that Leverkusen wouldn’t be champions right now!
Someone that hasn't been sacked off by Chelsea would be a great start.
People are desperate
Guess we'll have to cross Ancelotti off the list if he ever becomes available then
Ah yes well done on bringing that point up
He's not our manager for 10 years but his adaptability is perfect for a transitional period with an owner that cannot overhaul the squad in 1 window.
How difficult is this to understand.
The Southgate comparisons are criminal though.
He was sacked by Chelsea due to clueless Boehly and him clashing,think you will find Chelsea fans would take him back in a heartbeat given the chance
Well if ten Hag and Tuchel both pick fights with their best players... Then that leaves only Southgate.
Graham Potter let's goo!
Graham Potter let's goo!
Jeez what a depressing choice that is
I knew there was something off about you.
Graham Potter? Ah yes he really turned that Chelsea team around!!
Yeah was the exact point I made earlier, oh Tuchel why did you have to give those doubters in our fanbase ammunition. You could have silenced a few of them if hadn't made a defensive change when leading. Will never hear the end of it from our media for the next few days too which is annoying.
Iraola for me.
You can't get lucky over an entire season. XG doesn't mean anything. Teams over and under perform it all the time.
The winning manager in that game was Chelseas "sloppy seconds". They're unmanageable right now.
Like Ole? Like Ten hag? Or like Southgate? Atleast try to be sincere when making an argument.
Some will take any pot shots at him no matter whether other managers have lost big games from winning situations too
Whoa! So all these years you are living a privileged life here pretending to be a united fan and now this? Or am I the only one who wasn’t aware of your actual identity? If not then you deserve Orc treatment.
Plenty of our fans make ridiculous arguments about managers to discredit them. I don't know why.
You also didn’t know and thought he/she was a united fan like me?
I had Tuchel and Potter in mind, managers that we're currently linked with.. I'm just against the idea of hiring managers that have been sacked from rival clubs, Ancelotti is probably the only exception as he's an all time great.
Ruben Amorim, Kieran McKenna, Iraola, I'd honestly get more excited us hiring Carrick over Tuchel. Tuchel is just a boring choice.
If he comes here… let’s see how he handles 11 players making crucial mistakes like Neuer did.. on a weekly basis… against shite teams. He better get rid of that comb-over already because those last precious hairs are for sure not surviving the stress of being a United manager.
Oh sure, sure...
I mean he's only won 1x German league, 1x German Cup, 2x French league, 1x French Cup, 1x French League Cup, 2x French Supercup, 1x Champions League, 1x Club World Cup, 1x Supercup.
But what has he done lately to prove that he could be the manager of our shambles of a club??
Amiright??
I really don’t think Ineos will go for him and I don’t blame them. He has history of falling out with higher ups and they’re definitely going to want to avoid that on their very first appointment. Southgate sounds far safer for them.
Just say the Champions League, it's quicker and has exactly the same level of impact.
I don't think Tuchel would have the patience to work with a club that will clearly need 2,3 years to start competing.
McKenna, Carrick already? Come on, it’s not the time. After 3-4 years, yeah maybe if they have shown enough. Iraola, I’m not sold at all. Amorim is an interesting choice. A young hungry manager with a winning pedigree with non favourites.
Exactly why I feel he could be a good fit,I have always said he's not a long term manager but can get us back into Champions League. We could then go all in for an Alonso/Nagelsmann/Flick/Amorim type IF any of those are available in a couple of seasons
Yeah I keep seeing this pop up again and again. Are people trying to will this into existence or something?
ETH would've still be my preferred choice going into next season if he didn't piss his chance up the wall with his fecking oddball tactics.
Ancelloti.was sacked off by Chelsea too. Managers get sacked.
Ever thought he falls out because they have the wrong higher ups making those decisions in first place