O
Not listened to Katatonia since... Christ.. Viva Emptiness. Should probably check this out.
Also of note this year I quite enjoyed the Ashen album, good bit of riff-oriented death metal. And also the album from The Privateer was quite fun.
I'd suggest giving The Fall of Hearts a try first. That's the go-to album, when it comes to their latest transformation as a band, and, imho, one of the highlights of their entire career. Too many nice influences in it, from some doomy stuff and Paradise Lost to prog metal and Steven Wilson, Depeche Mode and even alt-rock. The last two albums have been written solely by Renkse because Nystrom has apparently lost his inspiration, and it kind of shows... Still a great band, though.
The Ashen, for me, falls into the "good at first, but with little staying power" category. I blame the heavy dose of death and black metal i was raised on as a 90s metalhead, he-he. The Privateer was a cool record, indeed. Very fun, they make good use of the subgenre's tropes, and most of their choices actually serve the songs (they're not being used for the sake of it). The brutal vocals reminded me of Angela Gosow.
Since we're talking about legacy bands from the 90s, Immolation's Acts of God was terrific. Hell, even the last one from Fear Factory managed to find the sweet spot between their narrow range of riffs and electronics this time.
What i've heard of this last album sounds better than most of their later albums, so they're going in the right direction at least.
But i guess i forgot the elitism in the metal community, so it was silly of me to think you would like some new stuff that doesn't sound like they did in the 90s.
Siren Charms and Battles are the equivalent of Michael Bay films: Content that barely passes for music simply because they have musical instruments in them and a guy trying to sing, aimed for an audience of 14-15 year-olds.
I will agree that Reroute, Soundtrack and Come Clarity don't deserve the stick they get. I can understand why this is happening, but IF have always been the most "accessible" among the bands that began their careers in the early 90s. Even when they were still playing 100% metal. They always had that in their sound.
The other post-Clayman albums are run-of-the-mill records. It's not elitism to suggest that bands like Dark Tranquillity have matured way better than them. And since someone mentioned Soilwork, Overgivenheten, with its super mellow sound, the folk and acoustic elements and keys, is a far more honest nod to the sound IF helped create back in the day without hiding its intention to be commercial and radio friendly. You don't have to sound like Skillet to be able to tour in the US.