It does say 'optimistic', but for comparisons sake, there's a player at the club bottom of the league who got a +4 from 78 to 82 and he had played 558 minutes in the league this season. Disasi has played almost 3x the number of minutes and is at a club 11th in the league (was 2nd a few weeks ago). If his rise is the same, or lower, than the player who went to 82, it is a disgrace.
Gaming The SM RedCafe League
- Thread starter Damien
- Start date
No mean feat to play 100% of minutes in a top 5 league at a club in midtable.
They're mid table and Ligue 1 tends to be rated less favourably. At least I always get stung badly with Ligue 1 players even if they're playing constantly.
Kelvin Amian for Toulouse has played 9,068 minutes in Ligue 1 and he's only 86 rated.
Axel Disasi has played only 1,507 minutes in Ligue 1 and you think he'll be 84? Mental. Maybe if he was at a top, top club.
I think it would be weird if he didn't get 83, yes.
I've been the same, but with respect to a rise to Disasi I'm comparing with Bafode Diakite. Before the review started I was thinking 82, but with Diakite getting 82 having played far fewer minutes at a club that is doing much worse, he should be higher. Should and will are another matter, I expect he'll probably get 82 as I get screwed over on this kind of thing.
Toulouse often gets decent rating increases for their teenagers. He's also only 18 and they tend to like to throw ratings at very young players. If Disasi was a teenager then he'd probably get a +5 as he'd have the hype boost. Guarantee he won't get +6. If he does, all it does is confirm that you're on the rating panel and fix the game.
I've not said he will. It is an optimistic prediction ffs
Can't believe you think he'll get a +6, jeez.
Can I just point out is taken over 1600 minutes of football for bafode to get this rise which is pretty similar to disasi amount of football since his last rise.
Looking at when you bought him, the first 932 minutes would have been factored into his rating at the time he was added.
Only got one Ligue 1 player, hoping for a nice +3 to 76 for Elie Youan.
Ikone 87 +4 = 91
Maxime Lopez 88 +4 =92
Strootman 90 no change please god
Di Maria 92 no change please god
Tiago djalo 73 +15 = 88
Yacinr adli 80 +3 = 83
Maxime Lopez 88 +4 =92
Strootman 90 no change please god
Di Maria 92 no change please god
Tiago djalo 73 +15 = 88
Yacinr adli 80 +3 = 83
- Joined
- Sep 1, 2015
- Messages
- 18,529
- Supports
️
Celik +1
Aouar Stay
Tchouameni +2
Aouar Stay
Tchouameni +2
Martinez Quarta gets a plus 4.
A move to Europe next please.
A move to Europe next please.
3:0 win at home to Leeds United. My winning run will come to an end at Forest.
Subs: Ramos (95)↑, Boateng (92), Alaba (93), Pogba (93), Eriksen (94)↑, Sterling (94)↑, Mbappe (94)
Did not travel: Dele (92), Retsos (87), Berge (87), Vinicius Jr (87)
Key:
= Goal
= Assist
= MOTM
↓ = Subbed off
↑ = Subbed on
Next three games:
MD05: Nottingham Forest (A)
SSGAG3: Eintracht Frankfurt (H)
LCR1: Burnley (H)
De Gea (95)
Christensen (90)↓ Stones (91) Kimmich (93) Gaya (91)
Brandt (90)↓ Kovacic (91)
-- Sancho (90)↓ -- Kroos (95) -- Goretzka (91)
Griezmann (95)
Christensen (90)↓ Stones (91) Kimmich (93) Gaya (91)
Brandt (90)
↓ Kovacic (91)-- Sancho (90)
↓ -- Kroos (95) -- Goretzka (91)Griezmann (95)
Subs: Ramos (95)↑, Boateng (92), Alaba (93), Pogba (93), Eriksen (94)↑, Sterling (94)↑, Mbappe (94)
Did not travel: Dele (92), Retsos (87), Berge (87), Vinicius Jr (87)
Key:
= Goal = Assist = MOTM↓ = Subbed off
↑ = Subbed on
Next three games:
MD05: Nottingham Forest (A)
SSGAG3: Eintracht Frankfurt (H)
LCR1: Burnley (H)
Season 15/16
Season 16/17
Season 17/18
Season 18/19
Week 1-10
Week 11
Week 12
Week 13
Week 14
¦
8.48 - Mohammed Ihattaren (17/82) ¦ 90mins
8.42 - Krzysztof Piatek (24/90) ¦ 90mins
7.90 - Dayot Upamecano (20/89) ¦ 90mins
7.70 - Joe Gomez (22/89) ¦ 90mins
7.63 - Rodrigo Bentancur (22/90) ¦ 41mins
7.60 - Dan-Axel Zagadou (20/86) ¦ 90mins
7.42 - Wilfred Ndidi (22/90) ¦ 90mins
7.41 - Kai Havertz (20/90) ¦ 71mins
7.37 - Alphonso Davies (19/83) ¦ 90mins
7.26 - Gaetano Castrovilli (22/82) ¦ 90mins
7.22 - Emerson (20/83) ¦ 90mins
7.17 - Domagoj Bradaric (20/83) ¦ 90mins
7.07 - Sandro Tonali (19/85) ¦ 90mins
6.98 - Santiago Arias (27/89) ¦ 80mins
6.91 - Lucas Torreira (23/90) ¦ 90mins
6.87 - Yeray Alvarez (24/89) ¦ 90mins
6.80 - Federico Valverde (21/86) ¦ 90mins
6.76 - Andy Robertson (25/92) ¦ 76mins
6.71 - Matvey Safonov (20/80) ¦ 90mins
6.64 - Gianluigi Donnarumma (20/90) ¦ 90mins
6.62 - Lys Mousset (23/83) ¦ 65mins
6.56 - Edin Dzeko (33/92) ¦ 22mins
6.29 - Karim Bellarabi (29/89) ¦ 79mins
6.26 - Matthijs de Ligt (20/91) ¦ 90mins
6.13 - Moussa Diaby (20/85) ¦ 30mins
6.07 - Kwadwo Asamoah (30/90) ¦ 18mins
6.02 - Hannes Wolf (20/86) ¦ 5mins
n/a - Bruno Petkovic (25/86) ¦ 90mins
n/a - Nikola Moro (21/85) ¦ 90mins
n/a - Riqui Puig (20/82) ¦ 90mins
n/a - Bosko Sutalo (19/80) ¦ 90mins
n/a - Lenny Pintor (19/80) ¦ 6mins
n/a - Adam Hlozek (17/80) ¦ 90mins
n/a - Ryan Gravenberch (17/78) ¦ 90mins
n/a - Davide Bettella (19/73) ¦ 90mins
n/a - Jurrien Timber (18/73) ¦ 90mins
Didn't Play:
Bench
Serge Gnabry (24/91)
Matteo Politano (26/90)
Moise Kean (19/87)
Alessandro Bastoni (20/83)
Correa Lincoln (18/82)
U21
Oumar Solet (19/78)
Mitchel Bakker (19/76)
Loic Mbe Soh (18/76)
Alanzinho (19/75)
Alessandro Cortinovis (18/70)
Brandon Soppy (17/70)
Not in the squad
Mohamed Daramy (17/76)
Daishawn Redan (18/73)
Injured
Ousmane Dembele (22/91)
William Saliba (18/82)
Suspended
No Match
Matias Arezo (17/65)
Summary:
Players: 51
Played Ratio: 71%
Average Mins: 76mins
Average Rating: 7.05
Goals: 2
Assists: 3
Yellows: 3
Reds: 0
Season 16/17
Season 17/18
Season 18/19
Week 1-10
Week 11
Week 12
Week 13
Week 14
8.48 - Mohammed Ihattaren (17/82) ¦ 90mins
8.42 - Krzysztof Piatek (24/90) ¦ 90mins 7.90 - Dayot Upamecano (20/89) ¦ 90mins
7.70 - Joe Gomez (22/89) ¦ 90mins
7.63 - Rodrigo Bentancur (22/90) ¦ 41mins
7.60 - Dan-Axel Zagadou (20/86) ¦ 90mins
7.42 - Wilfred Ndidi (22/90) ¦ 90mins
7.41 - Kai Havertz (20/90) ¦ 71mins
7.37 - Alphonso Davies (19/83) ¦ 90mins
7.26 - Gaetano Castrovilli (22/82) ¦ 90mins
7.22 - Emerson (20/83) ¦ 90mins
7.17 - Domagoj Bradaric (20/83) ¦ 90mins
7.07 - Sandro Tonali (19/85) ¦ 90mins
6.98 - Santiago Arias (27/89) ¦ 80mins
6.91 - Lucas Torreira (23/90) ¦ 90mins
6.87 - Yeray Alvarez (24/89) ¦ 90mins
6.80 - Federico Valverde (21/86) ¦ 90mins
6.76 - Andy Robertson (25/92) ¦ 76mins
6.71 - Matvey Safonov (20/80) ¦ 90mins
6.64 - Gianluigi Donnarumma (20/90) ¦ 90mins
6.62 - Lys Mousset (23/83) ¦ 65mins
6.56 - Edin Dzeko (33/92) ¦ 22mins
6.29 - Karim Bellarabi (29/89) ¦ 79mins
6.26 - Matthijs de Ligt (20/91) ¦ 90mins
6.13 - Moussa Diaby (20/85) ¦ 30mins
6.07 - Kwadwo Asamoah (30/90) ¦ 18mins
6.02 - Hannes Wolf (20/86) ¦ 5mins
n/a - Bruno Petkovic (25/86) ¦ 90mins
n/a - Nikola Moro (21/85) ¦ 90mins
n/a - Riqui Puig (20/82) ¦ 90mins
n/a - Bosko Sutalo (19/80) ¦ 90mins
n/a - Lenny Pintor (19/80) ¦ 6mins
n/a - Adam Hlozek (17/80) ¦ 90mins
n/a - Ryan Gravenberch (17/78) ¦ 90mins
n/a - Davide Bettella (19/73) ¦ 90mins
n/a - Jurrien Timber (18/73) ¦ 90mins
Didn't Play:
Bench
Serge Gnabry (24/91)
Matteo Politano (26/90)
Moise Kean (19/87)
Alessandro Bastoni (20/83)
Correa Lincoln (18/82)
U21
Oumar Solet (19/78)
Mitchel Bakker (19/76)
Loic Mbe Soh (18/76)
Alanzinho (19/75)
Alessandro Cortinovis (18/70)
Brandon Soppy (17/70)
Not in the squad
Mohamed Daramy (17/76)
Daishawn Redan (18/73)
Injured
Ousmane Dembele (22/91)
William Saliba (18/82)
Suspended
No Match
Matias Arezo (17/65)
Summary:
Players: 51
Played Ratio: 71%
Average Mins: 76mins
Average Rating: 7.05
Goals: 2
Assists: 3
Yellows: 3
Reds: 0
Last edited:
Ratings are bonkers, Badiashile only gets a +1?
Sadly it depends also on how well the rest of team does
Am fully prepared that Tonali will not get any rise this time round
I forgot Foster existed. Guess I also thought he'd be reviewed with Belgium... yeah, that is my excuse.
Fair enough, but he should be a 85 atleast!
FFP Bans
Dans breaking it by doing a deal with Dutza and signing Thomas DELANEY.
Sigh.
- Dans - Turn 28 of Season 19 to Turn 28 of Season 20 - 2nd violation
- dutza - 4th November 2019 to 4th December 2019 - 1st violation
Dans breaking it by doing a deal with Dutza and signing Thomas DELANEY.
Sigh.
I really wanted Alvarez too, didn't sign anyone for weeks waiting for his TB to end 
I really wanted Alvarez too, didn't sign anyone for weeks waiting for his TB to end
How many bid on him? We could order him to sell the player once his TB expires.
For dutza's case:
He managed to sell a player in less than a week, so he was not banned
OP needs to be updated though
He managed to sell a player in less than a week, so he was not banned
OP needs to be updated though
I think there were 2 or 3 more. But greeny said he's OK.
Ah ok, was looking at the OP. In that case its just Dan who's tripped up... again. I'd say reverse that transfer when TBs expire but that's a while a way. Mmm.
I like the idea of reversing transfers though, maybe should look into it, would serve as a further deterrent.
- Joined
- Sep 1, 2015
- Messages
- 18,529
- Supports
- ️
I bid on him and genuinely am annoyed that someone who has a TB has got him.
See above, he wasn't TB'd Damien didn't update the opening post was all.
Harsh punishment for a stupid oversight. Given dutza was also banned why not simply reverse the transfer and carry on. Not sure if i will not get a bit fed up and give up if i can't sign any players for this long.
I wasn’t banned. I sold a player in order to don’t get banned. I don’t get it how you guys can t keep count of your players and get banned..... just check before you bid on a player, if u know u ve reached the limit or u re around the limit. Or if u re banned just wait till the ban expires and then do any transfers.... it s so simple
If you were not banned then fair dos - all my fault I agree. I completely forgot I was banned when accepting. You made the bid and I left it up for days and then decided finally that it was an ok swap, of DRs! Doh.
No rise for N'Soki
No rise for Mbuku
Gnagnon with a -1
Pricks.
No rise for Mbuku
Gnagnon with a -1
Pricks.
I don't get the Gnagnon drop.
Well, Rennes are midtable and SM always tend to punish players at midtable for some reason. Mukiele will hopefully rise and take his spot as cover so not a huge issue for me ultimately.
N'Soki not rising is annoying though, he's played enough minutes to warrant a +1 to 83 ffs.
@The Taurean a few days ago "Lewandowski will definitely be out."
Lost 2:1 with Forest starting Lewandowski. Would say it was a deserved loss, but look at the stats (I'm away). Congrats.
Subs: Stones (91), Boateng (92)↑, Gaya (91)↑, Pogba (93)↑, Kovacic (91), Brandt (90), Sancho (90)
Did not travel: Goretzka (91), Retsos (87), Berge (87), Vinicius Jr (87)
Key:
= Goal
= Assist
= MOTM
↓ = Subbed off
↑ = Subbed on
Next three games:
SSGAG3: Eintracht Frankfurt (H)
LCR1: Burnley (H)
MD06: Newcastle United (H)
Lost 2:1 with Forest starting Lewandowski. Would say it was a deserved loss, but look at the stats (I'm away). Congrats.
De Gea (95)
Christensen (90)↓ Ramos (95) Kimmich (93) Alaba (93)↓
Eriksen (94) Kroos (95)
Mbappe (94) -- Dele (92)↓-- Sterling (94)
Griezmann (95)
Christensen (90)↓ Ramos (95) Kimmich (93) Alaba (93)↓
Eriksen (94) Kroos (95)
Mbappe (94) -- Dele (92)↓-- Sterling (94)
Griezmann (95)
Subs: Stones (91), Boateng (92)↑, Gaya (91)↑, Pogba (93)↑, Kovacic (91), Brandt (90), Sancho (90)
Did not travel: Goretzka (91), Retsos (87), Berge (87), Vinicius Jr (87)
Key:
= Goal = Assist = MOTM↓ = Subbed off
↑ = Subbed on
Next three games:
SSGAG3: Eintracht Frankfurt (H)
LCR1: Burnley (H)
MD06: Newcastle United (H)
Everton Ligue 1 predictions
Thiago Silva (35/92) no change
Presnele Kimpembe (24/90) +1
Layvin Kurzawa (27/90) no change
Juan Bernat (26/89) +1
Neymar (27/96) no change
Sofiane Alakouche (21/85) no change
Thiago Silva (35/92) no change
Presnele Kimpembe (24/90) +1
Layvin Kurzawa (27/90) no change
Juan Bernat (26/89) +1
Neymar (27/96) no change
Sofiane Alakouche (21/85) no change
Manchester United Ligue 1 players
UPMR = United Player Minutes Ranking (out of 42)
CR = Club Ranking in their respective league
Disclaimer: Minutes only take the league into account. A few play in other competitions which might also be taken into account when SM do their ratings.
*hides from a smug RedSky*
Player Name | Age | Rating | Club | Prediction | New Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kylian Mbappe | 20 | 94 | Paris Saint-Germain | No Change | No Change |
Malang Sarr | 20 | 87 | Nice | No Change | No Change |
Dario Maresic | 20 | 83 | Reims | No Change | No Change |
Jean-Ricner Bellegarde | 21 | 80 | Strasbourg | +2 (82) | +3 (83) |
Hichem Boudaoui | 20 | 80 | Nice | No Change | No Change |
Axel Disasi | 21 | 78 | Reims | +6 (84) | +4 (82) |
Ferhat Cogalan | 17 | 68 | Lille | No Change | No Change |
- Worse than predicted
- Predicted
- Better than predicted
UPMR = United Player Minutes Ranking (out of 42)
CR = Club Ranking in their respective league
Disclaimer: Minutes only take the league into account. A few play in other competitions which might also be taken into account when SM do their ratings.
*hides from a smug RedSky*