The Seven Leading Candidates To Be Old Trafford's Next Number 7 /From Goal.com/

CentreForward

Berba's bitch. A Bulgarian dEvil
Joined
May 18, 2009
Messages
4,948
Location
Chicago
I came across this article on Goal.com. Now, I don't usually read them, but the f*cker tricked me into reading it, with this headline. Anyway...

I like many, find David Silva a very good footballer and a very possible new signing, but something tells me, SAF won't buy big this summer. Everyone else is either too expensive, or too old, or just not what we need. I like Robben too, Joe Cole if for free, but that's about it and I don't think it'll happen. Di Maria, I don't know much about

Manchester United Debate: The Seven Leading Candidates To Be Old Trafford's Next Number 7 - Goal.com
Counting down the best candidates to take United's left wing mantle

By Matt Monaghan
Mar 23, 2010 7:15:36 AM
120
Share

Photo Gallery Zoom
EPL: Cristiano Ronaldo, Manchester United v Stoke City (PA)
Cristiano Ronaldo's exit to Real Madrid has robbed Manchester United of some midfield magic and left seven candidates for his legendary number seven shirt.

Current incumbent Michael Owen is sidelined by injury, while the advancing years of veteran Ryan Giggs has robbed Manchester United of a spell-binding winger.

Press reports have centred on Valencia striker David Villa filling the gap. The vacuum on the left wing is a bigger priority and the spot for the next Old Trafford superstar to emerge from.

While £17 million signing Antonio Valencia has blossomed on the right, a revolving door is spinning on the opposite flank. Nani, Park Ji-Sung and Giggs have all been used without any of them cementing their place.

For Giggs, age has taken away his turbo-boosted turn of speed, while Park has excelled in central midfield and Nani is a natural right-footer.

The 'Welsh wizard' is likely to bring down the curtain on his time at Old Trafford at the end of next season and can now be found in the middle of the pitch. At the top of United's transfer agenda for the summer is the acquisition of a natural left-footed winger happy to hug the touchline.

Goal.com UK studied the seven left-sided wide men in contention to don the mystical number seven jersey and counted them down by suitability...





7) - Joe Cole, 28, Chelsea

Strong favourite, but injury record could make him another Michael Owen


Alex Dimond is the Chelsea correspondent for Goal.com UK and a keen follower of the Premier League.

Why: "Despite being feted as a prodigy from a young age, since joining Chelsea he has always been willing to adapt his natural game. He's now a well-rounded player with a great eye for a defence-splitting pass. He's not naturally left-sided but has played very well there for England. He is good with both feet in close quarters, but his crossing is much stronger with the right foot and he prefers to cut inside rather than head for the byline."

Why not: "Unfortunately this season he has been derailed by a knee injury that kept him out for nine months of 2009. He has struggled for chances under Carlo Ancelotti and consequently his confidence is a little low. Fabio Capello has remarked that Cole "isn't the player I remember" this season, and he will need to put in a few sparkling performances to convince Chelsea (or another big club) he is worth a sizeable contract."

Estimated transfer value: "Out of contract at the end of the season, he'll be available for free if United are to sign him. With the birth of his first child last week, he will likely be looking for long-term security in the summer if he is to move away from London."

Likelihood rating: - Cole has starred in the Premier League for more than a decade, and with budgets tightening at Old Trafford, a move for him would please the money men.

6) - David Silva, 24, Valencia

Lightweight Spaniard has pedigree but is more comfortable in the middle


KS Leong is Goal.com International Spain Editor and a dedicated viewer of all things La Liga.

Why: "David Silva is a brilliant combination of a playmaker and a winger. This is thanks to his vision and ability to thread the most delicate of Xavi-esque passes, as well as his outstanding ball control, pace and trickery which allow him to hug the touchline. His versatility is also one of his key attributes as he can slot in effortlessly on either flank, in the 'hole', or as a second striker. He has an excellent left-foot, whether it's for shooting or crossing - although he prefers to keep things on the ground - and he's also comfortable on the ball with both feet."

Why not: "Silva isn't the biggest or strongest of players physically and he has a tendency to go down quite easily. The pace and direct approach of the English game could also be a problem, as he sometimes lingers on the ball to pick the perfect defence-splitting pass. Communication and language could also be a problem as the highlight of Silva's game is his almost telepathic understanding with his team-mates."

Estimated transfer value: "With a contract that runs until 2013, Silva is currently valued at around £27 million, a very reasonable figure for a versatile attacker who's only 24 years old."

Likelihood rating: - Has impressed Sir Alex Ferguson on international stage, and even though he isn't a natural winger, the manager views him as the answer.

5) - Balazs Dzsudzsak, 23, PSV Eindhoven

Lack of experience holds Hungarian back from the top of the list


Wout Stravers is the editor for Goal.com Netherlands and has followed Balazs Dzsudzsák since he joined PSV in January 2008

Why: "Balazs Dzsudzsak is a great player. Because of his attributes, PSV are still in the race for the Eredivisie title. His biggest quality is his eye for goal. He has scored many times from long range and has a Beckham-like ability to hit free kicks. Dzsudzsak is very fast as well and makes many goals from the left wing. He can pass and shoot with his left and right feet."

Why not: "Problems have started for him after he threatened to leave PSV if the team doesn't qualify for the Champions League football next season. The PSV-fans like him, but he is a controversial player all over the country because of his arrogant attitude. He is a good player but he needs to become calmer. Dzsudzsak could be useful for United but I would advise their scouts to come back next summer when he is more experienced."

Estimated transfer value: "I would estimate Dzsudzsak would cost £12 million. He is still young and yet to prove himself on the international stage."

Likelihood rating: - United are looking for the finished article after experimenting with Nani, and the PSV man doesn't fit this bill.

4) - Franck Ribery, 26, Bayern Munich

Massive price-tag and roaming role hampers Frenchman's suitability


Francois Duchateau of Goal.com Germany is a Bundesliga-expert and as a Dutchman he is a follower of the Eredivisie and Dutch players worldwide.

Why: "Ribery is a creative offensive midfielder who likes to play on the wings. In fact, he has the qualities of a traditional number 10, but doesn't play to his best in the centre. His favourite side is the left, although his right foot is his strongest. His skills with his left are good, but he isn't as two-footed as Robben. When he reaches the base line he loves to give sharp passes into the penalty area or even try to score himself."

Why not: "Especially after injury breaks, Ribery has failed to shine. This season he has been injured quite often and wasn't as important for Munich as he was during the last two seasons when he was outstanding. He also grew up in problematic circumstances, can be a diva and gives provocative interviews when he wants to force things."

Estimated transfer value: "Bayern rejected a £60 million bid from Real Madrid last summer but he is certainly worth less now. I would say £40 million."

Likelihood rating: - Huge price tag and loss of form could put Ferguson off making another approach for the former Marseille man.

3) - Arjen Robben, 26, Bayern Munich

Balsa wood made Dutchman no fit for Ferguson's squad


Francois Duchateau of Goal.com Germany is a Bundesliga expert and as a Dutchman he is a follower of the Eredivisie and Dutch players worldwide. He has watched Robben since he broke through at PSV Eindhoven.

Why: "Robben is a sympathetic guy, no star attitude, not one for scandals or provocative interviews. He is a weapon for every team as a winger. I compare his playing style to Marc Overmars as he is naturally two-footed on the ball, plays in the national team on the left (his original side) and at Bayern on the right side. He has the individual class to decide matches by himself, but also is a team player."

Why not: "A factor against him is his injury record. In Spain they gave him the nickname "Glass Arjen." He compares himself to a Formula One car, if one little detail goes wrong when you're at high-speed, it has a big effect on the car. He is also very happy in Munich and has just welcomed the birth of his second child."

Estimated transfer value: "Robben's value has increased in Munich and I would say he is worth £25 million."

Likelihood rating: - Injury record, suspect temperament and spurning of Ferguson's advances in the past make this a non-starter.

2) - Juan Manuel Vargas, 26, Fiorentina

Emerging Peruvian requires more time to prove left wing credentials



Sergio Chesi has watched Serie A for 15 years and is the Goal.com Italy chief editor.

Why: "Juan Manuel Vargas has matured into one of the most important players for his national and international sides. He has great pace, speed and aggression, but his best asset is his left foot. I believe in this moment he is one of the best left wingers in the world. His shots are always powerful and precise and he is dangerous from free kicks. In Italy, he's very famous also for his dangerous crosses that often create trouble for the opponents' defence."

Why not: "If Sir Alex Ferguson hopes to find a new Roberto Carlos, it's not Vargas. He could be a very offensive full-back but he's very poor when asked to defend. Vargas has also been a great surprise this year as he has moved from defence to attack and has only emerged as a great player this season."

Estimated transfer value: "Some weeks ago rumours about his contract renewal with Fiorentina talked about a release clause fee of £22 million. It's a realistic price for his ability and fact he is 26-years old."

Likelihood rating: - The Peruvian will not have landed on Ferguson's radar even after a stellar first campaign on the left wing.

1) - Angel Di Maria, 22, Benfica

Starring role against Everton proves Argentine international is worth a punt


Luis Mira has watched the Portguese first division for more than 17 years and reports on Spanish and Portuguese clubs for Goal.com.

Why: "Di Maria makes most of his moves with his left foot, is extremely gifted, and even when he cuts inside from the left wing he prefers using it rather than his right foot, which is not nearly as good as the left. His crossing and passing are both very good, but the best thing about him is his technique as he can easily move past defenders and create space in the area. When motivated, he is extremely good and an absolute nightmare for defenders. I don’t recall him ever picking up any serious injury, I would say only a few minor knocks that take a few days at most to recover from."

Why not: "Considering he is one of Benfica’s most attacking players, Di Maria is not great at scoring goals. He has only netted 12 goals in the three years he has been at the Estadio da Luz. When he is given the opportunity from close range he isn't ruthless enough. The worst thing about him is his composure and concentration. If he is not motivated, or if he does not start the game well, he feels such pressure to perform that he can’t deliver."

Estimated transfer value: "He currently has a contract until 2015, with a £35 million clause attached to it, but I would value the transfer at £22-27 million."

Likelihood rating: - Starting spot for Argentina and Europa League dismantling of Everton has Di Maria on Ferguson's shopping list.
 
If Robben keeps wearing his longjohns then I'd love for him to sign up at OT
 
Robben would have been part of the Ronaldo transfer last summer if SAF was interested in him.
 
Nani is our left winger. Valencia is our right. Giggs and Park are our other options on the wings. And collectively they form a pool of wingers that we're lucky to have because they have been better than any other side's pool of wingers.

David Silva, if he's Berbatov's replacement. £27 million and then sticking him in his 3rd best position on the left would be such a waste. Almost like Rooney on the left.

The advantage of Silva over Berbatov would be that he could find a role no matter how we set up for a match, whereas Berbatov only seems to get games against the easy teams when we play 2 up front. He's also much younger and will improve over the years. He's not all that effective considering he's one of the more talented players in europe but that should hopefully improve a lot in the next few seasons. Then again I was hoping it would happen in the last 2... Didnt happen, yet.

The disadvantage would be that Berbatov is more of a goalscorer, and although his finishing is rarely all that great it's still a lot better than Silva's most of the time.

Jovetic and Ozil are just as good options.
 
I wouldnt want anyone but David Silva in that list to wear out coveted number 7 shirt. Vargas? Cole? the Kuszkzkk guy? These guys to wear our number 7? Have the media gone nuts?
 
Robben just moved to Bayern and he is enjoying playing for that club. So I see no reason why he would move unless there is a fallout. Ribery just ended speculation that he will not move to England. So that rules him out too.
 
With Giggs aging i wouldnt mind getting Joe Cole in on a free - he would provide useful backup on the wings and in the middle as well.

Other than that, there is no reason to spend big because as others have said, we have a decent (if not world class) pool of wingers to pick from. Valencia is great - my only wish is that he wasnt quite so one-footed, and Nani/Park/Giggs seem to be able to pen down the left flank between them.

I do feel that there is room for one more versatile player like Joe Cole though - Park and Giggs can both play in the middle, Nani can play on the right. We have good versatility which is why another body in the squad wouldnt necessarily be a problem. The only potential issue i could foresee would be the youngsters such as Obertan, and possibly Tosic/Welbeck not getting as many games.


If we were buying though, I would put Di Maria and Silva at the top of the list, also Robben if he can stay fit.
 
I wouldnt want anyone but David Silva in that list to wear out coveted number 7 shirt. Vargas? Cole? the Kuszkzkk guy? These guys to wear our number 7? Have the media gone nuts?

The whole number 7 thing is ridiculous anyway. Fergie has already guaranteed Owen will be here next season. And considering we got him on a free, he has injury problems and we have him on a pay if you play contract I think its safe to say he wasnt just trying to up his transfer fee for the summer. He'll be here next season and he'll still be our number 7.

And then I'm sure after next season the likes of Valencia, Nani, Anderson and the rest of our current emerging players would be interested in taking the shirt. With enough progress from now until then, one of them will probably get it.
 
How good is David Silva on the left? I've only see him play through the middle so far.
I wouldn't mind Joe Cole on a free and one of Rodwell/Silva. Our squad is fine and big enough though and we have some very promising youngsters coming through the ranks.
 
7. Joe Cole, not happening, and if he did join us he would not get Michael Owens 7.
6. David Silva, great player, don't think we will move for him. If we sign someone like him, he might get the 7 though.
5. Dzsudzsak - He looks very interesting to me. A hell of a shot, and just a simple left winger.
4. Ribery - won't happen
3. Robben - :lol:
2. Juan M. Vargas - never seen us linked to him before now... I'd perfer someone younger.
1. Angel di Maria - My personal favorite option, lets get him. :)

Personally, I am not sure Ferguson would strip Owen of the 7 shirt to any of these. Silva or Ribery perhaps, but I can't see any of those happening..
 
How good is David Silva on the left? I've only see him play through the middle so far.
I wouldn't mind Joe Cole on a free and one of Rodwell/Silva. Our squad is fine and big enough though and we have some very promising youngsters coming through the ranks.

He does the basics well enough. Fulfils the role on the left wing, as long as you dont want someone with chalk on their boots giving you great width because Silva naturally comes 8 yards off the touchline. Imo he's no better than Nani there, but he is left footed. I think the whole idea of playing him on the left is the same as a player like Kieran Richardson. Not his best role. But he's left footed, so we'll stick him on the left. He hasn't played there for a string of games for his club for coming up to 2 seasons now.

Contrary to the paragraph on him in the article, his right foot isnt very good and he doesnt have lots of speed. Quick enough to get away from a player but thats about it. His crossing is average.

I feel he's better suited to a "Ronaldinho" or "Messi" role where he can come inside from the opposite flank so that he can open up spaces to pass the ball.

With him the one truly great thing he has (other than technique) is his passing ability. And he's hit and miss with that in terms of finding his team mate, but he has the vision to open up defences from in the middle. Just not as often as the best players. He'll usually put someone through about once a match and the rest are sideways passes keeping moves going.
 
How good is David Silva on the left? I've only see him play through the middle so far.
I wouldn't mind Joe Cole on a free and one of Rodwell/Silva. Our squad is fine and big enough though and we have some very promising youngsters coming through the ranks.

I actually agree on that. He has not played on the left on a long time, I do believe he played out wide before his injury and Juan Mata replaced him as a winger, right now he is playing a lot as a attacking midfielder.. Quite frankly, if I had to pick between the two I would rather see Juan Mata joining us, we need a pure left winger like Valencia is a pure right winger. Pace, technique and decent crosses you got that, you can be class as a winger.
 
I actually agree on that. He has not played on the left on a long time, I do believe he played out wide before his injury and Juan Mata replaced him as a winger, right now he is playing a lot as a attacking midfielder.. Quite frankly, if I had to pick between the two I would rather see Juan Mata joining us, we need a pure left winger like Valencia is a pure right winger. Pace, technique and decent crosses you got that, you can be class as a winger.

He was playing on the left the season before the injury, he played the supercup games which kick off the 08/09 league season against Madrid in his role just off David Villa and they were frightening with their linkup play in the matches. But then he got injured. And their linkup play has been average since.
 
Neither Joe Cole or Ribery are 'natural left-footers who hug the touchline'.
 
How good is David Silva on the left? I've only see him play through the middle so far.
I wouldn't mind Joe Cole on a free and one of Rodwell/Silva. Our squad is fine and big enough though and we have some very promising youngsters coming through the ranks.

He is a beast on the left. But he can play anywhere in midfield. For Valencia, he plays on the left and the middle and for Spain, he plays on the right. He is really versatile. If we spend 25M on this lad, it will be worth every penny.
 
I actually agree on that. He has not played on the left on a long time, I do believe he played out wide before his injury and Juan Mata replaced him as a winger, right now he is playing a lot as a attacking midfielder.. Quite frankly, if I had to pick between the two I would rather see Juan Mata joining us, we need a pure left winger like Valencia is a pure right winger. Pace, technique and decent crosses you got that, you can be class as a winger.

We dont even get the players we are linked to and you want Mata. Its not like Valencia want to sell him anyway. Silva can play on the left. He is as good as anybody on the left hand side and nowadays we often employ the 4-3-3 formation. Silva will fit into that system like a glove fitting a hand.

Rooney

Silva-------------------------------Valencia​
 
At the top of United's transfer agenda for the summer is the acquisition of a natural left-footed winger happy to hug the touchline.

And restrict the space Evra can attack?
 
We dont even get the players we are linked to and you want Mata. Its not Valencia want to sell him anyway. Silva can play on the left. He is as good as anybody on the left hand side and nowadays we often employ the 4-3-3 formation. Silva will fit into that system like a glove fitting a hand.

Rooney

Silva-------------------------------Valencia​

He's not as good as Mata on the left. And Mata is not as good as Silva behind the striker.
 
To be honest I'd rather see Nani develop than buy any of those players. Him and Valencia on each side has provided us with nice balance of late, and If he keeps up his good form I don't find it necessary that we buy any of those players mentioned.