So I finished
The Evil Within yesterday and here's some thoughts:
- Incredibly lopsided gameplay; it doesn't know whether it wants to be a survival horror or an action horror and it's both, whenever it chooses.
- The story is poorly told and awfully presented with charisma-less characters and not a hint of humour about its self-serious facade.
- The atmosphere is top notch. It's more creepy than scary but the visual design of about 80% of levels and enemies really stands out.
- It's way way way way too long, especially for how hard it is. I dropped the difficulty down about 40% in and it improved my enjoyment tons.
- It's still not easy on casual because there's so many random deaths, many of which feel cheap and annoying.
- Bear traps didn't need to be in the game at all. There's no bears ffs. Acid traps are stupid too.
- The ending is the worst part. The first 4/5 chapters are the best.
- At one point I ragequit and uninstalled it, only to later reinstall it, forcing myself to finish it.
All in all, an
okay but unspectacular game. I just read a review that implied Mikami and his team didn't know what made Resident Evil 4 good and agree.
The sequel - which I played a few years back - is an improvement in every single way except for the atmosphere.
Now I'm playing Halo: ODST which is a markedly more fun game.