Moby
Dick
Will start the game in a few minutes..
Fair enough. Didn't know you we're into Juv and Barca to that extent.
OK, let's start discussing proper stuff. I was discussing with NM whether he should go for a diamond or XMAS tree and he mentioned a hidden gem I assumed to be Kopa. As an inside right alongside Zidane he could have worked and his adaptability at Madrid indicates he wasn't the sort to kick a fuss over a team being built around him.
That said, I wasn't sure about a 30s player in a diamond. Wouldn't it be too alien a formation? Suárez as a DLP wouldn't be doing too much different from what he did at Inter, but upfront it could be a different cup of tea. Thoughts?
I actually wound up suggesting he may be better off with a previously managed player he could play there or in a front two if he went for a diamond. Kalle, obviously.
I'll happily edit the much as it may paint Cafú in a bad light, which is not in any way the intention. The point was that as all-rounders I'd have Carlos Alberto and Zanetti as the most accomplished ones, with one being somewhat better when attacking and the other when defending but not much separating the two other than preference (and what the game requires from them would be relevant, obviously).
The point is purely to provide a helpful benchmark for those familiar with the more recent ones. If you put attacking and defending at the extremes you would order them: Cafú-Carlos Alberto-Zanetti-Thuram. At least I would.
Never got a chance to get back to replying to this 'til now. I do think you're asking a lot of some of the older players to play their best in a completely alien setup but when you're talking about players like Kopa I wouldn't think it's an issue at all. Someone with his kind of comfort in possession, intelligence on the ball and ability to carry the ball can realistically play in any midfield position which doesn't put too much defensive strain on them, I think. Charlton essentially said as much when he was asked about how he found it when he was first asked to play in Ramsey's "wingless wonders". It's much harder to find an older player that would work well in one of the slightly wider roles in midfield though. You could say someone like Duncan Edwards had the skillset to play there but I'd definitely be seeing that as a weakened Edwards.
What about someone like Zito at the base of a diamond? He has the skillset to play there but it's such a distinctly different role to the one he played that I don't think you could pull it off either.
I'd never got that impression but like I said I'd be interested in hearing a bit more on Carlos Alberto defensively. I've heard him being described as having defensive frailties from quite a few sources and I didn't see him as being a level above Cafú defensively at all. All I saw of him was that '70 World Cup though and it was easy to get distracted by Tostão and co. so I'm far from clued up on Carlos Alberto to be honest!
Looks good kps, that defense is incredible and Neeskens-Vieira behind Platini is mouthwatering. Fontaine really does have a superb goal scoring record too, but I still fear he may not be rated as highly as he probably should.
Thanks. Should be a tough one against the Stobster, fear not many voters will look past his front three!
Thanks. Should be a tough one against the Stobster, fear not many voters will look past his front three!
Excellent!
Corrected, thought you'd be a good barometer for the accuracy of my South American research.That's a cracking side Gio. Just one correction: sasia wasn't a leftback but a forward. I wouldn't be surprised about him knocking his teeth off!
Quality write up Gio. Looking forward to our battle on Tuesday
Is it Jayvin that has Best and Giggs? Imagine the carnage they would cause in this match.
Agree on Jayvin, he has an awesome side and for me its him and Cutch as the standouts at the first round
Not that we disagree. I have it 1. EDogen, 2. Jayvin, 3. Cutch.
If they go through those are the three draws I wouldn't want next.
I mentioned during the drafting the sides without proper fulbacks could really suffer!
Jayvin has a top side. EDogen would at present be my frontrunner, but that would entail Brwned going out and freeing up Edwards and Charlton for Jayvin, who has been careful to plan for it with his 30s picks. All bets are off then with the Trinity back together again + Edwards, Giggs...
Nice team mate, strange you never got talked when talking of teams with great wings. Yours is my favourite wing combo in the draft, absolutely deadly.
Corrected, thought you'd be a good barometer for the accuracy of my South American research.