The music of Manchester

Manchester......

Greatest place on earth

a passion and emotion to rival any city in the world. a city of culture, a city of rivalry, a city of great music, a great football club, a great race of people

anyone who lives there, you dunno how lucky you are.....Manchester is the greatest place on earth to me.....a second home.....love it

anyways yeah music, smiths, oasis, stone roses etc etc, had status quo record a single for united.....magic!!
 
Manchester......

Greatest place on earth

a passion and emotion to rival any city in the world. a city of culture, a city of rivalry, a city of great music, a great football club, a great race of people

anyone who lives there, you dunno how lucky you are.....Manchester is the greatest place on earth to me.....a second home.....love it

anyways yeah music, smiths, oasis, stone roses etc etc, had status quo record a single for united.....magic!!


Points for this man please ! A sensible soul in a time of quandary.
 
best city in the world for music, always make laugh when livepool try to compare them selves with us..............
 
Some of you for some reason forget the older stuff that was produced around the time that Liverpool claimed to be the music capital of the world, yet really wasn't.



My mother knew Allan Clarke, she went to school with him.



Peter Noone I've sure she shagged on several occasions.
 
the first time i've been to manchester i met a chap and these were his first words..
"Rule number 1: you're not in england..you're in Manchester
Rule number 2: we don't speak english..we speak Manchester"

the people in Manchester are very proud of their identity..and they should be.. they're the best in the things that matter most..football and music..
 
the first time i've been to manchester i met a chap and these were his first words..
"Rule number 1: you're not in england..you're in Manchester
Rule number 2: we don't speak english..we speak Mancunian"

the people in Manchester are very proud of their identity..and they should be.. they're the best in the things that matter most..football and music..

Fixed ;)
 
if I'm honest, it's the music of Manchester that brought me to United in the first place.
 
if I'm honest, of all the bands mentioned in this thread I quite like two (Buzzcocks and The Smiths), the rest I really couldn't care less about.
 
if I'm honest, of all the bands mentioned in this thread I quite like two (Buzzcocks and The Smiths), the rest I really couldn't care less about.

Blasphemer!

There is something weird about this thread
 
Manchester bands that are shit:

Doves
Puressence
Simply Red
James
M People
Oceansize

There are lots more too. We've produced some great bands up here, by=ut we've unleashed an awful lot of crap too.

Edit: How did I forget Oasis?
 
Can't agree with you there...

Doves first album was very good, not too fussed about the stuff after that.

James have some worthy tracks - enough to make a decent greatest hits CD - maybe not any great album though.

I even like this Puressence track - I think that might be the only one from them though!


and I dont care what anyone says, Oasis were quality once upon a time
 
I just can't stand Tim Booth. Hate his songs, his voice, everything about him.

Doves songs all sound exactly the same. Jimmy whatsit can't hold a tune to save his life either.

Oasis had one decent album that was a derivitive tribute album to two or three good bands that were around 30 years earlier and have plowed the same field over and over to lesser effect ever since.
 
I was going to post something else about not liking many Manchester bands, but realised Last.FM can do it for me;

secondfig.png-list


I basically listen to American artists/bands, with a small bunch of British and Canadian bands filling in the gaps.
 
I just can't stand Tim Booth. Hate his songs, his voice, everything about him.

Doves songs all sound exactly the same. Jimmy whatsit can't hold a tune to save his life either.

Oasis had one decent album that was a derivitive tribute album to two or three good bands that were around 30 years earlier and have plowed the same field over and over to lesser effect ever since.

fair enough on Booth - sounds similar to my hatred of all things Morrisey!

I still listen to Lost Souls quite often - ditto Def Maybe and even Morning Glory from time to time.
I dont think anyone will claim there is much original about Oasis but I think the same can be said of a lot of rock music.

Anyway I've always felt a bit protective of Manchester music heritage - happy to admit I probably over rate some of our bands!



I basically listen to American artists/bands, with a small bunch of British and Canadian bands filling in the gaps.

So you are a traitor and a blasphemer ;)
 
To the ones that don't rate James

feck the lot of you. Awesome band, excellent live. Pre-Goldmother they were even better and more diverse.





 
Gonna go see James next Thursday Dave, lookin forward to it. Used to love watchin Tim Booth dance and then he had that car accident and had to stop his flailin. Manchester was buzzin for me right around the release of Gold mother and that show at the gmex. They were an integral part of the movement in the 90s.
 
Charlatans.jpg

I went and saw the Charlatans the other night here in Ga on the first date of their U.S tour.They're touring their latest album "Who we Touch". I have to say Im an avid Charlies fan and really enjoy a great chunk out of every album they present. They always seem to adapt a definitive change of direction on every album. This albums is a cracka ! Got some soul tunes and some quality organ grinders.

 
Looking at the list of bands from Manchester on Wikipedia, none of them are brilliant.

and Oasis being there just makes it worse.

Edit: Disregard that. I just saw The Smiths. Manchester wins, I'm an idiot etc.

:lol: The fact the Smiths didn't spring to mind just shows how clueless you are on the subject..

Let me guess.. You're a Queen fan?
 
Bands worth a mention:

The Smiths
The Stone Roses
Oasis
Joy Division
New Order
Doves
Elbow
Buzzcocks
Chameleons
Happy Mondays
John Cooper Clarke (not a band but worth a mention)

Extend this subject to the North west and you can include the staggering list of Liverpudlian and other North-west bands.

The area is the the greatest producer of musical talent in the world and has shaped the culture of English clothes, music and football for generations..
 
feck the lot of you. Awesome band, excellent live. Pre-Goldmother they were even better and more diverse.







Good choice, I'm just hoping to talk Tim into playing Skullduggery live again at some point. James have if anything come back better live since they reformed, and once again are prepared to improvise which was what they did best back in the late 80's early 90's. I'm off to see them later in the year once more, as I saw them earlier this year a few times.
 
To you perhaps but not to many.

They're hated by most people in Manchester that aren't students or fourteen years old.

Their second album's as dire a second album i've heard by any big british band in decades and word has it they've only sold 7000 tickets for their big December homecoming gig.

I refuse to mention them in the same breath as the likes of Joy division or the Smiths. It would be criminal.